H&C Humanitarian Ground with/or Without Failed refugee claim

[Mansteinvon]

If applied somewhat recently a 4 month response for H&C is highly unusual especially if it was approved. There would have been something extremely time sensitive.

2023 September submission

 

[canuck78]

2023 September submission

There must have been an exceptional situation like a sick child needing life saving treatment.

 

[Mansteinvon]

There must have been an exceptional situation like a sick child needing life saving treatment.

Actually no

 

[Andypolis1987]

As I understand it, JR is not about assessing if your application should have been refused or approved but about whether the officer did a thorough / appropriate job of reviewing the application. So let's say that an application involved best interest of a child. JR will assess if the officer assessed this in their reivew of the file and considered the evidence submitted. JR is not there to re-assess the evidence or to say that a negative decision should have been positive. Just to make sure the officer considered what the applicant provided as part of their decision. Let's say that the officer did not assess all evidence, JR can then call this out and send the application back for review by a different officer. JR is not saying that the result should have been positive. They are saying evidence wasn't considered. When the new officer assesses the application, the end result can still be a refusal. This is my layman understanding.

@scylla Excuse me, Do you have any statistics and database that shows up from credible sources that recently huge numbers of applications got refused agin after positive outcome of JR?
If you have any source of information please disclosed to this platform!

JD. VP

 

[Andypolis1987]

Agree that it is often a waste of money. Asylum, refugees and H&C applications and associated programs are costing Canada a fortune. Most now file JR for any immigration rejection where JR it is possible and not for cases that have strong chance of actually getting a positive result or have a good chance of approval if redetermination is granted. Many filing JR have not idea what it actually is but given the volume of applications and wait times it is often used as a way to extend time in Canada.

I filed ALJR for the purpose to get positive results, not to grant extent my time in Canada !
My intention is pretty clear to get redetermination, not sure how weak case they are getting positive results since strong grounds are allowed to JR but how come opposite for H&C grounds !!

 

[Andypolis1987]

it is called compassionate for a reason, we are begging Canadian not that we are entitled for the pr

If the owner/host closed all the doors on your face then “ beggars “ where they should knock the next destination door?

 

[Andypolis1987]

2023 September submission

2023 March submission is still here !

 

[Andypolis1987]

2023 September submission

2023 March submission is still here !

 

[scylla]

@scylla Excuse me, Do you have any statistics and database that shows up from credible sources that recently huge numbers of applications got refused agin after positive outcome of JR?
If you have any source of information please disclosed to this platform!

JD. VP

I'm not aware of any such data source personally.