Wth, he don’t has the right to ignore your documents !!!!
He should process all the file and all arguments before writing his decision.
H&C Humanitarian Ground with/or Without Failed refugee claim
- Thread starter TheWaitingGamer
- Start date
He should process all the file and all arguments before writing his decision.
Can you tell me how did you refer to the law in your arguments or did you submitted everything that your lawyer did first
I removed all legal arguments that the lawyer wrote, like examples of cases that won HC in the past. I personally do not find them useful because my partner lost HC twice despite citing dozens of judges that granted HC in similar cases. I focused on his HC evidence instead.
Ok...so you wrote your own store with no legal argument? I think that's what I will do.
She did not bother herself with that. Her refusal letter was generated in July 2020 but she did not close the file. Then in November we sent additional evidence, and in February 2021 she sends us refusal letter dated July 2020!
Yes, no legal argument whatsoever. Just proofs of family ties in Canada, best interest of Canadian child, employment letters, reference letters etc.
Funny thing in my case regarding friends and family in canada, i sent all letters as well about 10 i guess and the officer. stated tje same thing that i didnt show how it would impact their lives also he literally mentioned that they wont die of separation from you and vice versa and now we have social media and you/they cancontact using that and stay in toch. Hats off to that officer
I really want to know why you didn’t apply for PR before and you prefered a life with no rights freedom and privileges, but Of course we should focus on the futur And not the past.
In your first refusal your officer did a mistake because he said you don’t have any impact in your relatives life but that not true.
Did you send articles about your home country to prove the situation there and how it can cause a culture chock to your children ?
You have many and many ways to build a strong case especially in your case but you should c’arify More your arguments.
I’ve been following this story since it made headlines.It’s pretty sad.you guys can support him if you want to.
P.s I don’t know him personally.I just saw it somewhere and decided to share
https://www.gofundme.com/f/stop-the-deportation-of-carlo-escario
P.s I don’t know him personally.I just saw it somewhere and decided to share
https://www.gofundme.com/f/stop-the-deportation-of-carlo-escario
Think the member likely said that although it would be sad there are other ways to communicate with friends like via social media. There may even be opportunities to meet up with friends for a visit. In life it is not unusual for friends to have to move for personal, professional reasons or just go traveling for an extended period of time and friends miss them but it isn’t the end of the world. Think that is a fair comment about life without even immigration being involved.
He can reapply for PR when he gets to the Philippines and this time declaring his wife and child and then reapply. He asked to stay long enough to get his2nd Pfizer shot which was approved. Living his life in Canada while his wife and child would never qualify to immigrate (unless they qualified on their own) was not an ideal situation either. Not sure why he didn’t declare the wife and child in the first place.
What we’re each of your status since 2005. Visitor? Students? Workers? What happened from 2015-2018? What prompted you to apply for H&C in 2018? Did you have contact with CNSA or IRCC? DI’d you both have WPs since 2018? Have you both been working since 2021? No welfare?
My interpretation of why your 1st H&C was denied. Having both parents who are out of status makes the application harder to approve. H&C isn’t to protect people from having a different standard of living if they had to return home unless if it was a life or death situation. Is English the primary language in your home country? If so, they could transition into a new school system like any other child who has moved and the children will make friends and will adjust to a new school. Sure it is very sad to leave their friends but most can keep in tough via social media and children make new friends. They also have extended family in their home country like they do in Canada. Your eldest child who dreams of post-secondary school in Canada has nothing stopping her from attending college or university in Canada. In terms of your support to poor people in your country. Hopefully others you know will take up your cause will you try to get on your feet in your new country. H&C applications are about your family and not your charitable endeavours in other countries. In terms of jobs in your home country. Would start thinking about small business ideas, reach out to people you know in Canada or in your home country looking for employment, etc. I assume tourism is likely a big part of your home country’s economy. I would try to leverage your time in Canada into a business opportunity. For example Canadians may have a 2nd home in your home country. They may keep it for their use or rent it out longterm or an AirBnB or VRBO. You could be a property manager for these properties.
I assume your second refusal will highlight similar issues There are 2 very similar cases with H&C applicants have had 4 kids without status almost all or a good portion of the time. They may even both be from Jamaica. I think the message is that having children in Canada doesn’t guarantee that the whole family can remain in Canada.
My interpretation of why your 1st H&C was denied. Having both parents who are out of status makes the application harder to approve. H&C isn’t to protect people from having a different standard of living if they had to return home unless if it was a life or death situation. Is English the primary language in your home country? If so, they could transition into a new school system like any other child who has moved and the children will make friends and will adjust to a new school. Sure it is very sad to leave their friends but most can keep in tough via social media and children make new friends. They also have extended family in their home country like they do in Canada. Your eldest child who dreams of post-secondary school in Canada has nothing stopping her from attending college or university in Canada. In terms of your support to poor people in your country. Hopefully others you know will take up your cause will you try to get on your feet in your new country. H&C applications are about your family and not your charitable endeavours in other countries. In terms of jobs in your home country. Would start thinking about small business ideas, reach out to people you know in Canada or in your home country looking for employment, etc. I assume tourism is likely a big part of your home country’s economy. I would try to leverage your time in Canada into a business opportunity. For example Canadians may have a 2nd home in your home country. They may keep it for their use or rent it out longterm or an AirBnB or VRBO. You could be a property manager for these properties.
I assume your second refusal will highlight similar issues There are 2 very similar cases with H&C applicants have had 4 kids without status almost all or a good portion of the time. They may even both be from Jamaica. I think the message is that having children in Canada doesn’t guarantee that the whole family can remain in Canada.
Does anyone here knows how to apply for reconsideration for a Temporary Resident Application ? Can we email the IRCC office for reconsideration ?