PR Refused

[indianguy11]

Hello,

My PR under CEC has been refused. My AOR was 1st Feb and received the refusal letter just now. The reason is - "He did not provide a job descriptions nor were any duties listed on his Express Entry profile". This is true, my job letter was not adequate as per CEC requirements. Can I repeal the decision if I am able to procure a new updated letter now? Or do I have to reapply from the start? Please help @legalfalcon ! I should also probably get in touch with an Immigration Lawyer now. Can anyone please suggest a good firm?

 

[legalfalcon]

Hello,

My PR under CEC has been refused. My AOR was 1st Feb and received the refusal letter just now. The reason is - "He did not provide a job descriptions nor were any duties listed on his Express Entry profile". This is true, my job letter was not adequate as per CEC requirements. Can I repeal the decision if I am able to procure a new updated letter now? Or do I have to reapply from the start? Please help @legalfalcon ! I should also probably get in touch with an Immigration Lawyer now. Can anyone please suggest a good firm?

It is your responsibility to file a complete application. There is no appeal process. You can request a reconsideration, which will be refused since you did not meet the criteria.

Also, you can file a judicial review.

Ideally, you should create a profile and enter the pool again.

 

[sumitsaurav]

Hello,

My PR under CEC has been refused. My AOR was 1st Feb and received the refusal letter just now. The reason is - "He did not provide a job descriptions nor were any duties listed on his Express Entry profile". This is true, my job letter was not adequate as per CEC requirements. Can I repeal the decision if I am able to procure a new updated letter now? Or do I have to reapply from the start? Please help @legalfalcon ! I should also probably get in touch with an Immigration Lawyer now. Can anyone please suggest a good firm?

was your eligibility got passed it before?

 

[indianguy11]

was your eligibility got passed it before?
I am not sure. never asked for gcms notes. profile said bg check in progress

It is your responsibility to file a complete application. There is no appeal process. You can request a reconsideration, which will be refused since you did not meet the criteria.

Also, you can file a judicial review.

Ideally, you should create a profile and enter the pool again.

Yes, reapplying again seems like the most straightforward option. A few more questions please,
1. Would it matter if this time my wife is the primary applicant? She can claim points for her job as well.
2. I have BOWP till April '22. That's still valid, right?
3. We plan to re-apply from our home country. Is there any reason why we should apply from within Canada only?

Thanks for your time.

 

[Kumar25]

Hello,

My PR under CEC has been refused. My AOR was 1st Feb and received the refusal letter just now. The reason is - "He did not provide a job descriptions nor were any duties listed on his Express Entry profile". This is true, my job letter was not adequate as per CEC requirements. Can I repeal the decision if I am able to procure a new updated letter now? Or do I have to reapply from the start? Please help @legalfalcon ! I should also probably get in touch with an Immigration Lawyer now. Can anyone please suggest a good firm?

I would strongly recommend that you reapply. I got my CEC application refusal in May 2021 and I submitted a reconsideration request but the file has not been reopened yet. It's just a waste of time.

 

[sumitsaurav]

@indianguy11 In your gcms was the eligibility passed or anytime you spoke to an agent in regards to your eligibility as you waited for 8 months did any time you contacted so that you could have corrected all those details

 

[indianguy11]

@indianguy11 In your gcms was the eligibility passed or anytime you spoke to an agent in regards to your eligibility as you waited for 8 months did any time you contacted so that you could have corrected all those details

I only seriously started inquiring in August when the 6 months completed. Before that tried the call centre a few times but to no avail.

 

[Kumar25]

@indianguy11 In your gcms was the eligibility passed or anytime you spoke to an agent in regards to your eligibility as you waited for 8 months did any time you contacted so that you could have corrected all those details

Hi Sumit,
Eligibility pass doesn't guarantee that your application will be approved at a later stage. According to GCMS notes, my application got refused after I passed eligibility, that too 9 months after I submitted my application.

 

[sumitsaurav]

Hi Sumit,
Eligibility pass doesn't guarantee that your application will be approved at a later stage. According to GCMS notes, my application got refused after I passed eligibility, that too 9 months after I submitted my application.

agreed, but it would be very rarely I have seen the application got rejected after Eligibility and security have been passed. Sorry, I know you have been unlucky here. Eligibility assessment itself means officers need to assess on all fronts by both the program assistant and senior officer.As per my understanding, Eligligy is only passed by the senior office once it is all reviewed.

 

[Siraj22]

Hi Sumit,
Eligibility pass doesn't guarantee that your application will be approved at a later stage. According to GCMS notes, my application got refused after I passed eligibility, that too 9 months after I submitted my application.

Quick question did your GCMS notes show Final: Approved ? Before you received refusal ?

 

[Kumar25]

Quick question did your GCMS notes show Final: Approved ? Before you received refusal ?

Last note before refusal was "Ready for RPRF" which means it was about to be approved and then refused strangely.

 

[Kumar25]

agreed, but it would be very rarely I have seen the application got rejected after Eligibility and security have been passed. Sorry, I know you have been unlucky here. Eligibility assessment itself means officers need to assess on all fronts by both the program assistant and senior officer.As per my understanding, Eligligy is only passed by the senior office once it is all reviewed.

I am not sure how that works. Initially, my file was in Ottawa VO where eligibility was cleared then it got transferred to Edmonton VO, where it was refused

 

[sumitsaurav]

I am not sure how that works. Initially, my file was in Ottawa VO where eligibility was cleared then it got transferred to Edmonton VO, where it was refused

hmm, I have seen your PR got refused bcoz of NOC mismatch and Job duties. How have you corrected this time?

 

[Kumar25]

hmm, I have seen your PR got refused bcoz of NOC mismatch and Job duties. How have you corrected this time?

How did you find out? Not NOC mismatch exactly, the officer wasn't convinced that I have 1 year of Canadian Work Experience (which was wrong evaluation on his part, according to the job letter I had more than 1.5 yr experience at the time of my application)
and also he wasn't satisfied with the job letter provided by my employer. ( However, the 1st officer was satisfied with the job letter)

I got a new employment letter with more details that would clear all the doubts and submitted it for reconsideration along with paystubs and T4's for last two years.

 

[sumitsaurav]

How did you find out? Not NOC mismatch exactly, the officer wasn't convinced that I have 1 year of Canadian Work Experience (which was wrong evaluation on his part, according to the job letter I had more than 1.5 yr experience at the time of my application)
and also he wasn't satisfied with the job letter provided by my employer. ( However, the 1st officer was satisfied with the job letter)

I got a new employment letter with more details that would clear all the doubts and submitted it for reconsideration along with paystubs and T4's for last two years.

Oh okay..I just read your older post in other chat group