+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

PR Refused under CEC

planetch

Star Member
Jan 10, 2020
110
104
Thanks Jes_ON! Your guidance has been really valuable. Hoping for positive response on re evaluation request. I have another question which i will ask post re evaluation result is shared.

It is about next steps but i want hold on to that for now and dont want to confuse everyone with multiple questions.
 

planetch

Star Member
Jan 10, 2020
110
104
So still waiting on web form query result but i understand its just a query portal may not entertain reconsideration request.

However, i met one of friend on weekend (works on same org, same NOC code and had submitted same letter) but he got invited through Ontario PNP and his PR was approved last year. So i wanted to find if he got 50 point for job offer and he had requested GCMS report (it has all details of individual's case and all comments by VO etc.) and i found that he was awarded 50 point for job offer from that report. When he applied PR, his ICT WP had only 6 month left so theoretically speaking he also did not have 1 year of job guarantee post PR approval, at the time of application.

So after looking at my scenario and many other here, i believe its case of pure bad luck that VO decided to reject the application. I see my file was in Edmonton office and VO code starts with KK03***
 
  • Like
Reactions: dinkarinjosh

jes_ON

VIP Member
Jun 22, 2009
12,091
1,421
Category........
Visa Office......
New York
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
06-May-2010
AOR Received.
13-Aug-2010
File Transfer...
01-Mar-2011
Passport Req..
30-Jun-2011
VISA ISSUED...
12-Jul-2011 (received 25-Jul-2011)
LANDED..........
03-Sep-2011
So still waiting on web form query result but i understand its just a query portal may not entertain reconsideration request.

However, i met one of friend on weekend (works on same org, same NOC code and had submitted same letter) but he got invited through Ontario PNP and his PR was approved last year. So i wanted to find if he got 50 point for job offer and he had requested GCMS report (it has all details of individual's case and all comments by VO etc.) and i found that he was awarded 50 point for job offer from that report. When he applied PR, his ICT WP had only 6 month left so theoretically speaking he also did not have 1 year of job guarantee post PR approval, at the time of application.

So after looking at my scenario and many other here, i believe its case of pure bad luck that VO decided to reject the application. I see my file was in Edmonton office and VO code starts with KK03***
Alternatively, the VO in your friend´s case made a mistake. VOs do make mistakes, sometimes in favor of the applicant - you shouldn´t expect them to make the same mistake for you. More likely, since he had the OINP nomination for 600 pts, there was no point in reviewing the valid job offer claim.
 

Priyanka2206

Newbie
Jun 12, 2020
5
1
So still waiting on web form query result but i understand its just a query portal may not entertain reconsideration request.

However, i met one of friend on weekend (works on same org, same NOC code and had submitted same letter) but he got invited through Ontario PNP and his PR was approved last year. So i wanted to find if he got 50 point for job offer and he had requested GCMS report (it has all details of individual's case and all comments by VO etc.) and i found that he was awarded 50 point for job offer from that report. When he applied PR, his ICT WP had only 6 month left so theoretically speaking he also did not have 1 year of job guarantee post PR approval, at the time of application.

So after looking at my scenario and many other here, i believe its case of pure bad luck that VO decided to reject the application. I see my file was in Edmonton office and VO code starts with KK03***
So still waiting on web form query result but i understand its just a query portal may not entertain reconsideration request.

However, i met one of friend on weekend (works on same org, same NOC code and had submitted same letter) but he got invited through Ontario PNP and his PR was approved last year. So i wanted to find if he got 50 point for job offer and he had requested GCMS report (it has all details of individual's case and all comments by VO etc.) and i found that he was awarded 50 point for job offer from that report. When he applied PR, his ICT WP had only 6 month left so theoretically speaking he also did not have 1 year of job guarantee post PR approval, at the time of application.

So after looking at my scenario and many other here, i believe its case of pure bad luck that VO decided to reject the application. I see my file was in Edmonton office and VO code starts with KK03***
Hi, was your PR approved?
 

arghya009

Hero Member
Sep 19, 2019
232
34
Hi, I claimed 50 points and submitted by documents. I have submitted reference letter and offer letter which I employer used for work
Permit extension. My work permit valid till 14th Aug 2022, which is also mentioned in my employer letter. Also offer of employment number provided. Do you see any chance of approval??
 

Suryarao611

Hero Member
Sep 23, 2020
358
140
Hi, I claimed 50 points and submitted by documents. I have submitted reference letter and offer letter which I employer used for work
Permit extension. My work permit valid till 14th Aug 2022, which is also mentioned in my employer letter. Also offer of employment number provided. Do you see any chance of approval??
I'm also in same boat but never used the offer letter, I have just attached the offer letter/invitation letter for my experience and attached my expired work permit and my latest pay stub and compensation letter received recently.
 

arghya009

Hero Member
Sep 19, 2019
232
34
I'm also in same boat but never used the offer letter, I have just attached the offer letter/invitation letter for my experience and attached my expired work permit and my latest pay stub and compensation letter received recently.
Offer letter means I submitted the letter which my employer filled to IRCC for my work permit extension request. I attached my expired and new work permit both. Also submitted all paystubs of last 2 years. Submitted a reference letter where it’s mentioned that I will be working on Canada as a full time employee going forward as well
 

Suryarao611

Hero Member
Sep 23, 2020
358
140
Offer letter means I submitted the letter which my employer filled to IRCC for my work permit extension request. I attached my expired and new work permit both. Also submitted all paystubs of last 2 years. Submitted a reference letter where it’s mentioned that I will be working on Canada as a full time employee going forward as well
Same here my employer had specified in the letter stating the associate will be working for additional 24 months in the letter and the letter has all my duties and responsibilities. But I'm not claiming this as job offer instead using it only for my experience. Will this work?
 

chhatbarjignesh

Star Member
Dec 28, 2020
186
80
Category........
CEC
Job Offer........
Yes
App. Filed.......
08/09/2020
Nomination.....
08/01/2021
AOR Received.
11/01/2021
1. What kind of work permit did you have, and what kind of work permit will you have when it is renewed? (Is or has your employer applied for an LMIA?) - Its closed work permit and will be same post renewal as well. LMIA is exempted for org that i work.

1.a. If the job is LMIA-exempt, had you worked for the same employer for at least one year before applying? - I work for same employer since 2014 in India and since Sept 17 in Canada.

2. What was the exact wording of the employment term in the job offer letter? Was it an offer of employment for at least one year after you become a permanent resident? i found these lines - Your overseas assignment at Canada shall be for a period of twelve (12) months from the “Date of Travel”. This period of deputation shall not be extended unless communicated in writing.


Do you think these lines played key role in refusal? However, these are standard letters given everyone who travels on overseas assignments. I know many of my colleagues on same NOC code with same letters, have got their PR approved.

Thanks!
looks like it. Did you had any other document that says in writing