How dose IRB know if you visited your home country or used their passport?

[Kaisa_18]

I am curious to know how they would know? And specially how they can get the proof of it since the onus is on them to prove that the protected person/refugee had voluntarily reavailed themself of the protection of their country of nationality. Do people share this information while renewing PR cards, or disclosing it to CBSA when entering the country after that action? Or how? I can't imagine that all countries share the entry/exit information with Canada specially the travel document details (maybe name, dob only) so how would IRB know that this person used their national passport instead of RTD?

EDIT: This thread is not to share opinions on why to use national passport, please answer my specific question above if you know the answer. ***

 

[steaky]

Why do they want to use their national passport? Do they want to continue to consider to be a citizen of the country they try to flee?

 

[Kaisa_18]

Why do they want to use their national passport? Do they want to continue to consider to be a citizen of the country they try to flee?

That wasn't my question.

 

[steaky]

That wasn't my question.

Doesn't mean I cannot ask a question! Look at other threads in this forum. The original poster asked a question and another poster asked their own ones.

 

[Ghess23]

I am curious to know how they would know? And specially how they can get the proof of it since the onus is on them to prove that the protected person/refugee had voluntarily reavailed themself of the protection of their country of nationality. Do people share this information while renewing PR cards, or disclosing it to CBSA when entering the country after that action? Or how? I can't imagine that all countries share the entry/exit information with Canada specially the travel document details (maybe name, dob only) so how would IRB know that this person used their national passport instead of RTD?

EDIT: This thread is not to share opinions on why to use national passport, please answer my specific question above if you know the answer. ***

You have to disclose all your travels in the pr and citizenship application, so unless you are willing to perjure yourself in your applications and citizenship interview then they will know. That has very severe consequences, if they come to find that you lied on your application, they can overturn even you citizenship status, cause you would have gotten it fraudulently. I would NOT recommend this AT ALL. NOT RECOMMENDED.

 

[Kaisa_18]

@Ghess23
That would make sense (voluntary disclosure).

 

[scylla]

I am curious to know how they would know? And specially how they can get the proof of it since the onus is on them to prove that the protected person/refugee had voluntarily reavailed themself of the protection of their country of nationality. Do people share this information while renewing PR cards, or disclosing it to CBSA when entering the country after that action? Or how? I can't imagine that all countries share the entry/exit information with Canada specially the travel document details (maybe name, dob only) so how would IRB know that this person used their national passport instead of RTD?

EDIT: This thread is not to share opinions on why to use national passport, please answer my specific question above if you know the answer. ***

The obvious ones I know about are: airline manifests and immigration records shared with other countries.

 

[canuck78]

Did you get a new passport from your home country or used your old one? CBSA can see that you are a protected person. They also question people if they visit neighbouring countries because it is known that people fly to neighbouring countries and go to a land border.

 

[Kaisa_18]

The obvious ones I know about are: airline manifests and immigration records shared with other countries.

I believe that only 5 countries can share immigration information between them, Canada included, under the "Information-SharingFive Country Conference (FCC)" agreement, are you aware of any other agreements?

 

[Kaisa_18]

Did you get a new passport from your home country or used your old one? CBSA can see that you are a protected person. They also question people if they visit neighbouring countries because it is known that people fly to neighbouring countries and go to a land border.

No I didnt nor I am planning to, it is a serious issue no question about that. I am just curious how IRB (in general) gets to know that someone had violated their refugee status conditions.

 

[Buletruck]

The obvious answer would be arrival/departure stamps in the passport. Since you need to provide copies of current and previous passport stamp for renewals or citizenship, it would become pretty obvious. A new passport would also be a dead give away.
Some, I am sure is based on reasonable suspicion (travelling to a neighbouring country) for further investigation. And withholding relevant information is misrepresentation, and that has no statute limit.

 

[Yuki.03]

No I didnt nor I am planning to, it is a serious issue no question about that. I am just curious how IRB (in general) gets to know that someone had violated their refugee status conditions.

cbsa or ircc agents reports it to IRB. Then they fill to revoke protected person, pr and even citizenship.

 

[Copingwithlife]

I am curious to know how they would know? And specially how they can get the proof of it since the onus is on them to prove that the protected person/refugee had voluntarily reavailed themself of the protection of their country of nationality. Do people share this information while renewing PR cards, or disclosing it to CBSA when entering the country after that action? Or how? I can't imagine that all countries share the entry/exit information with Canada specially the travel document details (maybe name, dob only) so how would IRB know that this person used their national passport instead of RTD?

EDIT: This thread is not to share opinions on why to use national passport, please answer my specific question above if you know the answer. ***

I am curious to know how they would know? And specially how they can get the proof of it since the onus is on them to prove that the protected person/refugee had voluntarily reavailed themself of the protection of their country of nationality. Do people share this information while renewing PR cards, or disclosing it to CBSA when entering the country after that action? Or how? I can't imagine that all countries share the entry/exit information with Canada specially the travel document details (maybe name, dob only) so how would IRB know that this person used their national passport instead of RTD?

EDIT: This thread is not to share opinions on why to use national passport, please answer my specific question above if you know the answer. ***

https://www.cbsa-asfc.gc.ca/btb-pdf/eeair-esaerien-eng.html

Simple , the departure airline sends the Government the information

 

[Toronto1971]

I am curious to know how they would know? And specially how they can get the proof of it since the onus is on them to prove that the protected person/refugee had voluntarily reavailed themself of the protection of their country of nationality. Do people share this information while renewing PR cards, or disclosing it to CBSA when entering the country after that action? Or how? I can't imagine that all countries share the entry/exit information with Canada specially the travel document details (maybe name, dob only) so how would IRB know that this person used their national passport instead of RTD?

EDIT: This thread is not to share opinions on why to use national passport, please answer my specific question above if you know the answer. ***

1- Stupid people tells the truth
2- IRCC can see that from stamps on the passport
No other ways

 

[Simba112]

1- Stupid people tells the truth
2- IRCC can see that from stamps on the passport
No other ways

If there is no physical stamp, Airlines share manifest of all customers from point of origin, CBSA runs them through database for various security and admission reason