Got the passport today. Here are my details of my adventure. Hope this helps others. First of all, major thanks to everyone (particularly to t1908) and the discussion in the form which really helped.
I am in Toronto. Sent the application over mail to the Gatineau on April 21st. Received on April 24th. Credit card charged on May 20th. Travel plans for June 24th (tomorrow).
I submitted 'track my application' form online on June 8th and got no response. I called the 800 number to request transfer on June 14th and couldn't get through. I called again on 15th right before 8:30am (when the lines open) and was 170ish in the line. Finally got through and asked for the status of the application. The agent requested my date of birth and last name to find the application, however, they couldn't find my application. Requested to transfer the application to Toronto downtown office. The agent used the mailing tracking number to transfer the application and confirmed that the Toronto office has accepted the transfer. The agent told me that the office will call to schedule a pick-up and it may take few days. The agent also said to wait as long as you are comfortable otherwise go to the office (good advice) and, if I go to the office, I can skip the normal line (not true). Waited until June 17th for the call back from Toronto office which never happened.
On June 20th, I went to Toronto downtown office and lined-up at 6:00am. There were likely about 30 people in front of me by that time (to give you a sense of the line: I was the last person before the line continued on Richmond Street). By 6:30, there was at least 10-15 people behind me. Didn't quite track the line after that. Around 7:30am, the security guard split the line (outside the building). They created 2 lines: one for the transfer and one for urgent applications. This was quite chaotic because the security guard wasn't super clear on how the lines are being split (the guard at this location is an incompetent person; he does not listen and speaks incoherently which is hard to understand when you are on the street). Some of the people who had lined up after me got in front of me in that chaos. I was about 15-20th in the transfer line. Finally, staff members from the location came (kudos to them to come before office opening hours) and chatted with every person in the line to answer any questions and also checking if we have got everything. The people in the transfer line were given a form to fill basic information so they can find our application. We were all given numbers (white slip; C series numbers). The other line were also given numbers (pink slip). They also cut the line after some point who were likely told they won't get the service that day. Even though the office opens at 8:30, it seemed some of the staff members were arriving as late as 8:45am. There was no movement in the line until 10:00am. I was inside the building at 11:00am and was welcomed with no waiting seats inside the building (good savings on our tax payer money!). I was at the counter at 11:45am. There were separate counters for the transfers. The person at the counter was super nice and asked for proof of travel, confirmed that the application has been transferred, and scheduled a pick-up for June 23rd (day before the travel). They didn't say anything around the transfer fees so didn't get charge for it. They told me there was no need to line-up for the pick-up. I was out of the building by 11:50am.
On pick-up day on June 23rd. I reached the office around 2:15pm for a 3:00pm pick-up. Only 3 people in the line-up for the pick-up. Unfortunately, they couldn't find my passport and told me to come back around 3:30 - 3:45pm. Reached back the office at 3:35pm. Around 7 people in the line-up for the pick-up. They had the passport this time. Phew! In all of this, I forgot to ask the phone agent or at the passport office about how I will be receiving my citizenship certificate back. If you know, please let me know.
My tips (if you are in the similar situation):
- Call the 800 number right before 8:30am - worked for me
- Once you are with the phone agent, stay on the call and ensure the office has accepted the transfer
- Don't wait for the office to call back if you requested a transfer - most people in the line hadn't received the call back. Go the office even if you are few days in advance to the travel (doesn't need to be 48 hrs)
- If you are going to Toronto downtown location, line-up before 6am and keep an eye on when they start to split the line: this might save you few hours