+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

lawsuit against bill c24

razana

Newbie
May 15, 2015
6
0
hello,
I have 1 question only
I heard about lawsuit against bill c24 started by mr.Lorne Wildman.
does anybody know when is the final judgement in it?
 

nope

Hero Member
Oct 3, 2015
301
52
I don't know how it's going, but I'm certain that it will only be a lawsuit against certain aspects of bill C-24 -- not the whole bill. The Canadian government has the right to change the terms of qualifying for citizenship. What are you hoping this lawsuit will do?
 

razana

Newbie
May 15, 2015
6
0
well, Frankly I don't have high expectation but I am trying to be optimistic.
I hope after the lawsuit the government starts making action on the citizenship act including actions on residency and language requirements, processing times and the time credit before getting the PR.
 

itsmyid

Champion Member
Jul 26, 2012
2,250
649
razana said:
hello,
I have 1 question only
I heard about lawsuit against bill c24 started by mr.Lorne Wildman.
does anybody know when is the final judgement in it?
It will just be a waste of time...
 

nope

Hero Member
Oct 3, 2015
301
52
razana said:
well, Frankly I don't have high expectation but I am trying to be optimistic.
I hope after the lawsuit the government starts making action on the citizenship act including actions on residency and language requirements, processing times and the time credit before getting the PR.
Well, the lawsuit isn't going to have any effect on residency and language requirements -- there is no way that those aren't legal. I would be VERY surprised if the current government decided that it was a priority to change these. They are just in office, they want to do some ambitious things, and I don't see how headlines like "Trudeau Plans To Cheapen Canadian Citizenship" will help them maintain support.

Processing times have nothing to do with the lawsuit, they have nothing to do with the law, and they are already far faster than in the past.

The only thing that the lawsuit might change is the requirement to swear intent to continue residing in Canada, which all the evidence indicates is a legal formality anyway.
 

Bigudi

Hero Member
May 22, 2015
377
17
Montreal
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
27-05-2015
AOR Received.
20-07-2015
LANDED..........
08-08-2011
razana said:
well, Frankly I don't have high expectation but I am trying to be optimistic.
I hope after the lawsuit the government starts making action on the citizenship act including actions on residency and language requirements, processing times and the time credit before getting the PR.
I completely understand why someone would want to have changes in time credit for PR, and residency requirements. But language requirements? Really? Do you really think the citizenship process demands too much in terms of language requirements? I think they are very soft in this matter.
Language is the number one requirement inf the goal is to integrate one to his new society and community.
 

subha_1962

Hero Member
Dec 20, 2013
265
24
Razana,

Please read the conversation thread on topic "Bringing Back 3 Year Residency by Repealing Bill C-24" started by morgan. There are also two petitions against bill c 24 and would be helpful as many as can would sign it
 

tarikMontreal

Full Member
Mar 22, 2015
30
5
yes there is no news about the lawsuits but it is supposed to be in January


Harper took care of the immigrants before his golden retirement.
 

subha_1962

Hero Member
Dec 20, 2013
265
24
All through the election campaign the liberals maintained that they promises to repeal (unfair elements) of bill c 24. Remember "A Canadian is a Canadian is a Canadian". Much of the sway towards Trudeau was based on this promise ( Harper's dictatorship helped of course). Now we must not let the liberals forget their promise
 

Canadiandesi2006

Champion Member
Mar 6, 2014
1,126
41
Visa Office......
Scarborough, Toronto
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
Oct 2015 (Re-applied)
Before leaving, Steven Harper renewed employment contracts lot of his henchmen called "Bureaucrats" in various key positions.

These bureaucrats will payback by continuing to implement Harper's visions and tarnish Trudeau's polices to make him look bad & failure.

One way or other they would drag their feet in everything to improve that would expose Harper's past failures.

Unless all Federal agencies are sanitized of past political appointees, there cannot be any real improvement. Possibly, every change for improvement is facing tough resistance from Harper's moles. All they want to see that Trudeau fail and people think Harper was better.

Harper tried to use the race card like what Trump doing in USA. Thanks to all Canadians who raised above that and voted for real change.
 

Politren

Hero Member
Jan 16, 2015
470
149
It is also interesting fact that despite all the attempts this law to be challenged none of them is successful.

There is also no practical indication that something will be changed soon.
 

surgi

Star Member
Feb 20, 2014
140
14
Bigudi said:
I completely understand why someone would want to have changes in time credit for PR, and residency requirements. But language requirements? Really? Do you really think the citizenship process demands too much in terms of language requirements? I think they are very soft in this matter.
Language is the number one requirement inf the goal is to integrate one to his new society and community.
the language and knowledge of Canada requirements in the new law arenot fair. The age requirements to ask 14 year old and above 55 year old persons to pass exams is too much stress on some of them especially older ages. The interview is fair enough for these ages and during the interview the officer can judge the situation . All these tricks in the laws were done deliberately to slow down the flow of new citizens to the list of voters to help conservatives to keep power in their hands. You will never strengthen citizenship by making the process more difficult. You will strengthen citizenship by helping people to integrate in the society and offering them facilities to do so.
 

surgi

Star Member
Feb 20, 2014
140
14
I do not believe that any lawsuite will change the law, because they do not do that. They only say if it is constitutional or not. The laws change by the parliament . So concentrate on working with your PM and the minister of Immigration. The liberals gave promises for which more than 3 millions moved and voted for the them more than the previous elections in 2011. I think they commit a mistake if they slow down their promises and leave hundreds of thousands of people fall under the effect of the new citizenship law introduced by the conservatives. Those people will feel that they did not get benefits from the new government and they may lose their voting and vote for NDP for example. I think to get the fruits of their victory and the mistakes of Harper liberals should act fast and repeal this law.
 

subha_1962

Hero Member
Dec 20, 2013
265
24
A Canadian is a Canadian is a Canadian": PM Trudeau, repeal Bill C-24

This is the heading of one of the petitions against bill c 24. All who want change should sign more petitions as it adds on for the voices against it