Hi Derek, I agree with you.
There are some confusing or maybe contracting statements on the IRCC website as regards this new policy.
While doing some online research over the weekend, I went through the recent update on IRCC's website which now allows family members of foreign workers in TEER 4 and 5 work categories to apply for Open Work Permits. I had to read through the new policy several times because it sounded confusing to me initially. Kindly open the link below, and then, please scroll down to the section "Family Members of Post Graduate Work Permit (PGWP) applicants".
https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/corporate/publications-manuals/operational-bulletins-manuals/temporary-residents/foreign-workers/public-policy-competitiveness-economy/c47-c48.html
I have copied the first 3 paragraphs and pasted them below:
Family members of Post Graduate Work Permit (PGWP) applicants
Family members of PGWP applicants cannot be issued an open work permit if the PGWP applicant is working without work permit under R186(w). The PGWP applicant remains working under R186(w) until the actual work permit is issued.
At the time of the PGWP application submission, the study permit holder and the family member(s) can submit their different work permit applications as a family group.
As with the family group outside Canada, the principal foreign national’s PGWP application would be assessed first, and then the family member’s open work permit application would be finalized.
..............end
From the above, the first paragraph seems to contradict paragraphs 2 and 3. What I can deduce from the above is that at the time of the decision on the family member's application, the principal applicant's application must have been assessed and found okay (i,e the PGWP applicant working in Teer 4 or 5 job category).
This same issue that I had here also applies to the eligibility criteria at the beginning of the link sent.
My takeaway from the above is that a family member can be issued a work permit if the PGWP (primary) applicant working in Teer 4 or 5 job category has been assessed and confirmed okay to be issued a regular work permit. As long as they both applied together, the family member's work permit can be issued about the same day or a few days after.