HDappicant said:
Can someone give me details about flag polling and the documents required to do it?
Thanks!
Hello HDApplicant,
My wife and I decided to cross into the U.S. for the day and then return to Canada instead of flagpoling, because we'd heard about bad experiences people had with U.S. authorities afterwards. Most people never have any problems, but one guy apparently gets pulled over for an hour every time he crosses into the U.S.
As I said, one option is to actually enter the U.S.
The other option is to go to the U.S. side and tell them you're not really interested in entering the U.S., but you have business with Canadian immigration. They give you a piece of paper that says "refusal of admission" which you give to the Canadian border officer. If the Americans code the refusal properly in their system, you'll never have a problem. So it's probably safe after that.
I phoned the Buffalo border post CBP office to ask about this. They said that it doesn't count negatively against you in future. I told them about what I'd read on the internet and they said that there was probably more going on with that person. In other words, the border guard must have thought he was being dishonest in some way. She also said you can correct any mistakes afterwards. But my view is that if the border guard took a dislike to you and wrongly decided you were being dishonest, you'll never be able to fix that.
My advice, if you don't need a visa to get into the U.S., is to be upfront and say that you'd like to enter the U.S. for a day AND afterwards you have business with the Canadian authorities. You should make sure you have a real plan for where you're going to go, what you're going to do, etc., so they can't accuse you of lying.
It's not clear at all that on ESTA or on any U.S. visa applications you would need to say you were refused entry. The CBP itself admits that there are refusals that aren't really genuine refusals for these purposes. Here's what they say about the ESTA question on being refused entry, for example:
https://help.cbp.gov/app/answers/detail/a_id/1097/~/previously-denied-a-visa-or-immigration-benefit
How would my eligibility for a travel authorization via ESTA be affected if I was previously denied a visa, previously denied an immigration benefit, or previously committed an immigration-related violation?
[...]
In some cases, you may not be sure how to answer this question because you were "allowed to withdraw" your application for entry, or a U.S. Consulate declined to issue you a visa because you did not have enough paperwork for them to make a decision on whether or not to grant you a visa. If this is your situation, we advise you to contact a U.S. Consulate and discuss what happened and ask them to tell you whether or not the withdrawal or declining to issue a visa constitutes an actual denial of entry or visa.