+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

Inquiry about being reported or 44(1) issued

monavy

Hero Member
Aug 20, 2013
327
65
I became PR towards end of August 2018. I got PR cards for me and my family. My daughter's PR card expires by Oct 2013 (3 weeks from now), while rest of us our PR cards expire by Jan 2024.

In last 5 years I spent about 50 days in canada. I moved to Canada in Feb 2023 but after 40 days, had to go back due to medical emergency back home Recently I returned to Canada. At the airport, the kiosk we'rre not able to scan my PR cards so I scanned my passports. The lady of cbsa told me to scan PR cards next time and sent me to the referral to another cbsa agent.

The agent checked my passports, PR cards and asked me how long my India visit was. I answered him. After that he let us go without saying anything.

Should I be worried about 44(1) being issued? How do I know if he did make any notes or proceedings against me?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: lossada

Besram

Hero Member
Jun 13, 2019
251
182
I became PR towards end of August 2018. I got PR cards for me and my family. My daughter's PR card expires by Oct 2013 (3 weeks from now), while rest of us our PR cards expire by Jan 2024.

In last 5 years I spent about 50 days in canada. I moved to Canada in Feb 2023 but after 40 days, had to go back due to medical emergency back home Recently I returned to Canada. At the airport, the kiosk we'rre not able to scan my PR cards so I scanned my passports. The lady of cbsa told me to scan PR cards next time and sent me to the referral to another cbsa agent.

The agent checked my passports, PR cards and asked me how long my India visit was. I answered him. After that he let us go without saying anything.

Should I be worried about 44(1) being issued? How do I know if he did make any notes or proceedings against me?
Based on your description above, you were not issued a report for failure to comply with the residency obligation. This would involve a lot more questioning than you were subjected to, and you would have - at the very least - been told about the report and its consequences.
 
  • Like
Reactions: monavy

Torrykitten

Newbie
Sep 21, 2023
6
1
I became PR towards end of August 2018. I got PR cards for me and my family. My daughter's PR card expires by Oct 2013 (3 weeks from now), while rest of us our PR cards expire by Jan 2024.

In last 5 years I spent about 50 days in canada. I moved to Canada in Feb 2023 but after 40 days, had to go back due to medical emergency back home Recently I returned to Canada. At the airport, the kiosk we'rre not able to scan my PR cards so I scanned my passports. The lady of cbsa told me to scan PR cards next time and sent me to the referral to another cbsa agent.

The agent checked my passports, PR cards and asked me how long my India visit was. I answered him. After that he let us go without saying anything.

Should I be worried about 44(1) being issued? How do I know if he did make any notes or proceedings against me?
I'm in the similar situation. May I ask which airport were you at? Thanks!
 

Sugar2016

Hero Member
Jul 21, 2016
294
43
I became PR towards end of August 2018. I got PR cards for me and my family. My daughter's PR card expires by Oct 2013 (3 weeks from now), while rest of us our PR cards expire by Jan 2024.

In last 5 years I spent about 50 days in canada. I moved to Canada in Feb 2023 but after 40 days, had to go back due to medical emergency back home Recently I returned to Canada. At the airport, the kiosk we'rre not able to scan my PR cards so I scanned my passports. The lady of cbsa told me to scan PR cards next time and sent me to the referral to another cbsa agent.

The agent checked my passports, PR cards and asked me how long my India visit was. I answered him. After that he let us go without saying anything.

Should I be worried about 44(1) being issued? How do I know if he did make any notes or proceedings against me?
Based on my experience, If you scan passport instead of PR card, its auto referral for verification. I doubt 44(1) was issued.
 

lossada

Hero Member
Sep 5, 2017
281
81
I became PR towards end of August 2018. I got PR cards for me and my family. My daughter's PR card expires by Oct 2013 (3 weeks from now), while rest of us our PR cards expire by Jan 2024.

In last 5 years I spent about 50 days in canada. I moved to Canada in Feb 2023 but after 40 days, had to go back due to medical emergency back home Recently I returned to Canada. At the airport, the kiosk we'rre not able to scan my PR cards so I scanned my passports. The lady of cbsa told me to scan PR cards next time and sent me to the referral to another cbsa agent.

The agent checked my passports, PR cards and asked me how long my India visit was. I answered him. After that he let us go without saying anything.

Should I be worried about 44(1) being issued? How do I know if he did make any notes or proceedings against me?
it seems to be fake,,,
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cassiano

monavy

Hero Member
Aug 20, 2013
327
65
you got very lucky this time but may not get lucky if you try to leave again before January. You must remain in Canada for the next 2 years. Your daughter needs to remain in Canada for the next 2 years and not leave.
Yes. I am aware I will have to spend 2 years without going out.