Bank of Canada seen on hold as Canada loses jobs
OTTAWA — More proof the Canadian economy has cooled emerged Friday with labour data indicating a net 6,600 jobs were lost in September, giving the Bank of Canada additional reasons to refrain from rate hikes in the coming months.
Yet there were bright spots within the data — such as a 37,000 addition in full-time jobs — that gave analysts encouragement about the health of the Canadian economy.
The unemployment rate dropped, to eight per cent, although that was driven by more people opting to stop looking for a job and, among other things, return to school. Plus, the headline job loss was below the consensus call for a 10,000 gain in September.
September marked the second time in three months the economy reported monthly net job losses, following an amazing six-month streak beginning last January in which monthly job growth averaged 51,000. A total 19,900 jobs were created for the three-month period ended Sept. 30.
"There is no denying the fact that employment conditions have cooled markedly from the piping hot pace seen as recently as the spring," said Douglas Porter, deputy chief economist at BMO Capital Markets. "Renewed solid job gains will be tough to come by in the months ahead amid the lacklustre pace of underlying growth that has spilled over from the U.S. into Canada."
Jonathan Basile, vice-president of economics at Credit Suisse in New York, said the labour market is now "taking a pause," just like economic growth did in the second quarter, followed by a contraction in July. "This supports our call for (a pause) from the Bank of Canada at its next Oct 19 meeting."
In recent months, the central bank has raised its trendsetting lending rate from a record low 0.25 per cent to its current level of one per cent. A string of weaker-than-expected economic data has led markets to place very low odds on an October rate hike.
Canada's gross domestic product declined in July for the first time in almost a year, as the economy shrank 0.1 per cent during the month. The July data marked the first monthly contraction since August 2009, when GDP also shrank 0.1 per cent. That had been the only month to show a decline in economic activity since a 10-month string of reduced GDP readings between August 2008 and May 2009. The Bank of Canada had anticipated 3.5 per cent growth this year and 2.9 per cent in 2011, although those projections are expected to be revised downward when the central bank releases its updated economic outlook on Oct. 20.
Still, economists suggested the September employment data mask some underlying strength. Most important, full-time jobs gained for a second straight month, by a robust 37,100, compared to a 43,700 drop in part-time employment. Scotia Capital said this likely represented a conversion of part-time work to full-time work, which is a "mild positive" as it expands hours worked. Full-time jobs are generally better paying and more stable.
A sharp decline of 18,400 self-employed jobs — which people without jobs tend to move toward if they believe prospects will stay bleak — was offset by modest increases of 5,300 in private-sector payrolls, and a 6,500 gain in public-sector payrolls.
On a sector basis, jobs fell in the service-producing sector, 10,100, and but advanced in the key goods-producing industries by 3,500 — led by a 8,200 gain in the key manufacturing region.
Over the course of 2010, the rate of part-time job creation has outpaced full-time and, as a consequence, the number of hours worked remains below the peak level hit prior to the economic downturn, said Dawn Desjardins, assistant chief economist at Royal Bank of Canada.
"At the same time, debt levels have been rising with the household debt-to-income ratio hitting a new high early this year," she said. "The prospect of more moderate growth going forward suggests that labour market conditions will improve more slowly in the months ahead and that the unemployment rate will only gradually drift lower."