so its 50-50?Ponga said:You're not listening.
You don't need to have any paper (signed or otherwise) to be common-law. You usually NEED these papers if you want to prove common-law to CIC when you are applying WITH YOUR CURRENT COMMON-LAW PARTNER.
Just because you don't have any papers proving that you were in fact common-law (which YOU WERE) it doesn't change the FACT...that you were.
You have two choices:
Disclose the previous common-law and deal with your wife freaking out about it (which really does sound ridiculous)- [Yay...right decision]!
or
Not disclose it and wonder...'What if' with each passing day, while you wait for a decision on your application. - [Booooo! Bad decision].