Anlo29 said:
I would argue that by birth I was granted Canadian citizenship which would define me as first generation but I also moved and lived there after being born which makes me think I earned it which would allow the Canadian citizenship to be passed down to first generation that is for my two daughters.
You can argue as much as you like but it is not going to get you anywhere. Born to Canadian citizens outside Canada and gaining citizenship based on that they were citizens when you were born, you meet the definition of "first generation born abroad". Nothing ever changes that. In order to be a "born Canadian" you would have had to have been born in Canada.
If your daughters were born before April 17, 2009, they would be Canadians because the citizenship law changed on that date. The law before that date was that 2nd generation born abroad (like your children) had to spend a certain amount of time in Canada and apply to retain their citizenship before their 28th birthday. On April 17, 2009, the law changed and 2nd generation born abroad who were not yet 28 years old did no longer have to take steps to retain their citizenship but also that after that date, first generation could not pass citizenship to their children anymore. However, these children can be sponsored for PR.
Hence, if your children were born before April 17th 2009, you can apply for their citizenship certificates. Otherwise, depending on your situation, you have the following options:
1. As a Canadian living outside Canada, you must either be in Canada or planning on moving to Canada if you want to sponsor your spouse and/or children for PR. You may have to show proof of this.
2. If you are not planning on moving to Canada at this time, you may sponsor your children for PR under the current rules until their 19th birthday. After their 19th birthday, they would have to find a way to apply for PR on their own if they want it.
If you do sponsor your spouse/children for PR, they would have to meet the residency obligation of 2/5 years in Canada in any rolling 5 year period. However, as long as your spouse is living with you and your children are minors and living with you, they can keep their PR based on that. If you do sponsor your children for PR and they go to Canada to study or work and fulfill the residency obligation in order to apply for citizenship, they would become naturalized citizens and would be able to pass citizenship to their children, even if their children are later not born in Canada.
If you sponsor your children for PR and move to Canada with them while they are still minors, you can apply for their citizenship right away without them having to meet the RO for citizenship and they would again be considered naturalized citizens.