+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

NOC 4131 category application rejected

SDESAI1981

Star Member
Jun 9, 2009
164
3
UK
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
Hi
Can you please confirm your ECAS status please.
Many Thanks Desai

Nouvelzelande said:
Hi Desai,
It may sound funny but i didn't get what ECAS is.
@ Rupesh:did u also apply under NOC 4131. I know another person who applied under same category and whom i gave advice regarding the JDs to match it with the JDs listed under NOC 4131 and make it descriptive. His application got approved and is under further processing. So that's why I am thinking of reapplying. What is FSW1?

Thanks
Ram
 

mpapdp.1984

Hero Member
Oct 27, 2009
271
6
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
NOC Code......
4121
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
13-11-2008
AOR Received.
18-03-2009
File Transfer...
27-10-2009
Med's Request
16-04-2010
Med's Done....
29-04-2010 (Reached Ottawa May 4 2010)
Interview........
waived
Guys,

Sorry if this question is a bit unrelated but did any of you who applied under NOC 4131 did NOT give IELTS and were still considered for further processing on the basis that fluency in English is needed for being an instructor? I have applied under NOC 4121 and have not submitted IELTS scores. I have had some initial correspondence with the consulate and they have not requested the scores yet. Am just keeping fingers crossed that they do not ask me to submit the scores.

Thanks
 

Nouvelzelande

Newbie
Dec 16, 2009
9
0
@Harry,
Here is what my friend wrote under JDs. He had 4 yrs teaching experience in his country.
1. taught undergrads with plan of lecture
2. published text based books
3. evaluated studies, prepared and marked tests
4. planned, organized and lead technical projects

@mpapdp:To go through initial processing, u don't need IELTS score. If u get approved, then u need to submit the scores. I have question regarding that. Is it possible that teh IELTS scores can be waived based on the fact that u have completed ur masters in United States? I have heard if you write an essay demonstrating ur proficiency in english in all aspects(listening, writing, reading and speaking), you may not need to submit IELTS if you get lucky. Any thoughts on that??

I had sent my application to Sydney, Canada and the response time for that initial processing was 8-10 weeks
 

jes_ON

VIP Member
Jun 22, 2009
12,091
1,421
Category........
Visa Office......
New York
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
06-May-2010
AOR Received.
13-Aug-2010
File Transfer...
01-Mar-2011
Passport Req..
30-Jun-2011
VISA ISSUED...
12-Jul-2011 (received 25-Jul-2011)
LANDED..........
03-Sep-2011
Nouvelzelande said:
Here are few points that i had written as my JDs
1. tutored undergraduate electronics and computer engineering students(then i mentioned the courses)
2. maintainance of lab equipments
3.planned, organized, lead technical projects
4. instructed lab works(mentioned courses)

My thoughts on why this was not accepted - these sound like teaching assistant duties. "Tutoring" is not "teaching" here.

You would have to be able to demonstrate full course responsibility - designing course curricula, classroom instruction, student evaluation, etc.
 

rupeshhari

VIP Member
Sep 15, 2008
3,686
255
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
NOC Code......
4131
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
Dec 2008 to CIO
Doc's Request.
Jan 2009
AOR Received.
Feb 2009 from VO
IELTS Request
Didn't do IELTS.
File Transfer...
Not transfered to regional office.
Med's Request
July 2010 with RPRF and another PCC.
Med's Done....
Meds - September 2010. PCC - Late Oct 2010
Interview........
Waived
Passport Req..
Early November 2010
VISA ISSUED...
December 2010 - Exactly days shy of 2 years since I sent in my application to CIO.
LANDED..........
2011
That is true. That does sound like a TAing rather than teaching.
 

mpapdp.1984

Hero Member
Oct 27, 2009
271
6
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
NOC Code......
4121
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
13-11-2008
AOR Received.
18-03-2009
File Transfer...
27-10-2009
Med's Request
16-04-2010
Med's Done....
29-04-2010 (Reached Ottawa May 4 2010)
Interview........
waived
Nouvelzelande said:
@ Harry,
Here is what my friend wrote under JDs. He had 4 yrs teaching experience in his country.
1. taught undergrads with plan of lecture
2. published text based books
3. evaluated studies, prepared and marked tests
4. planned, organized and lead technical projects

@ mpapdp:To go through initial processing, u don't need IELTS score. If u get approved, then u need to submit the scores. I have question regarding that. Is it possible that teh IELTS scores can be waived based on the fact that u have completed ur masters in United States? I have heard if you write an essay demonstrating ur proficiency in english in all aspects(listening, writing, reading and speaking), you may not need to submit IELTS if you get lucky. Any thoughts on that??

I had sent my application to Sydney, Canada and the response time for that initial processing was 8-10 weeks

I had written an essay requesting them to waive the ILETS based on my language proficiency. Have not got anything from them yet about sending the scores.
 

rupeshhari

VIP Member
Sep 15, 2008
3,686
255
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
NOC Code......
4131
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
Dec 2008 to CIO
Doc's Request.
Jan 2009
AOR Received.
Feb 2009 from VO
IELTS Request
Didn't do IELTS.
File Transfer...
Not transfered to regional office.
Med's Request
July 2010 with RPRF and another PCC.
Med's Done....
Meds - September 2010. PCC - Late Oct 2010
Interview........
Waived
Passport Req..
Early November 2010
VISA ISSUED...
December 2010 - Exactly days shy of 2 years since I sent in my application to CIO.
LANDED..........
2011
mpapdp.1984 said:
Guys,

Sorry if this question is a bit unrelated but did any of you who applied under NOC 4131 did NOT give IELTS and were still considered for further processing on the basis that fluency in English is needed for being an instructor? I have applied under NOC 4121 and have not submitted IELTS scores. I have had some initial correspondence with the consulate and they have not requested the scores yet. Am just keeping fingers crossed that they do not ask me to submit the scores.

Thanks
I don't think IELTS and the NOC code is related. Anyone with or without IELTS will be treated as such despite the NOC code.
 

mpapdp.1984

Hero Member
Oct 27, 2009
271
6
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
NOC Code......
4121
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
13-11-2008
AOR Received.
18-03-2009
File Transfer...
27-10-2009
Med's Request
16-04-2010
Med's Done....
29-04-2010 (Reached Ottawa May 4 2010)
Interview........
waived
rupeshhari said:
I don't think IELTS and the NOC code is related. Anyone with or without IELTS will be treated as such despite the NOC code.
I guess you are right Rupesh. I'll update the forum if they send me a request for IELTS.

Good luck.
 

Nouvelzelande

Newbie
Dec 16, 2009
9
0
Hello guys,
I have decided to reapply for skilled worker under NOC 4131
I have few queries.
1. I have 2 yrs work experience as lecturer( to undergrad electronics and computer engineering students) in my country. Will that be sufficient?
2. I have 1 year teaching assistant experience in US working 20 hrs a week. Will they also consider it as a teaching experience? If not, in the form Schedule 3, shall i mention it as my work experience? will it fir under NOC 4131?
3. I am in OPT right now in US. IN background declaration form , section #11, personal history, shall i just write unemployed from the day i graduated to present date?
IS there any one who knows a good agent and agent fees?
Since mine application was rejected, i am thinking to be more careful? would it be a good idea?

Thanks
Ram
 

rupeshhari

VIP Member
Sep 15, 2008
3,686
255
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
NOC Code......
4131
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
Dec 2008 to CIO
Doc's Request.
Jan 2009
AOR Received.
Feb 2009 from VO
IELTS Request
Didn't do IELTS.
File Transfer...
Not transfered to regional office.
Med's Request
July 2010 with RPRF and another PCC.
Med's Done....
Meds - September 2010. PCC - Late Oct 2010
Interview........
Waived
Passport Req..
Early November 2010
VISA ISSUED...
December 2010 - Exactly days shy of 2 years since I sent in my application to CIO.
LANDED..........
2011
1) that should be fine as long as you did the duties of a lecturer
2) why dont you count this as TA NOC, you will still get points for it.
3) unemployed is okay, if that is what you are.
 

Nouvelzelande

Newbie
Dec 16, 2009
9
0
Rupesh,
Can u give the NOC code for the TA? So, it will just add to the points but don't count as a experience for NOC 4131?
And any idea about the Agents?
Do u think i should try on my own or take help of agent? Can they make my case little stronger?

Thanks
 

rupeshhari

VIP Member
Sep 15, 2008
3,686
255
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
NOC Code......
4131
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
Dec 2008 to CIO
Doc's Request.
Jan 2009
AOR Received.
Feb 2009 from VO
IELTS Request
Didn't do IELTS.
File Transfer...
Not transfered to regional office.
Med's Request
July 2010 with RPRF and another PCC.
Med's Done....
Meds - September 2010. PCC - Late Oct 2010
Interview........
Waived
Passport Req..
Early November 2010
VISA ISSUED...
December 2010 - Exactly days shy of 2 years since I sent in my application to CIO.
LANDED..........
2011
I am not sure of the code for TA, but if you go to the NOC website and search for 4131, you can see at the end of the page, related NOCs. TA is one of those related NOCs.

No idea about agents. I did it myself. If your application is clear cut, then I would do it myself but if there is something about your points that is not clear cut, maybe they can help.
 

SDESAI1981

Star Member
Jun 9, 2009
164
3
UK
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
Hi Nouvelzelande
Would it be possible for you to confirm your last ECAS status please.
Many Thanks Desai
 

amk

Star Member
Aug 29, 2009
104
1
Category........
Visa Office......
New Dehli
NOC Code......
4131
Job Offer........
App. Filed.......
29-06-2009
Doc's Request.
02-09-2009
AOR Received.
12-11-2009
i got rejection.
no more proceeding to Canada.
 

vahidvahid

Star Member
Jul 11, 2009
74
0
amk said:
i got rejection.
no more proceeding to Canada.
Hi amk,

Sorry for that. what is the reason for this second rejection (your new application)? did you get rejection letter? what has included?