Mine was re-created the day they announced last year and got the NOI within 24 hours. So, I don't know what would exactly constitute a new profile but definitely one created right now would be new.
The below is from the OINP FAQ page (
http://www.ontarioimmigration.ca/en/pnp/OI_PNP_EE_CAPITAL_FAQ.html):
- I meet Ontario’s stream criteria. Why haven’t I received a Notification of Interest?
Express Entry is Citizenship and Immigration Canada application management system to manage permanent resident applications for skilled migration to Canada.
Ontario uses Express Entry (EE) to select potential nominees for permanent residence under two Ontario Express Entry Streams.
It has come to our attention that technical issues may have resulted in candidates not receiving a Notification of Interest (NOI) though they believe they meet the criteria for Ontario’s Express Entry streams. If you believe you fall into this category and have not received an NOI after one month of submitting your EE profile, we encourage you to create a new profile in the EE system. If you create a new EE profile, you must delete your old profile.
So, I am assuming a profile created within the last one month would be considered as new.
With 2750 ITAs being issued and draws happening every 2 weeks, CRS 441 is good enough to get a direct ITA.