I have had similar rejections regarding my sibling. I do not believe that it matters what you do next time, as the application will always fall out of the system because of this rejection. This rejection will be used against her the next time she applies. My brother has been dealing with this since 2013.
I am a citizen of Canada and my brother's application has been rejected three times, despite the fact that my spouse and I both work for the government and make enough money to support him for three weeks. He also has a business of his own and has three children and works as a full-time teacher.
What were reasons for rejection? Three times is a lot. Your being a citizen, having the funds and government jobs is not relevant to his application. Your brother shows his own funds with his own personal bank accounts. Assume he applied on his own.
I mentioned the government jobs to show that between us we make enough funds to support someone visiting for three weeks.
Your job and financial statements are irrelevant. Approval is based on the strength of his profile - travel history, his own funds and ties to home country. Nothing to do with you. In fact, showing you are supporting his visit weakens his profile. IRCC sites states not to buy ticket until approved.
What country are they from? Conditions in that country will certainly make a difference. A business doing well is not enough. His salary from the business has to be good. Only his personal accounts matter not his business accounts because business savings are not meant for personal use. Did any family member apply for asylum? H&C? Is he the only sibling in your home country? Do you have other siblings and do they also live abroad? Is your mother in Canada? What is her status? Is your father deceased?
I find it strange because people from Mexico, a dangerous and unstable country, are not subjected to any of this. They simply need a return ticket and everything to drive to the airport, where they can apply for an eTA. Far too many people here are making excuses for the inhumane approach towards people from "certain countries."
That primarily has to do with the fact that Canada is part of a major trade relationship with Mexico. I would watch for tightening of the rules because too many Mexicans are using Canada to enter the US illegally. Whether a country requires a TRV has very little to do whether it is dangerous and more to do with people staying illegally in Canada or claiming asylum.
If for example you were a citizen of Lebanon there would be huge concerns that you have no intention of returning home to Lebanon if you are able to enter Canada. Most leaving Lebanon for other countries have no plans on returning to Lebanon unless the situation changes dramatically. The same could be said for Argentina where inflation is out of control as well. It isn’t just about danger in a country. The situation in someone’s country has a major impact on whether a person is granted a TRV because one is expected to return home on a TRV.
If you are PR or citizen you should always go with Super visa (meant specially for parents). You can apply again with strong detailed invitation letter stating her ties back in home country with clear purpose of visit , show CA evaluation reports including all movable and immovable assets , Bank certificates
Hello,
