Client Portal
+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445
  • Forums
  • Immigration to Canada
  • Refugees and Asylum

H&C Humanitarian Ground with/or Without Failed refugee claim

Andypolis1987

Andypolis1987

Full Member
Feb 25, 2025
30
1
scylla said:
As I understand it, JR is not about assessing if your application should have been refused or approved but about whether the officer did a thorough / appropriate job of reviewing the application. So let's say that an application involved best interest of a child. JR will assess if the officer assessed this in their reivew of the file and considered the evidence submitted. JR is not there to re-assess the evidence or to say that a negative decision should have been positive. Just to make sure the officer considered what the applicant provided as part of their decision. Let's say that the officer did not assess all evidence, JR can then call this out and send the application back for review by a different officer. JR is not saying that the result should have been positive. They are saying evidence wasn't considered. When the new officer assesses the application, the end result can still be a refusal. This is my layman understanding.
Click to expand...
@scylla Excuse me, Do you have any statistics and database that shows up from credible sources that recently huge numbers of applications got refused agin after positive outcome of JR?
If you have any source of information please disclosed to this platform!

JD. VP
 
Andypolis1987

Andypolis1987

Full Member
Feb 25, 2025
30
1
canuck78 said:
Agree that it is often a waste of money. Asylum, refugees and H&C applications and associated programs are costing Canada a fortune. Most now file JR for any immigration rejection where JR it is possible and not for cases that have strong chance of actually getting a positive result or have a good chance of approval if redetermination is granted. Many filing JR have not idea what it actually is but given the volume of applications and wait times it is often used as a way to extend time in Canada.
Click to expand...
I filed ALJR for the purpose to get positive results, not to grant extent my time in Canada !
My intention is pretty clear to get redetermination, not sure how weak case they are getting positive results since strong grounds are allowed to JR but how come opposite for H&C grounds !!
 
S

scylla

VIP Member
Jun 8, 2010
97,079
22,989
Toronto
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
28-05-2010
AOR Received.
19-08-2010
File Transfer...
28-06-2010
Passport Req..
01-10-2010
VISA ISSUED...
05-10-2010
LANDED..........
05-10-2010
Andypolis1987 said:
@scylla Excuse me, Do you have any statistics and database that shows up from credible sources that recently huge numbers of applications got refused agin after positive outcome of JR?
If you have any source of information please disclosed to this platform!

JD. VP
Click to expand...
I'm not aware of any such data source personally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: canuck78 and Andypolis1987
C

canuck78

VIP Member
Jun 18, 2017
58,031
14,282
Andypolis1987 said:
I filed ALJR for the purpose to get positive results, not to grant extent my time in Canada !
My intention is pretty clear to get redetermination, not sure how weak case they are getting positive results since strong grounds are allowed to JR but how come opposite for H&C grounds !!
Click to expand...
Anyone can apply for JR. You are misunderstanding the JR process. JR is not meant to determine the strength of your case it is to determine if the case has been properly evaluated and there were not procedural errors.
 
C

casirat

Newbie
Mar 9, 2025
2
0
@Robin220
Hi
Hope you doing well
You not online since November
I need your advice Robin
As I check your last message you file JR but i not sure
I also facing same problem my h&c application refused on this basis
"All factors that you cited in your application were considered. An officer determined they are not sufficient for you to be granted an exemption on humanitarian and compassionate grounds. Therefore, your application for permanent residence from within Canada on humanitarian and compassionate grounds is refused. "
What should I do now
Should I file JR or File a new h&c application
Your reply is lots for me
Thank you
 
U

us in canada

Star Member
Nov 18, 2024
61
14
casirat said:
@Robin220
Hi
Hope you doing well
You not online since November
I need your advice Robin
As I check your last message you file JR but i not sure
I also facing same problem my h&c application refused on this basis
"All factors that you cited in your application were considered. An officer determined they are not sufficient for you to be granted an exemption on humanitarian and compassionate grounds. Therefore, your application for permanent residence from within Canada on humanitarian and compassionate grounds is refused. "
What should I do now
Should I file JR or File a new h&c application
Your reply is lots for me
Thank you
Click to expand...
How long you been in Canada out of status did you collect COVID benefits payment
You have kids in school
You have permanent resident or Canadian family
You have stable work
You have stable financial activity
You have a house
You have a car
You own any business
You get help from government
You have Canadian grandchildren in Canada
Your from a poor or country in war
You have criminal issues
You have health issues
You have income from work showing in bank account
How long was your file
They give you any interim work authorization
For what reason did you applied for H&C
Immigration should give you more reasons why they refused
Probably you have no reason tie you in Canada so they consider you can apply from back home using other programs
 
You must log in or register to reply here.