+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445
Client Portal

Important. Appeal system for refusals. Help me raise this issue

I

indiaguy121

Full Member
Jul 21, 2015
30
0
It is high time CIC should adopt appeal system for Study Permit refusals like UK and Australia. UK has administrative review system that is very effective. I am writing a petition about this important issue. Give you input. Let's put stop to discriminatory behaviour of visa officers.
 
indiaguy121 said:
It is high time CIC should adopt appeal system for Study Permit refusals like UK and Australia. UK has administrative review system that is very effective. I am writing a petition about this important issue. Give you input. Let's put stop to discriminatory behaviour of visa officers.
Click to expand...
Please elaborate what discriminatory behavior?
 
indiaguy121 said:
It is high time CIC should adopt appeal system for Study Permit refusals like UK and Australia. UK has administrative review system that is very effective. I am writing a petition about this important issue. Give you input. Let's put stop to discriminatory behaviour of visa officers.
Click to expand...

You can certainly create a petition - but it's going to be a complete waste of time.

Canada just elected a new prime minister and he has already made it clear what his priorities are with regards to immigration. There are already more than enough items on that list to keep him and his party busy for the next four years. Setting up a formal appeal process for study permit refusals isn't going to happen.

If you want to focus on something that benefits students - get behind the Liberal party's promise to make it once again easier for international students to obtain PR through CEC.
 
scylla said:
You can certainly create a petition - but it's going to be a complete waste of time.

Canada just elected a new prime minister and he has already made it clear what his priorities are with regards to immigration. There are already more than enough items on that list to keep him and his party busy for the next four years. Setting up a formal appeal process for study permit refusals isn't going to happen.

If you want to focus on something that benefits students - get behind the Liberal party's promise to make it once again easier for international students to obtain PR through CEC.
Click to expand...
very well said.
 
they are both equally important issues. new immigration minister himself said that corruption and red-tape is rampant at visa offices. there is no legislation required for appeal system. it will be an executive order by immigration minister and the respective visa office will hear appeal against the refusal by marking the case to a different officer for review. NDP and some of the Liberal MP's support this cause.
 
Federal Court prohibits visa officers from rejecting applications of candidates on the basis of weak family ties. Federal Court clearly ruled family bond and strength of relationship is more important than the number of family members in home country. Visa officers are committing contempt of court.
 
indiaguy121 said:
they are both equally important issues. new immigration minister himself said that corruption and red-tape is rampant at visa offices. there is no legislation required for appeal system. it will be an executive order by immigration minister and the respective visa office will hear appeal against the refusal by marking the case to a different officer for review. NDP and some of the Liberal MP's support this cause.
Click to expand...

Please read my post again. I'm not saying what is important and what isn't. I'm saying that he Liberal party very publicly stated its immigration platform up front as part of the election process. So we already know exactly what they are going to do and this work alone will take a long time to implement. Here it is again: https://www.liberal.ca/liberals-unveil-new-plan-for-immigration-focused-on-family-reunification-middle-class-growth/

You have also highly over-simplified the introduction of an appeal process. It would be extremely naive to think that a formal appeal process can be introduced through a simple executive order by the immigration minster. It takes a lot more than that - as we've seen time and time again with any other new policy or process introduced by CIC.

Anyway - you're free to start a petition. I'm just trying to set realistic expectations of what the impact and result will be.
 
indiaguy121 said:
Federal Court prohibits visa officers from rejecting applications of candidates on the basis of weak family ties. Federal Court clearly ruled family bond and strength of relationship is more important than the number of family members in home country. Visa officers are committing contempt of court.
Click to expand...

Where did you get this from out of curiosity?
 
indiaguy121 said:
they are both equally important issues. new immigration minister himself said that corruption and red-tape is rampant at visa offices. there is no legislation required for appeal system. it will be an executive order by immigration minister and the respective visa office will hear appeal against the refusal by marking the case to a different officer for review. NDP and some of the Liberal MP's support this cause.
Click to expand...
please post a link where it says New immigration minister said "corruption and red-tape is rampant at visa offices".
 
Here is the screenshot of summary of the judgement. read the full judgement here
caselaw dot canada.globe24h.com/0/0/federal/federal-court-of-canada/2012/12/20/thiruguanasambandamurthy-v-canada-citizenship-and-immigration-2012-fc-1518 dot shtml

i1028 dot photobucket.com/albums/y350/Emma_Sean/2015-11-13%201_zpse635thau dot png

here is the article about Canada visa system by John. he points out that Canada’s visa system is drowning in red tape.
thestar dot com/opinion/commentary/2014/01/28/canadas_visa_system_is_drowning_in_red_tape dot html

it is not allowing me to put links. i am writing dot instead of .
 
red tape is one thing but calling it corrupt is something different. Its ur emotions that are calling it corrupt
 
canada dot com/mobile/iphone/story.html?id=0f6538ae-b5bb-43f6-9c0e-04b53aa35053

It's bit old story but quite relevant.
 
Hi All and Shyla,


Let me tell my story:
1. I just got refusal and 5 year Ban on FSW 2014 program and my visa office was SGVO. I am under appeal process of the same as i feel i was correct in my pappers

2. as a parallel process, i want my wife to applied for Student permit to canada and can i go with her if she got.
 
Hi


afaruq said:
Hi All and Shyla,


Let me tell my story:
1. I just got refusal and 5 year Ban on FSW 2014 program and my visa office was SGVO. I am under appeal process of the same as i feel i was correct in my pappers

2. as a parallel process, i want my wife to applied for Student permit to canada and can i go with her if she got.
Click to expand...

1. If you were banned for 5 years for misrepresentation, you can't enter Canada for those 5 years period.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.