Ok. NOW it makes more sense why CIC has all reasons to revoke your PR.
You see, you never (and your family) were following the regulations. You got your PR in 2004 only, when you definitely were older than 1 year, and I suppose after a struggle with CIC to reinstate your family PR status. After that- left again for a long time and lost your status, but in meantime you went back as PR when if fact you were not, and so on and so on. So, your family (and you as a part of it) has a long history of using the system and breaking the rules, so that is the real reason why they rejected your application for SP and will not reinstate your PR status.
But I suggest to speak to an immigration lawyer (as a last resort) if you are ready to invest a lot of money into that battle or try another country as Australia or UK.
You see, you never (and your family) were following the regulations. You got your PR in 2004 only, when you definitely were older than 1 year, and I suppose after a struggle with CIC to reinstate your family PR status. After that- left again for a long time and lost your status, but in meantime you went back as PR when if fact you were not, and so on and so on. So, your family (and you as a part of it) has a long history of using the system and breaking the rules, so that is the real reason why they rejected your application for SP and will not reinstate your PR status.
But I suggest to speak to an immigration lawyer (as a last resort) if you are ready to invest a lot of money into that battle or try another country as Australia or UK.