I dont know where you are going with those statements. Stop creating misunderstanding among members. All I said was he seems to be a rich refugee. I am not disputing that. Ofcourse I know you dont have to be poor to be a refugee. All I am saying is that his intentions are not clear. You need to stop being judgemental, set yourself as an example first by cheering up and then maybe we will followsyrian-g said:
Asking for Asylum in Canada for Syrians
- Thread starter anjiek
- Start date
As Scylla mentioned earlier, this is erroneous as the Third Safe Country Agreement (http://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/agency-agence/stca-etps-eng.html#a2) clearly states that the OP must apply for Asylum in the US, and can not apply for asylum in Canada via the U.S. unless he/she meets one of the exceptions (family member in Canada, valid Canadian visa, etc.).syrian-g said:
In the same situation, what if a person holds a Canadian transit visa and has a ticket via Toronto to US but applies before arriving to US, right at the Pearson airport? Will they still send him to US? Even though he's not applying from land border? What are the chances they will consider him?torontosm said:
In this case, person can claim refugee status in Canada on landing at Pearson. Chances of success in getting refugee/protected person status eventually? Your guess is as good as mine.Lola-canadian said:
You cannot apply for asylum from Pakistan personally. If you wish to seek asylum personally in Canada you must do so from a POE (Point of Entry). This means you should get a visa that would allow you to come to Canada and when you land, you can make your claim for asylum with the first CBSA officer you encounter.bruce9078 said:
If you wish to remain in Pakistan and file for asylum, you will need to do as Scylla suggested in previous posts and contact the UNHCR to be recommended for asylum status. Whether or not the UNCHR feels you require asylum is up to their rules and regulations and nobody on this forum can advise you in that regard.
Alurra71 said:
Thanks Scylla and Alurra71
Is it important to have a family member in Canada... If yes, will my asylum process get stronger?
At arrival where should i go and file my asylum application? police station or any organization?
Is it important to have a family member in Canada:bruce9078 said:
In general term the answer will be NO it is not important to have a family member in canada to claim protection. blood relative/close family member requirement is only for those who claim refugee protection at USA-CANADA land border. people who make refugee claims inside canada or come to canada by air do not need to have family members in canada.
Refugee claim at US-canada border: people who are in USA (e.g on visit visa. legally living, studying, illegally living etc ) can come on Canadian border and claim a refugee protection (assuming they do not have a visa (TRV) to come to canada). to claim a protection at Canadian border they must have a close relative (spouse, children, parents, brother, sister, uncle, nephew etc ) otherwise they cannot. the reason is as you are already in USA (a safe place) you must make your refugee claim at the first safe place BUT if you have close family you can choose to make your refugee claim at Canadian border to facilitate family reunion. where to make the claim: at Canadian border where they have a RPU (refugee processing unit).
Refugee claim at Canadian airports: any person entering into canada legally or illegally can claim protection/make a refugee claim at airports. for such claim there is NO requirement of close family relatives to be present in canada. where to make the claim: at the airport when you meet the first CBSA officer/immigration officer.
Refugee claim inside canada or once you are in canada: any one who had entered in canada on visit visa (trv), student visa. is already in canada etc, etc.... can make a refugee claim while he is here in canada and he DO NOT need any family member to be present in canada.where to make the claim: You can make a refugee claim in Canada at designated CIC offices which are in almost all major cities.
If you have a family member in canada does it makes the refugee/asylum case stronger:
NO it does not. refugee case is accepted or rejected only the basis/reasons of your claim. a refugee case is only strong if you are unwilling to return because of a well-founded fear of persecution based on race, religion, political opinion, nationality or member of particular social group.
IRB can no way grant you refugee status only for the reason that you have family members living here.
Well said Syrian g .. Some ppl had black heart as the colour of their hair .. I don't know why .. It seems that they will carry the refugees on there head !!!syrian-g said:I know someone who has applied for a refugee In Canada and they hold a residency card of one of the Gulf countries . His refugee was accepted. They are not too strict on Syrians now. So if i were you , i would give it a shot . If they rejected you, they will most likely ask you to go back to the states. Some of the united states are easier on Syrian's refugee, new Jersey is one of them.
If you were accepted in Canada, you will be able to work,study,and get some financial help through the provincial government. But don't look up for that. It is never enough, so you need to be productive in the community .
You can always go on facebook and find Syrians community in Canada,or USA .They have stronger experience.
Keep in mind, there are lots of negative people on this forum,and only few accredited people. So keep asking and don't rely on this forum and ALWAYS take risks.
Like you see an immigrant says BS like he/she doesn't want more immigrants loool
Good Luck man
What if their hair colour is not black? hmm ....hmmmm.....something to think about eh? whether the glass is half empty or half full. Besides if anyone holds a chip on their shoulders about refugees that would be the conservative government. Their policies have made it very hard for refugees to come to Canada, stark contrast from what Canada used to do previously for refugees
Are you Kiiiidddddiiiiinnnnngggg me?!!!! . Can you not see how much money politicians waste here and there for nonsense reasons. Do you want me to list the canceled projects !!!!.Don't you notice increases on the road constructions prior to the election. There is a single street in my city, they have worked on that street four times this year in different occasions, and everytime i ask what is new, the answer is total BS. I am not saying Canada is obligated to help refugees,but please don't play " taxpayer money" card with me !!!!. Conservative initial spend on the airstikes was 90 million $,this money could'v helped our northern fellows more than what has it done in Syria or Iraq, oh no wait, uncle Sam said we have to go,then we have no choice. How many schools could'v been built in Canada with this money or educations funds,or transportation projects. Have you ever been in Japan and see their subway's routes. A small project on 401 takes ages to be completed.torontosm said:
@ Newtone : If you haven't felt the pain from NewImmi's comment, you wouldn't have replied to him. I am not gonna argue with ya, the total dislikes on your profile comparing to the likes and the total number of comments that you have,explained it all.
@ Bruce9078 : Alurra71 and Kriv had better answers than what i could'v written. Their answers are genuine .
Dislike on profile dosent mean squat, i can continue giving you dislikes and 6 months down the road tell you the same thing. So please dont give me this profile dislike non-sense logic.Yes Canada is not obligated. Lets start by how much has your so called Middle Eastern brothers helped you in all this crisis. Lets start with Saudi, UAE, Qatar, Oman, Bahrain and some of the Arab countries in the region. Why havent they taken any Syrian refugees? You gotta remember refugees similar to beggers dont have a choice regardless of how rich or talented they are. Canada is doing its fair share if accepting refugees which I think is beyond generous.Lets start with neighbouring countries, why arent they doing enough? Why target Canada, might as well try settling in the moon. Why does Canada always have to be the sacrificial lamb when it comes to accepting refugees?
So I'm not sure what exactly your point is. Are you saying that since we have so much money to "waste" on airstrikes and road construction, we should give some to the refugees? If so, then I agree. But if you mean that we need to open our borders so the refugees can bypass (i.e., cross through or fly over) numerous other safe havens (including all the GCC countries who haven't taken in a SINGLE refugee to date) to get to Canada, then I don't agree at all.syrian-g said:
Yes, what i am trying to say is that Canada should help and contribute more in saving lives and people in need-no matter who they are-.torontosm said:
GCC countries have resettled many Syrians who were on temporary visas,and built many refugee's camps around that area. Turkey has welcomed around two million Syrians,Jordan 800,000 , Iraq 280,000, Lebanon one third of its population are now Syrians, Germany 800,000, Sweden really high number, France,Norway,ِAustria,and Finland have opened their borders recently to Syrians.
Anyway, i wish if this war hasn't started.