Reasons for Rejection

[dobes]

Hi, I was just checking the other thread where people reported rejections regarding medical. One of them was "toronto_engg " and he mentioned:

Quote from: toronto_engg on August 18, 2015, 11:36:22 am

My medical information sheet i got from doctor said:
IME: Non- EDE
Upfront medical type: Worker
exams required: 501 medical exam
502 chest x ray
707 HIV
712 syphilis test

I have applied under cec express entry as main applicant, my wife is secondary applicant."

So, he did not go for the other tests. Then what might be the reason behind his rejection??

here is the link:
http://www.canadavisa.com/canada-immigration-discussion-board/upfront-medical-for-dependent-after-ita-what-type-t345005.15.html

Those are the right tests.

 

[f1ahmed]

Those are the right tests.

Yes Dobes, but s/he was rejected and CIC stated the same reason: "medical was assessed for temporary permit......"

 

[dobes]

Yes Dobes, but s/he was rejected and CIC stated the same reason: "medical was assessed for temporary permit......"

Yes. I'm just saying, the problem is not in the tests performed, it's in the assessment - the interpretation - of the tests, whoever does that.

 

[archjap]

he said on his post: http://www.canadavisa.com/canada-immigration-discussion-board/upfront-medical-for-dependent-after-ita-what-type-t345005.0.html;msg4579975#msg4579975

You are misunderstanding.. i meant that the medical which was rejected was a fresh one and not one i used for any other application.


base on this: http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/resources/tools/medic/assess/using.asp

The most commonly used limitations are:

“Assessed as excessive demand exempt only”. A new immigration medical examination is required if the applicant applies under an immigration category that is no longer excessive demand exempt (e.g. the foreign national applied as sponsored spouse (FC-1) and now applies as Federal Skilled Worker)
“Assessed as Temporary Resident only”. A new immigration medical examination is required if the applicant applies for permanent resident status or extend his or her stay in Canada.

Note: Applicants are responsible for informing a visa office if they applied previously in a different category.

 

[lexielei24]

Hello guys,

I have questions regarding our PR application under CEC. My husband is the main applicant. We submitted the application on June 07, 2015 pending my FBI certificate. I submitted my form to FBI on April 10 and on July I received a letter saying that my fingerprints are illegible. So we did try to re submit 3 sets of fingerprints on July 08. It has only been 6 weeks and the processing time is between 12-14 weeks. Cry

This morning, we received a notification from CIC requesting an FBI certificate and we only have 7 days to submit it. If my fingerprints passed, I would be receiving the certificate some time around October. And my husband's LMIA work permit is until September 28 of next month only. His employer tried to apply for a positive LMIA but was rejected. Sad We did however receive an Alberta nomination last month.

Will the VO cancel our application once we told them that we tried re submitting the fingerprints and it would take few more months for FBI to process? And will the officer cancel it since we would not be able to provide the certificate before my husband's WP expires? His EE points is 780 and 600 of those is because of LMIA.

We are planning on submitting our WP extensions this week through nomination based. In the event that our Express Entry application is unsuccessful, can he still submit a new profile? We might have to apply under AINP before the certificate expires but the processing times are ridiculous!

 

[kmagnusc]

Hello, I am following up with you all about my rejection. the ONLY information I received from CIC in my rejection letter was as follows:

"Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) has reviewed your application for permanent residence. We
have determined that your application does not meet the requirements of a complete application as
described in sections 10 and 12.01 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations. Your
application is rejected for being incomplete.
Specifically, your application does not include the following elements:
- Upfront medical report
Upfront medical report - Invalid medicals as medicals have been assessed for Temporary residence only
for both [applicant names]"

So far as I know I passed my medical according to the doctor, along with my partner. I tried to call the help line today and they told me they could not answer any of my questions. They sent me a useless link to the website. They said they do not take calls about Express Entry. I sent a CSE last night. Ugh.

I have no idea how to fix this. My partner and I were both assessed as NON-EDE Category: Worker on our upfront eMedical reports by Canadian physician. We told them over and over that it was for PR - EE. I can't believe this...

 

[uxd]

This is very unfortunate. Me and spouse's info sheet says NON EDE VISITOR. In the chest x ray, it is mentioned that CLINICAL INDICATION: IMMIGRATION . The letter that we rcvd on mail from our Medical Examiner says clearly Immigration Medical Exam.

Now I am feeling very worried. ???

 

[sraj07]

Hi sraj07,

What is the issue date you have given in your CIC application.
Is it the original issue date or the date on which the duplicate copy, which contains IMM, was issued?

Please reply

I gave the date that is there in my new form , not the old date .

 

[Mutair]

Hi, I was just checking the other thread where people reported rejections regarding medical. One of them was "toronto_engg " and he mentioned:

Quote from: toronto_engg on August 18, 2015, 11:36:22 am

My medical information sheet i got from doctor said:
IME: Non- EDE
Upfront medical type: Worker
exams required: 501 medical exam
502 chest x ray
707 HIV
712 syphilis test

I have applied under cec express entry as main applicant, my wife is secondary applicant."

So, he did not go for the other tests. Then what might be the reason behind his rejection??

here is the link:
http://www.canadavisa.com/canada-immigration-discussion-board/upfront-medical-for-dependent-after-ita-what-type-t345005.15.html

I was told by my doctor that it should be "Family" as "Worker" is only for temporary workers.

 

[kmagnusc]

Another update:

I have contacted CIC via phone, CSE, Twitter, and my doctor's office via phone and e-mail. I will see where I can get with this. Honestly I am extremely frustrated and may end up contacting a lawyer.

I will keep you all updated regarding this process.

 

[Michal]

I was told by my doctor that it should be "Family" as "Worker" is only for temporary workers.

Then the rest of the doctors around the world make the same mistake and choose worker...

 

[MySky]

Hello, I am following up with you all about my rejection. the ONLY information I received from CIC in my rejection letter was as follows:

"Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC) has reviewed your application for permanent residence. We
have determined that your application does not meet the requirements of a complete application as
described in sections 10 and 12.01 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations. Your
application is rejected for being incomplete.
Specifically, your application does not include the following elements:
- Upfront medical report
Upfront medical report - Invalid medicals as medicals have been assessed for Temporary residence only
for both [applicant names]"

So far as I know I passed my medical according to the doctor, along with my partner. I tried to call the help line today and they told me they could not answer any of my questions. They sent me a useless link to the website. They said they do not take calls about Express Entry. I sent a CSE last night. Ugh.

I have no idea how to fix this. My partner and I were both assessed as NON-EDE Category: Worker on our upfront eMedical reports by Canadian physician. We told them over and over that it was for PR - EE. I can't believe this...

I don't know what's going on with CIC. My medical confirmation page reads "Non EDE, Visitor". My medical shows Passed on myCIC.

 

[paras1991]

looks like CIC themselves doesnt know anything

 

[konosan]

Yes. I'm just saying, the problem is not in the tests performed, it's in the assessment - the interpretation - of the tests, whoever does that.

May I ask what the type of your medical exam was? Non-EDE worker or EDE family?
The decision was made for your application according to your signature.

 

[dobes]

Another update:

I have contacted CIC via phone, CSE, Twitter, and my doctor's office via phone and e-mail. I will see where I can get with this. Honestly I am extremely frustrated and may end up contacting a lawyer.

I will keep you all updated regarding this process.

I think it will take a lawyer to point this recurring issue out to CIC.