parents sponsership joine here

[september2007]

hi 9779570133,
congratulations, I tried to reply you on this foram but somehow I was not able to do it sorry about that....

 

[kandel]

I have recieved a letter from new delhi.They are asking explanation about my sister education.
Your daughter XXXXXX BORN NOV 1984 was over 22 years of age when an undertaking of assistance was submitted on your behalf at the case processing center in mississaugaon 7 april 2008.

information on your application indicates that after completing a BA course and doing a PGDCA and M.SC IN COMPUTER SCIENCE from college (affiliated to GNDU university) and my sister enrolled MA english course.She failed twice this course,she abandoned it and enrolled in a MA History course.it appears she was not actively pursuing this course.it is alsonoted that she has consistently changed her subjects, from computer sciences to english and then to history

This suggests that since attaining 22 years of age XXXXXX is not actively pursuing a course of academic,professional or vocational training and thereforedoes not meet the definition of a dependent child.

Given the foregoing ,i must conclude that xxxxxxxx is not a dependtant child as defined in section 2 of the immigration and refugee act.
Before a decision is made in your case, i am providing you with the opportunity to comment on the above concerns or provide any observation or explanation in writing. You have 30 days from the date of this letter to reply.

PLEASE ANYONE HELP ME ABOUT THIS LETTER .SHE DONT HAVE ANY GAP ,PLEASE ANYONE TELL ME HOW TO REPLY THIS LETTER.THANKS

Hi memebr39 I am sad and worried for you. I agree with Ranja please get help from Lawyer and make sure your lawyer writes very strong letter with lots of reasons on your sister's behalf. Let us know if you need any kind of help. Fight your best and convince that visa officer to give your sister a visa. My prayers are with you.

 

[39]

Hi memebr39 I am sad and worried for you. I agree with Ranja please get help from Lawyer and make sure your lawyer writes very strong letter with lots of reasons on your sister's behalf. Let us know if you need any kind of help. Fight your best and convince that visa officer to give your sister a visa. My prayers are with you.

Thank u kandel . Do u know any lawyer in Vancouver.

 

[39]

I suggest you consult an immigration lawyer. Seems like the concern from the visa officer is not the gap but rather the fact that she was enrolled in all these courses just to stay dependent for immigration purposes.

hi ranja thank u for u r advise. Do u know any immigration lawyers in Vancouver or in surrey bc

 

[Luck786]

Hi 39

From your sister's educational history via officer is of the opinion that she was enrolled in random courses just to be a dependent.
In my opinion there shouldn't have been any problem if she had the related subjects or education.
Now all you have to do is give provide reason to eliminate this doubt.You have to expalin why she changed her line and why she was failing the subject ?
So come up with a very very valid reason to cover that.It is upto you now to give satisfactory reasons.I don't think so that you need a good lawyer all you need is a reason to satisfy with some proofs.Any truthful simple explanation even from her teachers why she couldn't pass English and had to take History.

Take care and do little research.

 

[39]

yes lucky786 yes you are 100% right . I consult with my parents and my accountant.
Hi 39

From your sister's educational history via officer is of the opinion that she was enrolled in random courses just to be a dependent.
In my opinion there shouldn't have been any problem if she had the related subjects or education.
Now all you have to do is give provide reason to eliminate this doubt.You have to expalin why she changed her line and why she was failing the subject ?
So come up with a very very valid reason to cover that.It is upto you now to give satisfactory reasons.I don't think so that you need a good lawyer all you need is a reason to satisfy with some proofs.Any truthful simple explanation even from her teachers why she couldn't pass English and had to take History.

Take care and do little research.

 

[Luck786]

Hi 39
Here is a very useful link for you.Please read this very carefully.very informative for you.U can preapare your case keeping in mind this one.

http://www.canlii.org/eliisa/highlight.do?text=+dependent+child+immigration&language=en&searchTitle=Search+all+CanLII+Databases&path=/en/ca/fct/doc/2007/2007fc279/2007fc279.html

 

[RajaJi]

A change in my ecas.... IN PROCESS to DECISION MADE... and in my ecas...
4th line in my ecas... A decision has been made on your application. The office will contact you concerning this decision.

Congratulations! 9779570133 -SPONSORSHIP TIMELINE is updated

 

[39]

Hi 39
Here is a very useful link for you.Please read this very carefully.very informative for you.U can preapare your case keeping in mind this one.

http://www.canlii.org/eliisa/highlight.do?text=+dependent+child+immigration&language=en&searchTitle=Search+all+CanLII+Databases&path=/en/ca/fct/doc/2007/2007fc279/2007fc279.html

hello lucky can I talk with u on the phone

 

[user828]

39 - look up Canada Visa Law in google ( the 1st link ) , its a law firm which helped one of our forum members or their Parent App

The officer has definitely got strong case himself, however - he still has doubts that's why he is asking for explanation.

I came to Canada as a student in 2000, my background was hospitality and I moved to Computers so people change careers, direction etc all the time -- you gotta go with that

 

[user828]

Hi 39
Here is a very useful link for you.Please read this very carefully.very informative for you.U can preapare your case keeping in mind this one.

http://www.canlii.org/eliisa/highlight.do?text=+dependent+child+immigration&language=en&searchTitle=Search+all+CanLII+Databases&path=/en/ca/fct/doc/2007/2007fc279/2007fc279.html

..so that case was political science to history and yet the appeal was denied

 

[Luck786]

Yes because appellant had not enough knowledge of History.
39 has to satisfy the visa officer why his sister changed the studies.
@user 828 ,you gave a good practical reason that she wanted to change her career path.We can come up with some other good reasons too.

 

[ranja]

Hi 39

From your sister's educational history via officer is of the opinion that she was enrolled in random courses just to be a dependent.
In my opinion there shouldn't have been any problem if she had the related subjects or education.
Now all you have to do is give provide reason to eliminate this doubt.You have to expalin why she changed her line and why she was failing the subject ?
So come up with a very very valid reason to cover that.It is upto you now to give satisfactory reasons.I don't think so that you need a good lawyer all you need is a reason to satisfy with some proofs.Any truthful simple explanation even from her teachers why she couldn't pass English and had to take History.

Take care and do little research.

The only reason i suggested talking to a lawyer was because they would have experience with this kind of thing in the past. If he tries to explain this on his own without someone who has experience he might screw up and that would make his sister ineligible for the visa which will through the entire family's plans into a tailspin.

I would spend a lot of time researching it and discussing it with other users before replying to the visa officer.

 

[ranja]

just to start the conversation, i think the switching from computer science to english can be explained as follows.

1. choose computer science so that she could work in the booming computer industry in canada
2. lack of interest in computer due to the impractical or pure theoretical based learning style in India led to the student performing poorly.
3. Switched to English to improve fluency and command over the language so that it can help in better adjustment upon arriving in canada while at the same time learning about the richess of english language.

Once again like i said before, i am not a lawyer and am only sharing my thoughts. feel free to comment.

 

[Luck786]

I was also suggesting him to do a lot of research and then send the reply to visa officer through a lawyer.He needs a lawyer but he really needs a lot of research.
@ ranja your suggestions are really good and have weightage .

What relationship can be shown between Computer and History? Why she took history ? She wanted to be a teacher or what other reason could it be? If she is doing great in History then it would be a plus point for her.right?