H&C Humanitarian Ground with/or Without Failed refugee claim

[casirat]

Hi

How long you been in Canada out of status 5 years
did you collect COVID benefits payment NO
You have kids in school YES
You have permanent resident or Canadian family YES
You have stable work YES
You have stable financial activity YES
You have a house NO
You have a car YES
You own any business NO
You get help from government NO
You have Canadian grandchildren in Canada NO
Your from a poor or country in war NO
You have criminal issues NO
You have health issues NO
You have income from work showing in bank account YES
How long was your file YES
They give you any interim work authorization YES
For what reason did you applied for H&C BEST INTREST OF CHILD
Immigration should give you more reasons why they refused
Probably you have no reason tie you in Canada so they consider you can apply from back home using other programs

 

[canuck78]

@Robin220
Hi
Hope you doing well
You not online since November
I need your advice Robin
As I check your last message you file JR but i not sure
I also facing same problem my h&c application refused on this basis
"All factors that you cited in your application were considered. An officer determined they are not sufficient for you to be granted an exemption on humanitarian and compassionate grounds. Therefore, your application for permanent residence from within Canada on humanitarian and compassionate grounds is refused. "
What should I do now
Should I file JR or File a new h&c application
Your reply is lots for me
Thank you

This is really be something you should be discussing with your lawyer. They would need to look to see if they feel like you have grounds for JR. In general it will be hard for most to get approved for H&C given the small quota. If you are out of status CBSA is now looking to remove more people than they used to. You should also be discussing whether returning home may give you the opportunity to apply for PR via economic routes and what you can do to try to get PR via other pathways.

 

[us in canada]

That's fuck up unfortunately probably one of the reasons is you been in Canada for only 5 years and I do believe you need to be 3 or 5 years out of status to applied for h&c
So for example if you have 5 or 10 years old kids wend you arrived in Canada your kids speak your country language and went to school back home immigration wend they check your file they don't see problems to you and your kids go back home there's no really nothing to old you in Canada
For how long was your application in process
And how many months after they send you interim work authorization
This was 1 stage 2 second stage rejection

 

[canuck78]

That's fuck up unfortunately probably one of the reasons is you been in Canada for only 5 years and I do believe you need to be 3 or 5 years out of status to applied for h&c
So for example if you have 5 or 10 years old kids wend you arrived in Canada your kids speak your country language and went to school back home immigration wend they check your file they don't see problems to you and your kids go back home there's no really nothing to old you in Canada
For how long was your application in process
And how many months after they send you interim work authorization
This was 1 stage 2 second stage rejection

There are exact requirements or guarantees when it comes to H&C and what may have been possible even last year may no longer get you H&C. The quota levels are so low that not everyone is going to be able to claim best interest of children and get approved when it once was relatively easy to use this reason.

 

[Andypolis1987]

Anyone can apply for JR. You are misunderstanding the JR process. JR is not meant to determine the strength of your case it is to determine if the case has been properly evaluated and there were not procedural errors.

Canuck is Trump’s tariff will directly effect on our migration system?

 

[Andypolis1987]

did you collect COVID benefits payment

Waw, COVID benefits has nothing to do with H&C program !

 

[Andypolis1987]

Sadly for many it will result in people needing to return home move to another country.

If they remove TSR then I will be happy to move to another country

 

[idiris]

The Canadian immigration department has announced major changes to support Canada’s construction industry.

The biggest changes are

Reserving immigration spaces for up to 6,000 undocumented construction workers within Canada; and
Allowing qualified temporary foreign workers to study in apprenticeship programs without requiring a study permit.

https://www.cicnews.com/2025/03/breaking-canada-announces-new-pathway-to-permanent-residence-for-construction-workers-0352429.html