Initially, I thought its only Vegreville office, but i guess CIC in general seems to be having some issues these days. Making inconsistent decisions, applying laws retroactively, rejecting one application and accepting the other with exactly the same situation or simply not attaching documents with the email.
Not sure if last year's Vegreville drama is being repeated again.
http://www.sunnewsnetwork.ca/sunnews/politics/archives/2012/07/20120723-072542.html
But guys, please do keep sharing your stories. It might help you as well, incase you learned that someone else's application with exactly similar situation was accepted.