+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

Weird situation for Vistor extension approval decision? Do I need to reapply?

irochka832

Hero Member
Oct 26, 2018
242
95
Ontario
Category........
FSW
IRCC will ask you for a medical if they determine it's necessary on an extension application. It's not in the package.
Thanks a lot, it is a big relief for me.

It seems to me from what i read in multiple posts that it is most certainly they will require medical if she was in Canada for more than 6 months. Is it true?

So far it has been two months since i sent an application and except the signature on Canada post website i have no any other that my application has been received. Its so stressful ...
 

canuck78

VIP Member
Jun 18, 2017
55,594
13,524
Hi guys,

I have a question .My mother-in-law visited us in April 2017 and left to home country on october 2017. then again she came back on january 2018 after a gap of 4 months and shes staying with us till now. we applied for her extension in jun 2018 and got letter for medicals.

She did medicals and dr found some problem in xray ,she did it again according to panel doctor. now my question is
1. what are the chances of her extension.
2. If denied how much time is given
3. with regards to time periods is she considered living
4. if she leave how much time she needs to stay back home before returning to canada
5. If panel doctor doesnt submit report on time what happens to extensions

Any one would help
You MIL must have received another extension already if she arrived in January 2019 unless they are only getting to the June applications. She is spending much more time in Canada than in her home country so she should remain in India for at least 6 months. Is she only on a TRV? Why did you not apply for supervisa? If they do find something on her medical check she will have to return home to receive treatment.
 

ramkris

Hero Member
Apr 17, 2010
662
17
Category........
Visa Office......
NEW DELHI
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
16-Aug-2013
File Transfer...
13-Sep-2013
Med's Done....
1-Aug-2013
Passport Req..
26-Sep-2013
VISA ISSUED...
19-Apr-2014
LANDED..........
soon
You MIL must have received another extension already if she arrived in January 2019 unless they are only getting to the June applications. She is spending much more time in Canada than in her home country so she should remain in India for at least 6 months. Is she only on a TRV? Why did you not apply for supervisa? If they do find something on her medical check she will have to return home to receive treatment.
I m waiting for her extension . she's in implied status now. yes as you said shes almost more than a year here with a small gap of 3 months. She had a 10 yr multi entry visa. I dont want to take super visa. It seems they found some problem in her health. Thats what panel physician told it seems. In that case would she be rejected and denied entry in future
 

canuck78

VIP Member
Jun 18, 2017
55,594
13,524
I m waiting for her extension . she's in implied status now. yes as you said shes almost more than a year here with a small gap of 3 months. She had a 10 yr multi entry visa. I dont want to take super visa. It seems they found some problem in her health. Thats what panel physician told it seems. In that case would she be rejected and denied entry in future
Medical exams are often required as part of an extension.
 

ramkris

Hero Member
Apr 17, 2010
662
17
Category........
Visa Office......
NEW DELHI
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
16-Aug-2013
File Transfer...
13-Sep-2013
Med's Done....
1-Aug-2013
Passport Req..
26-Sep-2013
VISA ISSUED...
19-Apr-2014
LANDED..........
soon

canuck78

VIP Member
Jun 18, 2017
55,594
13,524
yes its done and found problem does it affect in future
If you don't get denied for a TRV, you likely won't get denied for a supervisa. You are taking a very large risk that you will have to repay a large hospital bill if your family member ends up in hospital. Yes at a certain point she will be denied for medical reason especially if she doesn't have insurance. It is not only a financial risk for you but also to the Canadian taxpayer.
 

ramkris

Hero Member
Apr 17, 2010
662
17
Category........
Visa Office......
NEW DELHI
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
16-Aug-2013
File Transfer...
13-Sep-2013
Med's Done....
1-Aug-2013
Passport Req..
26-Sep-2013
VISA ISSUED...
19-Apr-2014
LANDED..........
soon
If you don't get denied for a TRV, you likely won't get denied for a supervisa. You are taking a very large risk that you will have to repay a large hospital bill if your family member ends up in hospital. Yes at a certain point she will be denied for medical reason especially if she doesn't have insurance. It is not only a financial risk for you but also to the Canadian taxpayer.
When i check online about her application it says that she passed medicals but when i see panel physicians site if they submitted report or not . it says report not submitted I was confused about this. whats meant by medicals passed that shes not having any problems.
 

Hummingbird89

Hero Member
Mar 18, 2023
366
50
Toronto
Category........
CEC
LANDED..........
2019
Regarding child care/babysitting one's own grandchild as work or illegal work would be a particularly harsh interpretation of immigration law. I really don't see IRCC vigorously litigating such cases involving grandmas in federal court when the resources could be better used for stopping people who came to Canada solely to work and are actually getting paid while fraudulently working on visitor/ overstayed visas and thus blatantly breaking the law. No, it would not make any practical sense. Now, that does not in any way mean that parents and grandparents can stay in Canada on visitor visas endlessly, and I do agree with your earlier submissions that IRCC reserves the right to cancel visas/refuse applications if officers determine that by living in Canada for an extended period, a parent/grandparent no longer meets the criteria for the renewal of a visitor visa or the definition of a visitor.

Here's an excerpt from a letter to the HoC by no less a person than the Chair, Immigration Law Section of the Canadian Bar Association:

"Recent studies indicate that the net positive impact of the non-economic contributions of parents and grandparents on the economy, including child care, assistance with family business activities, emotional support, cultural education, volunteerism, maintenance of social cohesion, and housekeeping – in addition to the financial resources they may contribute – is often overlooked."

Link to full letter here: https://www.cba.org/CMSPages/GetFile.aspx?guid=14e53f42-575c-4d72-a305-f0755560f232

There are countless anecdotes of people actually stating childcare as the reason for inviting their PGPs to Canada in their (ultimately successful) visa applications.

I noticed that this issue has been discussed in the past: https://www.canadavisa.com/canada-immigration-discussion-board/threads/sponsor-parent-family-class-who-has-overstayed.238145/
https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/corporate/publications-manuals/report-on-super-visa-income-requirement-appeal-process-special-circumstances-temp-resident-visas.html#toc-0

Grandparents assisting with childcare is encouraged.