Hi @Bryanna @21Goose need your guidence on this .

[digitized007]

I have applied for the trv for 20 days to meet by real brother and to attend the marriage reception party on 19 march.but got refusal

i have applied for my self main applicant (33) my wife (31) my daughter (5).

my brother has sponser me he iis canadian permant resindence .his wife has recently got Canadian pr she moves in canada on feb 6 2019 so arrange marriage reception party on 4 may 2019 and invite me to attend that ceremony .

documents from brother which i have attached with my file .

1) invitation letter notary attested
2) copy of pr card ,copy of passport
3) copy of his lease document where he is living right now
4)copy of his pay stubs ,6 months bank statement ,3 years notice of assesments.
5)work proof ,he is permanent employ in public library as senior web developer of annual income of 67000 cad.
6)booking of marriage reception with pay slips

documents from my side .

1) cover letter
2)orignal passports ,other government id proof copy (adhar card)
3)my business letter heads,visiting cards
4)my business proof 2 goverment business proofs ,my 3 years income tax return (in whic i have payed tax for all three years )
5)my business account 6 months statement
6)my saving account with 10000 cad in it its statement and balance certificate
7).CA report with total 20000 cad moveable assets and 200000 cad immovable assets .the immovable assets are of my father with support affidavit notary attested.
8)my lic policy of cylindrical value of 400 cad.
9)my mutual funds of 220 cad,copy of family general insurance which is 6000 cad ,my accidental term insurance
10)my parents passport copy scans (my both father and mother have 10 years multiple entry visa on their passport)
11)school id card copy of my daughter and bonafide certificate from school.
12) gold valuation of 7000 cad mentioned in ca report
but visa officer refuse our letter on this .
Grounds for refusal:



· I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as a temporary resident, as stipulated in paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR, based on the purpose of your visit.



· I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as a temporary resident, as stipulated in paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR, based on your family ties in Canada and in your country of residence.



· I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as a temporary resident, as stipulated in paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR, based on your personal assets and financial status.



· I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as a temporary resident, as stipulated in paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR, based on your travel history.


This application is closed. Please note that any new information you wish to provide must be submitted with a new application and processing fee. Should you wish to reapply, I would suggest that you do so only if your situation has changed substantively or you have significant new information to submit


would i have reapply for that any good suggestion are welcome from experts

 

[Bryanna]

Here's what seems to be inadequate or missing in your application.

I have applied for the trv for 20 days to meet by real brother and to attend the marriage reception party on 19 march.but got refusal

Where was the marriage held? In India or in Canada?

i have applied for my self main applicant (33) my wife (31) my daughter (5).

With your entire family applying with you, you don't have any strong reasons to return to India.

1) cover letter
2)orignal passports ,other government id proof copy (adhar card)
3)my business letter heads,visiting cards
4)my business proof 2 goverment business proofs ,my 3 years income tax return (in whic i have payed tax for all three years )

These documents do not prove that your business is profitable.... nor does it prove that your business is a reason for you to return to India.

5)my business account 6 months statement

Funds from business income cannot be used for private trips unless you are a sole owner of the business. In that case too, you need a number of documents.

6)my saving account with 10000 cad in it its statement and balance certificate

Was this money transferred from your business account?

7).CA report with total 20000 cad moveable assets and 200000 cad immovable assets .the immovable assets are of my father with support affidavit notary attested.

1. Your father's immovable assets cannot be included in your application.

2. CA statements must be supported with actual evidence of ownership of those assets.

3. What movable assets did you declare?

4. Do you have loans or mortgages?

8)my lic policy of cylindrical value of 400 cad.
9)my mutual funds of 220 cad,copy of family general insurance which is 6000 cad ,my accidental term insurance

Unfortunately, all of these investments are very low.

10)my parents passport copy scans (my both father and mother have 10 years multiple entry visa on their passport)

For what reason? This made it even more obvious that you have no family to return to in India.

11)school id card copy of my daughter and bonafide certificate from school.

She is too young for her school records to be considered as a reason to return to India.

12) gold valuation of 7000 cad mentioned in ca report

An applicant will not liquidate gold to pay for a visit. Also, do you have legit receipts or bank statements to prove that this gold was purchased by you?

 

[digitized007]

thanks for you valuable guidance and good questions.

Here's what seems to be inadequate or missing in your application.



Where was the marriage held? In India or in Canada?

marrige was held in india last year and my brother wife move canada after getting pr in febuary and brother wants give party to his friend circle and family members .thats he he invite us to vistit there.i attached restaurant booking receipts.?

With your entire family applying with you, you don't have any strong reasons to return to India.

my father and mother are not going with me only my wife and my daughter and me was inveted .?

These documents do not prove that your business is profitable.... nor does it prove that your business is a reason for you to return to India.


then how can i show my business profitable.can you guide me more on this which make my profile good on this aspect. ?

Funds from business income cannot be used for private trips unless you are a sole owner of the business. In that case too, you need a number of documents.

i am sole proprietor of my business .

Was this money transferred from your business account?

no this money was from my savings and some money gifted from my father .

1. Your father's immovable assets cannot be included in your application.

ok.
2. CA statements must be supported with actual evidence of ownership of those assets.

its supported with bank statements and property valuation report from authorize evaluator with support affidavit from my father

3. What movable assets did you declare?

my bank statement,my gold with government registered valutor reciept. my lic policy .

4. Do you have loans or mortgages?

no no loans .



Unfortunately, all of these investments are very low.

these are my other investments which i have added to make profile strong

For what reason? This made it even more obvious that you have no family to return to in India.

on that point visa officer thinks that we all are going but only my family is going .i added it to make profile strong .


She is too young for her school records to be considered as a reason to return to India.

hmm you are right on this point


An applicant will not liquidate gold to pay for a visit. Also, do you have legit receipts or bank statements to prove that this gold was purchased by you?
i have gold reciept from government register valuator

i think i am not able to convince the visa officer that i would return my country in time .does cover letter play important role on all this ?

@Bryanna
do you think if i reapply on this alone .its important for me to attend that function from one of the family member .

waiting for your reply .

 

[Bryanna]

@digitized007

IMO, if you want to have some chances then you must reapply alone without your wife and daughter.


1. If you consider your application from a visa officer, your brother married in India. Hence, there's no reason for you to attend the wedding party in Canada.

2. Your financial situation is weak, including your investments.

3. You cannot include your dad's property in your applications.

4. You must prove that your business is actively trading.... that it is a financial incentive to return to India

 

[digitized007]

@digitized007

IMO, if you want to have some chances then you must reapply alone without your wife and daughter.


1. If you consider your application from a visa officer, your brother married in India. Hence, there's no reason for you to attend the wedding party in Canada.

2. Your financial situation is weak, including your investments.

3. You cannot include your dad's property in your applications.

4. You must prove that your business is actively trading.... that it is a financial incentive to return to India

hello @Bryanna
i have reapply on the same on 15 april alone without my daughter and my wife .
i have submitted my file online i use representative he submitted file on my behalf .
i have added more document for my business .which proves that my business in good running condition .
till now got no result files shows in processing .
get visitor acknowledgement letter from immigration department on 30 april .
event date is on 4 may and purpose of visit is that event and family visit .
still got no response if event date is pass there there will be more chances of refusal .

 

[digitized007]

hello @Bryanna
i have reapply on the same on 15 april alone without my daughter and my wife .
i have submitted my file online i use representative he submitted file on my behalf .
i have added more document for my business .which proves that my business in good running condition .
till now got no result files shows in processing .
get visitor acknowledgement letter from immigration department on 30 april .
event date is on 4 may and purpose of visit is that event and family visit .
still got no response if event date is pass there there will be more chances of refusal .

Still waiting for decision ..

 

[canuck78]

Still waiting for decision ..

You were able to make it to their actual wedding so that is what really counts.

 

[digitized007]

@digitized007

IMO, if you want to have some chances then you must reapply alone without your wife and daughter.


1. If you consider your application from a visa officer, your brother married in India. Hence, there's no reason for you to attend the wedding party in Canada.

2. Your financial situation is weak, including your investments.

3. You cannot include your dad's property in your applications.

4. You must prove that your business is actively trading.... that it is a financial incentive to return to India

Got again refusal ,on the following two reason now ,

I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as a temporary resident, as stipulated in paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR, based on the purpose of your visit.

I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as a temporary resident, as stipulated in paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR, based on your personal assets and financial status

YOU ARE WELCOME TO REAPPLY IF YOU FEEL THAT YOU CAN RESPOND TO THESE CONCERNS AND CAN DEMONSTRATE THAT YOUR SITUATION MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS.

 

[k.h.p.]

We are now back to the initial advice provided to you. The purpose of your visit was not strong - your brother married in India, so why did you need to travel to Canada? And your financial picture is still weak. I'm sorry you were rejected again.

 

[mpl1973]

Got again refusal ,on the following two reason now ,

I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as a temporary resident, as stipulated in paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR, based on the purpose of your visit.

I am not satisfied that you will leave Canada at the end of your stay as a temporary resident, as stipulated in paragraph 179(b) of the IRPR, based on your personal assets and financial status

YOU ARE WELCOME TO REAPPLY IF YOU FEEL THAT YOU CAN RESPOND TO THESE CONCERNS AND CAN DEMONSTRATE THAT YOUR SITUATION MEETS THE REQUIREMENTS.

When you reapplied, did you submit all the documents again? Or only explanation with additional documents? I am trying to reapply for my aunt

 

[digitized007]

When you reapplied, did you submit all the documents again? Or only explanation with additional documents? I am trying to reapply for my aunt

I have submitted all documents again and added more additional supporting documents and explained the my concerns on previous refusal reasons .