noc4012 said:
Could you post your letter so we can advise you on what to put in it for the next time?
"While working at xFIRMx, his/her main duties included:
1- Utilize various design-software and CAD/CAM systems to design plastic and EPS products.
2- Prepare material, cost and timing reports for E.P.S products.
3- Prepare design specifications for E.P.S machinery.
4- Investigate unexpected mechanical failures of E.P.S machinery.
5- Provide guidance to E.P.S maintenance crews."
It is supposed to be compared with NOC2132 Mechanical engineer. There are nearly 50 example job title given for a Mechanical engineer, the duties of which is given as:
Mechanical engineers perform some or all of the following duties:
1. Conduct research into the feasibility, design, operation and performance of mechanisms, components and systems
2. Plan and manage projects, and prepare material, cost and timing estimates, reports and design specifications for machinery and systems
(comparable with No. 2 and 3 of my duties)
3. Design power plants, machines, components, tools, fixtures and equipment
(comparable with No. 1 of my duties)
4. Analyze dynamics and vibrations of mechanical systems and structures
5. Supervise and inspect the installation, modification and commissioning of mechanical systems at construction sites or in industrial facilities
6. Develop maintenance standards, schedules and programs and provide guidance to industrial maintenance crews
(comparable with No. 5 in my duties)
7. Investigate mechanical failures or unexpected maintenance problems
(comparable with No. 4 of my duties)
8. Prepare contract documents and evaluate tenders for industrial construction or maintenance
9. Supervise technicians, technologists and other engineers and review and approve designs, calculations and cost estimates.
(comparable with No. 2 in my duties)
It is stated in NOC that "There is considerable mobility between mechanical engineering specializations at the less senior levels." Also it says "Supervisory and senior positions in this unit group require experience." This was my first job right after I got my BS degree and I couldn't have had all of the duties above. I also doubt that there is any engineering job that covers all of the duties above as some the example jobs mentioned in NOC are very different.
Still consulting lawyers for appeal in court. But if I am going to reapply, I am not even sure if my employer would add duties that are not performed by anyone in their firm. Please advise.