Sibling Vistor Visa Refused

[amanbadal]

Hi Everyone,

I have applied Visitor Visa for my elder brother and below is his profile:

His Profile
- Travel History: France, Netherlands, Vietnam and Indonesia in 2022
- Employment: Google India
- Status: Married
- Funds: 35K CAD
- Length of Stay: 2 weeks
- Occasion: My Birthday Celebration

My Profile
- My Status: Canadian Citizen
- Invitation: Notarized

Application timelines:
- Applied: 12 June 2023
- Biometric request: 17 June 2023
- Biometric submission: 22 June 2023
- Refusal Letter: 09 July 2023

He had been refused in 2017 when I invited him to visit me for my university convocation and I mentioned that with all the details while filing his visa this time.
I plan to apply for GCMS notes and need advice on what can be improved for the next reapply.

Thanks in advance for your valuable comments

 

[tommy_2k23]

Hi Everyone,

I have applied Visitor Visa for my elder brother and below is his profile:

- Travel History: France, Netherlands, Vietnam and Indonesia in 2022
- Employment: Google India
- Status: Married
- Funds: 35K CAD
- Length of Stay: 2 weeks
- Occasion: My Birthday Celebration
- My Status: Canadian Citizen
- Invitation: Notarized

Application timelines:
- Applied: 12 June 2023
- Biometric request: 17 June 2023
- Biometric submission: 22 June 2023
- Refusal Letter: 09 July 2023

He had been refused in 2017 when I invited him to visit me for my university convocation and I mentioned that with all the details while filing his visa this time.
I plan to apply for GCMS notes and need advice on what can be improved for the next reapply.

Thanks in advance for your valuable comments

he is married and earn income so he must support his trip by himself. Why are you supporting him?

what generic reasons were given?

 

[RP@2023]

Hi Everyone,

I have applied Visitor Visa for my elder brother and below is his profile:

- Travel History: France, Netherlands, Vietnam and Indonesia in 2022
- Employment: Google India
- Status: Married
- Funds: 35K CAD
- Length of Stay: 2 weeks
- Occasion: My Birthday Celebration
- My Status: Canadian Citizen
- Invitation: Notarized

Application timelines:
- Applied: 12 June 2023
- Biometric request: 17 June 2023
- Biometric submission: 22 June 2023
- Refusal Letter: 09 July 2023

He had been refused in 2017 when I invited him to visit me for my university convocation and I mentioned that with all the details while filing his visa this time.
I plan to apply for GCMS notes and need advice on what can be improved for the next reapply.

Thanks in advance for your valuable comments

Apply again, my brother and his wife's visa was refused three times from India, 2009, 2014, and 2019. this time i applied only for him on May 28, 2023 and on July 06 he got his passport stamped

 

[amanbadal]

he is married and earn income so he must support his trip by himself. Why are you supporting him?

what generic reasons were given?

Sorry for the confusion and I updated the the thread and added break in his profile and my profile.

His Profile
- Travel History: France, Netherlands, Vietnam and Indonesia in 2022
- Employment: Google India
- Status: Married
- Funds: 35K CAD
- Length of Stay: 2 weeks
- Occasion: My Birthday Celebration

My Profile
- My Status: Canadian Citizen
- Invitation: Notarized

He is sponsoring himself and I am just providing an invitation letter only

 

[amanbadal]

Apply again, my brother and his wife's visa was refused three times from India, 2009, 2014, and 2019. this time i applied only for him on May 28, 2023 and on July 06 he got his passport stamped

Thanks for the reply and I only applied for my brother

 

[tommy_2k23]

Thanks for the reply and I only applied for my brother

do you have access to his refusal paper that he received? what general refusal reasons were given? purpose of travel is not consistent with? or what else?

 

[canuck78]

Sorry for the confusion and I updated the the thread and added break in his profile and my profile.

His Profile
- Travel History: France, Netherlands, Vietnam and Indonesia in 2022
- Employment: Google India
- Status: Married
- Funds: 35K CAD
- Length of Stay: 2 weeks
- Occasion: My Birthday Celebration

My Profile
- My Status: Canadian Citizen
- Invitation: Notarized

He is sponsoring himself and I am just providing an invitation letter only

Was the travel history related to business or personal? What is is personal travel history? Is he married? Does he own property? How long has he been working at google? How old is he?

 

[amanbadal]

do you have access to his refusal paper that he received? what general refusal reasons were given? purpose of travel is not consistent with? or what else?

Below are the reasons in the refusal letter


I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as required by paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR (https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/regulations/SOR-2002-227/section-179.html). I am refusing your application because you have not established that you will leave Canada, based on the following factors:


• Your assets and financial situation are insufficient to support the stated purpose of travel for yourself (and any accompanying family member(s), if applicable).


• You have significant family ties in Canada.


• The purpose of your visit to Canada is not consistent with a temporary stay given the details you have provided in your application.

 

[amanbadal]

Was the travel history related to business or personal? What is is personal travel history? Is he married? Does he own property? How long has he been working at google? How old is he?

Only France was for work and the rest was for tourism
Yes he is married
Yes he showed and owned assets worth 3crores
He is with Google since March 2023
He is 34 years old

 

[canuck78]

Only France was for work and the rest was for tourism
Yes he is married
Yes he showed and owned assets worth 3crores
He is with Google since March 2023
He is 34 years old

He is very new to the google job which weakens his job it as a tie. If he had been at google for years that would show longterm well paying employment. Netherlands is the only person travel history. Did he go visit after going to Paris for business? Has he ever applied to work/study abroad or immigrate to another country. Do your parents have TRVs or supervisas? Are thee any other family members that live in Canada or longterm visitors? Are his funds in liquid cash or FDs?

 

[amanbadal]

He is very new to the google job which weakens his job it as a tie. If he had been at google for years that would show longterm well paying employment. Netherlands is the only person travel history. Did he go visit after going to Paris for business? Has he ever applied to work/study abroad or immigrate to another country. Do your parents have TRVs or supervisas? Are thee any other family members that live in Canada or longterm visitors? Are his funds in liquid cash or FDs?

Did he go visit after going to Paris for business? - Yes
Has he ever applied to work/study abroad or immigrate to another country? - Yes he have UK work visa got through work but won't able to move due to family situation
Do your parents have TRVs or supervisas? - My dad passed away 2 years ago and my mom has visitor visa
Are thee any other family members that live in Canada or longterm visitors? - I am only person living in Canada from my family and I am a citizen
Are his funds in liquid cash or FDs? - Liquid cash

 

[canuck78]

Did he go visit after going to Paris for business? - Yes
Has he ever applied to work/study abroad or immigrate to another country? - Yes he have UK work visa got through work but won't able to move due to family situation
Do your parents have TRVs or supervisas? - My dad passed away 2 years ago and my mom has visitor visa
Are thee any other family members that live in Canada or longterm visitors? - I am only person living in Canada from my family and I am a citizen
Are his funds in liquid cash or FDs? - Liquid cash

Think it is combination of many things like your mother having a TRV and so there is the potential she wants both children to live in the same place, your brother’s travels that are relevant to IRCC are tied to work, he has tried to work abroad, he is a relatively new job, etc. Would suggest ordering GCMS notes.

 

[amanbadal]

Think it is combination of many things like your mother having a TRV and so there is the potential she wants both children to live in the same place, your brother’s travels that are relevant to IRCC are tied to work, he has tried to work abroad, he is a relatively new job, etc. Would suggest ordering GCMS notes.

Thanks and I applied for GCMS today
I will post it here when I get it