+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

Does working as a contractor hinder express entry?

Naturgrl

VIP Member
Apr 5, 2020
44,666
9,428

Copingwithlife

VIP Member
Jul 29, 2018
4,431
2,223
Earth
I want to apply for PR in express entry and I need Canadian Job Experience. Right now I am paying my tax by myself at the end of the year and I am not getting T4.
Some employers classify individuals as on contract to avoid paying payroll taxes etc . If you feel that you should be classified as an employee versus as on contract , you can request the CRA to rule on the issue . If the CRA decides in your favour , then you’d be classified as an employee, meaning a T4 would be issued , and you and your employer have to pay any payroll remittances that would have been due the Federal Government. For your employer that means , penalties & interest , issuing T4’s, and more than likely a closer look into the companies payroll records . For you , you’d have to adjust past tax returns .
For rulings , the CRA will reach out to the employer .


https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/forms-publications/publications/rc4110/employee-self-employed.html#


https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/forms-publications/forms/cpt1.html
 
Last edited:

theonlyone1

Full Member
Aug 4, 2022
27
21
Egypt
Category........
FSW
Is this for CEC or FSW? If Canadian work experience, do you get a T4 from the company for your taxes?
If the company is not Canadian and my work was outside Canada what documents do I need? I can get company reference letter and bank statements for the salary transfers, probably will be hard to get tax docs because I out of country, would that be enough for EE FSW?

Also another story, I'm currently still working there full time while being a student "2 months ago" in Canada (I learned that it's okay since it's remote), I will be filing my global income taxes here and everything, I can use that time for FSW experience as well, right?
 
  • Like
Reactions: felibg

iSaidGoodDay

VIP Member
Feb 3, 2023
4,449
2,377
Kaneda
If the company is not Canadian and my work was outside Canada what documents do I need? I can get company reference letter and bank statements for the salary transfers, probably will be hard to get tax docs because I out of country, would that be enough for EE FSW?

Also another story, I'm currently still working there full time while being a student "2 months ago" in Canada (I learned that it's okay since it's remote), I will be filing my global income taxes here and everything, I can use that time for FSW experience as well, right?
If the company isn't Canadian and you were a contractor with them - you need:
1. Reference letter
2. Contract
 

felibg

Newbie
Apr 1, 2024
1
0
If the company isn't Canadian and you were a contractor with them - you need:
1. Reference letter
2. Contract
So can an independent contractor, who works at a company registered in USA and is working from Nepal (and pays taxes there) claim Full time work experience after working there for a year?

This is the case for me. I get my salary (on papers, contract fee) on same time each month through wise transfer, and then do my own taxes and the contract mentioned that it's for a year. I also have an offer letter stating my annual salary, I work 32 hours per week minimum and employer controls all my tech stack and work, and i get fixed agreed upon salary regardless of company's profits or loss. The only problem is that the contract explicitly mentions that I am an independent contractor and not an employee (neither am i entitled to any of it's benefits), so can i prove my employer-employee relationship, and do i need extra documents?

Thanks.
 

iSaidGoodDay

VIP Member
Feb 3, 2023
4,449
2,377
Kaneda
So can an independent contractor, who works at a company registered in USA and is working from Nepal (and pays taxes there) claim Full time work experience after working there for a year?

This is the case for me. I get my salary (on papers, contract fee) on same time each month through wise transfer, and then do my own taxes and the contract mentioned that it's for a year. I also have an offer letter stating my annual salary, I work 32 hours per week minimum and employer controls all my tech stack and work, and i get fixed agreed upon salary regardless of company's profits or loss. The only problem is that the contract explicitly mentions that I am an independent contractor and not an employee (neither am i entitled to any of it's benefits), so can i prove my employer-employee relationship, and do i need extra documents?

Thanks.
You can claim work experience as a self-employed person. You are not employed by the said employer in your case. You should read more about how to claim this experience and apply as a self-employed person through EE.
 

superNova9

Newbie
Dec 12, 2018
6
0
Hello,

Since 2017, I was working for a company in US when I got accepted for the Express Entry in 2019, I moved to Toronto and I registered a Corporation in Ontario with Triple M Accounting firm based in Toronto. The firm has taken care of the corporation books and I have been working as an employee for newly created corporation. The corporation has a contract with the US company I was previously working for and I am registered as an employee for the corporation. I have been receiving T4 for all the subsequent years and all taxes have been paid throughout, both the company and myself. In 2023, the contract with my US client got over and I have also been working remotely from India since 2021 as I had to take care of family during the pandemic. So overall, I have an experience of around three years, but does this experience fall under the Canadian Work Experience and could I use this for Canadian Experience Class (CEC) or for the Express Entry? I am applying again for the PR as my previous PR got over last month in August 2024.

Theres a lot of good information throughout the thread and if anyone could provide some clarity as to how move forward in my case, I'd highly appreciate it.

Sincerely,
Nova
 

Naturgrl

VIP Member
Apr 5, 2020
44,666
9,428
Hello,

Since 2017, I was working for a company in US when I got accepted for the Express Entry in 2019, I moved to Toronto and I registered a Corporation in Ontario with Triple M Accounting firm based in Toronto. The firm has taken care of the corporation books and I have been working as an employee for newly created corporation. The corporation has a contract with the US company I was previously working for and I am registered as an employee for the corporation. I have been receiving T4 for all the subsequent years and all taxes have been paid throughout, both the company and myself. In 2023, the contract with my US client got over and I have also been working remotely from India since 2021 as I had to take care of family during the pandemic. So overall, I have an experience of around three years, but does this experience fall under the Canadian Work Experience and could I use this for Canadian Experience Class (CEC) or for the Express Entry? I am applying again for the PR as my previous PR got over last month in August 2024.

Theres a lot of good information throughout the thread and if anyone could provide some clarity as to how move forward in my case, I'd highly appreciate it.

Sincerely,
Nova
Experience has to be IN Canada for CEC. It will state that on the IRCC CEC requirements.
 
  • Like
Reactions: superNova9

superNova9

Newbie
Dec 12, 2018
6
0
Thanks for the prompt reply. So you are stating that the work experience is tied to me being physically present in Canada and the work experience would not be considered as Canadian Work Experience if I was to be working remotely for the corporation. In my case, I do have a year of working from Canada before I decided to work remotely, so would I be able to show that I had atleast a year of Canadian Work Experience?

Also, if this experience cannot be used for CEC, would this experience be useful for Express Entry and would they consider it as a relevant work experience considering it is still a Canadian corporation and I am an employee of it?
 

Naturgrl

VIP Member
Apr 5, 2020
44,666
9,428
Thanks for the prompt reply. So you are stating that the work experience is tied to me being physically present in Canada and the work experience would not be considered as Canadian Work Experience if I was to be working remotely for the corporation. In my case, I do have a year of working from Canada before I decided to work remotely, so would I be able to show that I had atleast a year of Canadian Work Experience?

Also, if this experience cannot be used for CEC, would this experience be useful for Express Entry and would they consider it as a relevant work experience considering it is still a Canadian corporation and I am an employee of it?
You can use experience as foreign. For CEC, from the IRCC site:

You must

  • have at least 1 year of skilled work experience in Canada (or an equal amount of part-time work experience) in the 3 years before you apply
  • have gained your work experience by working in Canada while authorized to work under temporary resident status
  • show that you performed:
 
  • Like
Reactions: superNova9

superNova9

Newbie
Dec 12, 2018
6
0
Thank you again. From June 2019 till Oct 2020, I worked in Toronto as a software developer (NOC code 21232) which falls in the TEER 1 category of occupations, so wouldn't that hold as a year of skilled work experience in Canada?

So here's my life's conundrum, I already have the three years of foreign work experience which entails the 50 points and I need this Canadian work experience to get my points above the last CEC cutoff of 508.
 

scylla

VIP Member
Jun 8, 2010
95,730
22,028
Toronto
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
28-05-2010
AOR Received.
19-08-2010
File Transfer...
28-06-2010
Passport Req..
01-10-2010
VISA ISSUED...
05-10-2010
LANDED..........
05-10-2010
Thank you again. From June 2019 till Oct 2020, I worked in Toronto as a software developer (NOC code 21232) which falls in the TEER 1 category of occupations, so wouldn't that hold as a year of skilled work experience in Canada?

So here's my life's conundrum, I already have the three years of foreign work experience which entails the 50 points and I need this Canadian work experience to get my points above the last CEC cutoff of 508.
You don't qualify for CEC since your work experience was longer than 3 years ago. To qualify under CEC, you need a full year of work experience in Canada and that full year of work experience must fall within the last 3 years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: superNova9