LemonLuv said:
Hello,
My aunt's application for MPNP was denied and here is the reason (She is a 2012 applicant):
"Applicant has satisfactorily demonstrated the ability and intent to establish successfully in
Manitoba and there were no retention issues identified" - Answer is "NO"
What could be the reason why she was assessed this way?
- Is it because she has a sister in Vancouver? (But her MB spportter is also her sister)
- Is it because her settlement plan wasn't strong enough
- Is it because she was already 58 yo and the point she got in Age is 0? (But she is a PHD)
Please help me.
Thanks
First of all, thanks to share this here, I think this is very important to know, and learn how they are thinking in order to not loose time.
My opinion about your Aunt´s application is:
Looking for whom/"features" that the Manitoba is looking for: They are 5:
1- Employability
2- Education
3- Language
4- Age
5- Adaptability
And thinking about the main reason of this immigration program: - That is Improve and Contribute to local grow, make sense to me that the main reason, remain in number 4 (Age).
The average retirement age in Canada is around 65, than your relative will contribute (taxing and so on...) around only 5 or 6 years top (you need discount the period of time to get the Visa and settlement process...) and after this, the government will need to take care of your relative.
After this main reason, you can add others "small things", like the field of your Aunt expertise, perhaps is not in the objective that they are looking for, maybe not a high IELTS level, and having a sister out side of Manitoba also is important.
If you some all this together, the settlement plan can be the best one, but the Profile does not fit in the Program requirement.
Any way, this is only an opinion, you should not discard the possibility to inquire the program, asking for more details, and try to send a asking for decision review, where (if your Aunt are able) to prove that can contribute more than only 5 years, that the intent is remain in Manitoba, and other points that you think is relevant.
Hope to help in some way.