Your situation is very different. The other person only had one part time semester which is allowed if that part time semester is your last one. You had two part time semesters which definitely is not allowed for a PGWP. If you reapply, you should be expecting another refusal unfortunately.Did you end-up getting your PGWP after second try? I'm in a similar situation. I had to do two part-time terms. My first PGWP application got refused, I applied again a few days ago (still in the 90 day time window).
It would really help if you share your experience
And to answer your question, no this person did not end up getting a PGWP. I believe they even tried appealing and still failed to get it.