Withdraw an Accepted Refugee Claim

[Babyfaced]

That's misrepresentation, or fraud. You are suggesting people withhold information that they do have to provide.

If she has an ailing parent that she needs to attend to, Cbsa wouldn't take that as a legitimate reason and she risks cessation filled against her.

 

[carolbb23]

Not asking her to break the law, she has private reason for wanting to withdraw her PR application not known to us which might be of grave concern to her, as long as her passport doesn't show stamps that prove she travelled to her home country, she has no case to answer to Cbsa.

but cbsa can ask for tickets where she is coming from If she did any connection cic and cbsa are not stupid has you think they have ways of finding out by computers that is why airlines ask for passports and etc plus the manifest from the plane. it seems to baby face that you would lie at cost to stay in canada

 

[Buletruck]

If she has an ailing parent that she needs to attend to, Cbsa wouldn't take that as a legitimate reason and she risks cessation filled against her.

As a refugee claimant, you can not return to your home country. What's the point of claiming protection from your home country if you are willing to go back? Why would you claim it in the first place if that was the case. When you make a refugee claim, you need to be aware and prepared that you can't go home. Read up on CALii about some of the cases. Not everyone will have their PR revoked, but they certainly seem to be making a concerted effort to address people who do and abuse the refugee system.

 

[vensak]

Not asking her to break the law, she has private reason for wanting to withdraw her PR application not known to us which might be of grave concern to her, as long as her passport doesn't show stamps that prove she travelled to her home country, she has no case to answer to Cbsa.

It does not matter the reasons why she wants to return (except if she was taken there against her own will - like abducted or something).
Claiming refuge is telling that your own country fails to protect you and that you are unable to be there.
Returning until citizenship is no option - regardless if your mother is dying of cancer or your brother went to jail.

And no stamp in the passport does not mean that her name did not end up in some kind of international database for incomers.

Getting refuge in other country and then returning back in your own country means, that you do not need that refuge anymore.

 

[carolbb23]

As a refugee claimant, you can not return to your home country. What's the point of claiming protection from your home country if you are willing to go back? Why would you claim it in the first place if that was the case. When you make a refugee claim, you need to be aware and prepared that you can't go home. Read up on CALii about some of the cases. Not everyone will have their PR revoked, but they certainly seem to be making a concerted effort to address people who do and abuse the refugee system.

Basically is like saying she's a refugee by conivence

 

[basheerh]

Thank you all for answering my questions.

What about other option by getting temporary travel document to go somewhere else (other than her home country)? Is that easy?
What is required to do this?

Thanks!

 

[carolbb23]

Thank you all for answering my questions.

What about other option by getting temporary travel document to go somewhere else (other than her home country)? Is that easy?
What is required to do this?

Thanks!

we see but pr is better

 

[North Star]

Thank you all for answering my questions.

What about other option by getting temporary travel document to go somewhere else (other than her home country)? Is that easy?
What is required to do this?

Thanks!

That's what most people do in any neighbouring country whee ur spouse/ family can come easily join them, greet them, and stay 3 months together or so, and then fly back to canada, violla no problem at all and in the mean time your spouse also get pr status abroad to join u in canada, what else u want, and later u will have ur Canadian citizenship, and passport travel any where in the world where ever u like.

 

[carolbb23]

That's what most people do in any neighbouring country whee ur spouse/ family can come easily join them, greet them, and stay 3 months together or so, and then fly back to canada, violla no problem at all and in the mean time your spouse also get pr status abroad to join u in canada, what else u want, and later u will have ur Canadian citizenship, and passport travel any where in the world where ever u like.






that is true bUT maybe his sister in law is tired of waiting for everything

 

[vensak]

tired of waiting more or less mean, that the claim was not that serious at all.
Going for refuge more or less means that you have nothing to loose. That even precarious status in Canada and lot of waiting (but still feeling safe) is better than being at home.
That is the moment when you understand that you may not be able to recontact your countrymen or your family again. And if you will be able to do that, then most likely you will not be able to help them.

That what it is. Because your fear of your own safety and life is persistent.

And yes, she can ask to withdraw her status.
Again, I think, that the only valid reason to do so would be, if in the mean time there was some change of regime in her country (or a war has ended there) and she feels safe again to return.
In that case there will be little to no consequences back home.
If however nothing has changed, then it could be regarded as convenience refugee with all the possible consequences mentioned here.

 

[carolbb23]

tired of waiting more or less mean, that the claim was not that serious at all.
Going for refuge more or less means that you have nothing to loose. That even precarious status in Canada and lot of waiting (but still feeling safe) is better than being at home.
That is the moment when you understand that you may not be able to recontact your countrymen or your family again. And if you will be able to do that, then most likely you will not be able to help them.

That what it is. Because your fear of your own safety and life is persistent.

And yes, she can ask to withdraw her status.
Again, I think, that the only valid reason to do so would be, if in the mean time there was some change of regime in her country (or a war has ended there) and she feels safe again to return.
In that case there will be little to no consequences back home.
If however nothing has changed, then it could be regarded as convenience refugee with all the possible consequences mentioned here.

if she does that she can never come back to.canada sp basically she wasted everyone's time when there is legitimate cases out there