There is some interesting discussion going on here.
If we accept your argument, it would mean only uneducated and family-less people move to countries such as USA and Australia.
There is no real healthcare in the US even after u get sponsored and people immigrate there all the time. I personally know a bunch of people who have moved to Australia as well and they are unable to sponsor their parents. They are not planning on moving back either. I dont think being able to bring parents with them is a major criteria for most immigrants. It is definitely a nice benefit for those of us living here to be even eligible to do. Infact, when moving here or elsewhere, people look at job opportunities and quality of life for their kids. Yes, most of us care about our parents, otherwise we wouldnt try to bring them here. But even if I was unable to bring my parents here with or without healthcare, I would still immigrate because the opportunity I got here was much better than in my home country and at the end of the day most immigrants are looking for the same.
If we could not sponsor our parents to come here, we would do what most immigrants have been doing for generations...travel more frequently to home country and send more money to sustain them.
If PGP stops, immigrants would still come in drives. Its not like there are other options which are better than Canada.
With the way this is going, I dont think Canada will keep the PGP program as is for too long. It is definitely a huge strain on the economy and life expectancy is only going up. Same goes for all the benefits that public servants get. A lot of the things that make Canada so attractive doesn't scale when population keeps on rising and the majority of them are senior.
hoveran said:
If the PGP requires sponsors to pay for health care, guess who would have applied for immigrating to Canada?
Canada wants to attract skilled young people. Mostly likely these people are from a country that is relatively well run and they themselves and their family aren't doing bad in their home country either. Thus most likely their parents have access to decent health care at reasonable cost in their home country. If a potential immigrant to Canada knew her parents won't be able to reunite with her in Canada due to the prohibitive medical cost, why would she immigrate to Canada? She is not crazy, right? Staying in home country is much better choice.
Then who will come to Canada instead? those whose parents are already dead and who don't have reasonable health care solution in their home country. These people are either old or uneducated and unskilled. Why would Canada want to attract these people to immigrate to Canada?
So hey Canada, there is no free lunch in the world. There is no such thing that you can grab the people educated by other countries to contribute to your economy without paying any cost. If you want to attract good immigrants, you need to pay the price.