The Nova Scotia PNP has been popular recently because they opened a new stream called Regional Labor Market Demand (RLMD) in March 2014 which had NOCs listed that were not available in FSWP 2013. This new stream did not require a job offer and had similar requirements as the FSWP with a few additional informational requirements, such as documenting a Settlement Plan. As such, many people applied or were preparing to apply, especially as there was the general feeling that FSWP 2014 would not have been available prior to Express Entry in January 2015.
I also was considering applying as my NOC became available and I had started researching information about it. However, I had faith and hoped that FSWP would reopen in 2014 with my NOC and decided to take the "wait and see" approach while at the same time attempting to get some of the more time consuming application tasks out of the way (IELTS/WES). Thankfully, that approach paid off.
Three things effectively turned me off from the NSNP (RMLD):
- The program is essentially a mini version of the coming express entry, meaning that the power to choose was not in your own hands. Even after you sent a complete application package, Nova Scotia would be the one to decide who would be nominated to apply for PR, and there were only 150 spots available, not per NOC, but for the entire stream - out of thousands of applications which would invariably be sent. Didn't particularly like those odds.
- The Settlement Plan was effectively a glorified essay as to why Nova Scotia should select you as one of its 150 nominees and how your previous experience and knowledge would prepare you to settle within the province. As much as I can be good at writing essays if I put my mind to the task, I don't particularly enjoy this and avoid them at all costs where possible .
- If selected as a nominee, you still would have to go through a similar federal application process, which could take up to a year, in addition to the approximately six months it would take to get a decision on whether or not you have been selected as a provincial nominee. Added to the fact that to become a provincial nominee you were required to "demonstrate intent to live in Nova Scotia permanently", if you became a nominee, at the very least you had to attempt to settle down in the province before moving elsewhere. This became the last straw. My preference would be to start in Toronto as I have "family" there who could ease the transition process of essentially restarting one's life if the PR application is successful.