I just got my CELPIP results back and I'm pretty annoyed! I clearly have great writing skills, but they still gave me an 8 in writing. What gives? I was surprised at how incredibly short the writing section was-- two 150-200 word entries seems like nothing compared to the essays I've had to write for exams like the SAT. I requested a re-evaluation of just the writing score. I just want them to bring it up to a 9.
We had a similar situation- my husband got an 8 on writing. It only made a difference of two points in our case so I don't think I'm going to request re-evaluation, but I find it frustrating. Every other area was a 12 - it makes absolutely no sense. Good luck with your re-evaluation!