+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

Bad News again........Decision Made after Interview

Jamesah

Star Member
Aug 26, 2010
63
1
Category........
Visa Office......
Mexico City
NOC Code......
0213
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
30-05-2010
Doc's Request.
05-11-2010
AOR Received.
30-09-2010
Med's Request
28-09-2011
Med's Done....
08-10-2011
Interview........
28-09-2011
Passport Req..
09-11-2011
VISA ISSUED...
24-11-2011
LANDED..........
Waiting
Ok then my theory is wrong then, then my opinion is with you you should appeal cause it doesn't makes any sense. Only with a Master they give you many points so i don't think the problem is there also.
 

mni

Hero Member
Mar 7, 2010
448
25
Canada
Category........
Visa Office......
New Delhi
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
LANDED..........
03-Jun-2013
Do you mind sharing how many years of experience you have?

Prabjot said:
I am having masters in comuter application. NOC 0213.

Both are related. I gave ref. letter on companies letter head signed by my manager.
 

Candreamz

Star Member
Dec 31, 2010
125
2
Category........
Visa Office......
ND
NOC Code......
0213
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
IELTS Request
With papers
File Transfer...
27-01-2010
Med's Request
06-10-2010
Med's Done....
14-10-2010
Interview........
waived
Passport Req..
06-10-2010
VISA ISSUED...
10-01-2011
LANDED..........
may - 2011
Hi Prabhjot,

Could you please tell us the job duties for which VO is not satisfied as i am also with the same NOC and already got the Visa.

Thanks
Candreamz.
 

Prabjot

Star Member
Dec 7, 2010
73
8
Candreamz said:
Hi Prabhjot,

Could you please tell us the job duties for which VO is not satisfied as i am also with the same NOC and already got the Visa.

Thanks
Candreamz.
I have alreday explained it in another topic. Please see that.
I hv got refusal....if any one can help me to know how to appeal, I will appreciate that
 

Adroit

Hero Member
Jan 19, 2011
304
123
Category........
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
Very Very sorry to hear about your situation Prabjot, before writing to anyone or making an appeal, my advice is to analyse the root cause of your refusal, i mean why VO is not satisfied with your experience? why he said to you during your interview that even your manager is not performing these duties?

there must be a reason, this is wt i guess.
 

Jamesah

Star Member
Aug 26, 2010
63
1
Category........
Visa Office......
Mexico City
NOC Code......
0213
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
30-05-2010
Doc's Request.
05-11-2010
AOR Received.
30-09-2010
Med's Request
28-09-2011
Med's Done....
08-10-2011
Interview........
28-09-2011
Passport Req..
09-11-2011
VISA ISSUED...
24-11-2011
LANDED..........
Waiting
I found this site I believe they can help you evaluate your case:

http://www.visaplace.com/canada-immigration/immigration-refusal.php
 

pittabread

Champion Member
Oct 25, 2010
1,699
442
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
Prabjot said:
its ok dear,
For me each reply is valuable..

I will talk to my consultants tomorrow. Let c what they will suggest. Its not just about Canada. Its about my emotions. My employer is sending me US in April. They wanted me to now itself. but I will eligible for L1 in April so I have to wait. H1 cap has been reached to end for this fiscal year..otherwise I would have applied till now.

I know my case was genuin and I gave all the proofs. If one VO is personally not satisfied CIC can not avoid my proofs.

I dont know what my consultants will say or what will be the result now. But I am going to fight for it now. If they were not satisfied with exp or job duties, they should have reject it at the time of initial review itself.

Please keep on sharing your exp. You all are my streanth now. I have already got refusal so there is no fear left now. If god wants me to fight for it, Let me show how far I can go with it.

Prabjot Kaur
thats like a brave girl. fight for it and carry on till you win....................... :) :) :) :) :) :)

may i ask are you sardarni... chak day phatay fare.........
 

pittabread

Champion Member
Oct 25, 2010
1,699
442
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
prabjot your case is strong. even if you take visa office to court then the court can verify from your manager that you did perform those job duties.

visa officer has no proof that you did not perform those job duties. only your manager can verify that you performed all the job duties.

i think your case is very strong. take them to court.
 

SATDXB

Champion Member
Sep 11, 2010
2,427
133
Category........
Visa Office......
London
NOC Code......
1111
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
12-Aug-09
Doc's Request.
02-Oct-09
File Transfer...
06-Oct-09
Med's Request
18-08-10
Med's Done....
09-09-10
Interview........
Waived
Passport Req..
19-01-2011 - Passport sent on 22-01-2011
VISA ISSUED...
11-04-2011
LANDED..........
19th May 2011- Thanks to Almighty!
pittabread said:
thats like a brave girl. fight for it and carry on till you win....................... :) :) :) :) :) :)

may i ask are you sardarni... chak day phatay fare.........
Yes, she is ..!!
PUNJABI BRAVE MUNDI ..!!


Cheers...
 

riz1

Star Member
Jul 26, 2010
174
3
Hi
My advice is to take it to the next step if you can afford, I think appeal process will cost you aroun 5000 cad$, but your case is strong visa officer just can not take a decision based on his beliefs and observation, totally ignoring the black and White proof, I mean written documents, only your company and Manager has a right to say yes or no regarding your job duties and their wording can not be ignored well they are the only one who can say yes she did or did not perform these duties, specially in countries like Pakistan and India we perform alot more job tasks then our actuall job designation other wise we can not keep on our seat. Go for appeal and don't miss your chance .
Thanks
 

canada via USA

Full Member
Jan 13, 2011
21
1
sorry to hear the rejection to your case madam prabjot.

Before you apply for appeal or reconsideration, as some one suggested work on the root cause,
In my opinion -
As you have mentioned that you have 5 yrs of exp and applied under IT Manager, you should consider that it will take you lot of efforts to prove that you were actually doing the PMs work, not just lil team management or working on RFPs or SoW.
Pl note that PMs in north america are with wealth of exp in technology and management. They will be evaluating you against current PMs lot in canada. You can do your self some research in canada job market and see the job ads for PMs ( you won't find very often PM required with total 5 yrs exp)
Also pl note, they don't need developers under NOC 0213 cat... They have become lot strict post 26june 2010 in their old case evaluation as well.

I can only wish as others did, good luck for your preparation in appeal procedures. But just don't overlooked the reality, we all know in India million of people works as PM ( only designation , they may not be doing whole project management -as mentioned in NOC 0213) with 5-8 yrs of exp. You may not be the one, but to satisfy VO there has to be different approach and presentation.
 

SISH7255

Hero Member
Nov 19, 2009
465
74
Toronto
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
LANDED..........
July 2011
STILLHOPE said:
HELLO

PRABHJOT I READ YOUR STORY, SORRY FOR THAT,I JOIN THIS BLOG ONLY TO TELL MY STORY. I APPLIED IN 2002 CANADIAN IMMIGRATION TILL 2007 I HAVNT GOT ANY THING FROM IMMIGRATION SIDE AND THEN I APPLIED STUDENT VISA FOR MY WIFE NAME IN 2007 SEPT AND THEN THEY REFUSED MY WIFE STUDY VISA, BECAUSE THEY SAID WE ALREADY APPLIED IMMIGRATION FOR CANADA (SO THIS IS MY FIRST REJECTION). IN 2008 I GOT A LETTER FROM MY IMMIGRATION CONSULTANT THAT THEY REFUSED MY IMMIGRATION APPLICATION AFTER LONG WAIT OF ALMOST 7 YEARS (SO THIS IS SECOND REJECTION) AND AGAING I APPLIED CANADA IMMIGRATION ON MY WIFE NAME BUT AFTER THREE MONTHS WHEN I APPLIED THEY SEND OUR APPLICATION BACK BECAUSE THEY CHANGED THE RULE AND REDUCE THE CATEGORIES (THIRD REFUSAL). NOW I AM PLANNING AGAIN TO APPLY FOR IMMIGRATION TO CANADA WITH ANOTHER HOPE. SO DONT LOSE HOPE, BE POSITIVE BELIEVE ON YOURSELF.BELIEVE ON GOD.

GOOD LUCK

THANKS


Appreciate your patience and perseverance.

God bless you this time.
 

SISH7255

Hero Member
Nov 19, 2009
465
74
Toronto
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
LANDED..........
July 2011
Prabjot said:
I have alreday explained it in another topic. Please see that.
I hv got refusal....if any one can help me to know how to appeal, I will appreciate that
Prabjot,

Sorry to hear about your case. If you are choosing not to go for appeal, write a letter to immigration minister-kennedy, CC to Canadian prime minister's office and Canadian high commission in India. Explain everything in letter and show additional proof to support your case.If your case is strong,they can reopen your file. It has happened with many in the past. My case was also rejected but they reopened it when they reralized that it was their fault.

Wish you all the best.
 

riz1

Star Member
Jul 26, 2010
174
3
Hi
I am not agree with Canadaviausa, I personally know so one who was working for the company as a systemanalyst for two plus years and before system analyst he works with me as a computer programmer he was computer programmer for 19 months and find an other job as a system analyst he work as a system analyst for two plus years then promoted in the same company as a Systems development manager, how can you justify it then his job includes the dealing with clients and projects on daily basis, he was promoted because he knows the company understand there pattern of work and has a good relations with clients, it all depends onhow well you perform i, and if you look at the requirements of INstitute of PRoject MAnagers, a you find out for the certification/designation of Pmp project manager professional there requirement is also 5 years experience and she has 5 exyears experience, she can be a project manager if she works hard and prove her skills.
Thanks