+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445
Dear All,

I have been a silent watcher of the thread and today was my interview. Wanted to share my story.
NOC code 1112
current designation and jD Sr. Financial Analyst

I was rejected in today interview on grounds that I do not fit in NOC code 1112. The interview was thoroughly technical, I was getting a feeling whether this was a immigration or job interview. I was asked generic questions like
a.developing debt portfolio risk profile
b. capital management and risk involved

I do not what to do!!!

thanks
Danish
 
danishfareed said:
Dear All,

I have been a silent watcher of the thread and today was my interview. Wanted to share my story.
NOC code 1112
current designation and jD Sr. Financial Analyst

I was rejected in today interview on grounds that I do not fit in NOC code 1112. The interview was thoroughly technical, I was getting a feeling whether this was a immigration or job interview. I was asked generic questions like
a.developing debt portfolio risk profile
b. capital management and risk involved

I do not what to do!!!

thanks
Danish

So sorry to hear this Danish, would you mind sharing you JD you provided to CIC initially?
 
danishfareed said:
Dear All,

I have been a silent watcher of the thread and today was my interview. Wanted to share my story.
NOC code 1112
current designation and jD Sr. Financial Analyst

I was rejected in today interview on grounds that I do not fit in NOC code 1112. The interview was thoroughly technical, I was getting a feeling whether this was a immigration or job interview. I was asked generic questions like
a.developing debt portfolio risk profile
b. capital management and risk involved

I do not what to do!!!

thanks
Danish


So sorry my dear friend. Remember, when one door closes, many more opens. All the best.
 
danishfareed said:
Dear All,

I have been a silent watcher of the thread and today was my interview. Wanted to share my story.
NOC code 1112
current designation and jD Sr. Financial Analyst

I was rejected in today interview on grounds that I do not fit in NOC code 1112. The interview was thoroughly technical, I was getting a feeling whether this was a immigration or job interview. I was asked generic questions like
a.developing debt portfolio risk profile
b. capital management and risk involved

I do not what to do!!!

thanks
Danish

Not finding any word to express my sympathy for you. Wish you all the best.
 
My JD is long a summary is as follows

a. Lead on planning and forecast activities
b. collation and submission of budgets and plan
c. feasibility studies
d. cost analysis and CBA studies
e. corporate cashflows

etc
 
danishfareed said:
Dear All,

I have been a silent watcher of the thread and today was my interview. Wanted to share my story.
NOC code 1112
current designation and jD Sr. Financial Analyst

I was rejected in today interview on grounds that I do not fit in NOC code 1112. The interview was thoroughly technical, I was getting a feeling whether this was a immigration or job interview. I was asked generic questions like
a.developing debt portfolio risk profile
b. capital management and risk involved

I do not what to do!!!

thanks
Danish

Height this is, I am speechless don't know what to say here.
 
danishfareed said:
My JD is long a summary is as follows

a. Lead on planning and forecast activities
b. collation and submission of budgets and plan
c. feasibility studies
d. cost analysis and CBA studies
e. corporate cashflows

etc

I know it\s tough but still if you can narrate the things how it went through, and at what stage they have mentioned this bad thing.
 
Got to know one more person from 2174 interviewed today.
he has been grilled for 30 minutes related to JD technical questions overall related to 2174 NOc and technical questions related to his job profile.

At last he told he'll get back to him concerning the result of the interview.

Courtesy
Dub2can
 
danishfareed said:
My JD is long a summary is as follows

a. Lead on planning and forecast activities
b. collation and submission of budgets and plan
c. feasibility studies
d. cost analysis and CBA studies
e. corporate cashflows

etc

I am really very sorry Danish but remember there is much better thing written for you.

can I ask you more thing If you don't mind please? you work as sr. financial analyst in a bank or some other organization? what is the standing of your company is it a big company/bank?

what vo asked exactly from you?

I am sorry to bother you brother.
 
danishfareed said:
My JD is long a summary is as follows

a. Lead on planning and forecast activities
b. collation and submission of budgets and plan
c. feasibility studies
d. cost analysis and CBA studies
e. corporate cashflows

etc



I am sure you must have answered the questions put across to u by the VO. Do u think the visa officer was not fully satisfied with the responses you gave regarding the questions asked?
 
you are all very kind. here is a bit of history

I work in ADNOC (the national oil company of UAE) in corporate planning and budget section. our daily activity is nothing crunching numbers and developing forecasts.

the VO was somewhat pre determined not to get me through, he did not ask for any documentation and when I highlighted he unwillingly took in my JD. the questioning started with bit of my history, I am a qualified CPA, ACMA, LFA and a masters in strategic management.

he asked me what I do, I explained a bit of my current role. my information was bit technical as well because it relates to oil and my previous role for automotive sector.

anyways at near end of the interview he said "we had a concern about your application as not in line with NOC 1112 and I am not satisfied with your responses" I responded in asking which area can I explain further, he said " your answers are broad" I replied I am only answering your broad level question do you have any specific questions to ask for example you asked about capital management, do you want me to explain about individual perspective a corporate perspective or any product portfolio do you have in mind where I can be more specific....he had nothing to say......

he was typing everything I was saying, I asked him if you can read through what you have written !!! he had a good typing speed but when he started reading I felt the writing was very fragmented and not making any sense......I did make sense!!!!

well our interview last for more than one hour and 10 minutes!! I kept explaining and he kept writing...at the very end may be because he did not want to give a bad feeling he said we will review and get back to you. at that moment he threw away my paper under his desk like rubbish. I said these are originals if he be kind enough to return and take photocopies instead...which he agreed !!!

so this is the unbiased version of the story. what I feel strongly is that we were not able to connect or may be I was too focused on explaining what I knew rather than what he wanted to listen....!!

I think the decision is final at his end, it was more or less the same case at the start of the interview ............. but this is all very confusing why did CIC accepted my application and why I was sent a confirmation letter. then all of a sudden an interview which was of the generic requirement as was sent o you all.....

I will request for a judicial review of the application and the scenario !!

let me know your thoughts !!