Refusal reasons was home visit by ndvo officers came out negative.one of girl from our neighbor gave a wrong information about our wedding .we mentioned in our application that itz love cum arrange wedding and she said it was arranged by parents.she said she attended the wedding too but they were not invited mnz she and her family never was invited.she said our wedding was in summer but it was winter my husband never flew in a summer .so we prove it by people were wearing winter stuff in wedding .about her that the marriage was arranged we prove it was inter caste marrige very close family members were invited as my mother never want that anybody find out as in initial application we mentioned that only 81 people attended the wedding .we used to have plate system in marriage hall so it was easy to prove with recipts she said it was summer we prove everything by shopping bills, religious place certificate,marriage hall booking and so many recipts.but the officer who interviewed me in new delhi ,he was a white man very nice and polite.he gave me so many chances to prove my concerns but i was so nervous and sick atx that day so refusal and our appeal went so well my husband won the appeal within 4 hours.we hired one of the best lawyer from calgary and we trust him fully.he knows from the beginning that there is no single lie in our application . Credit also goes to very nice minister council and a judge on hearing day. a perfect planing of god,by the god.