I hope I can express my opinion here as an Indian Muslim. The idea to have a separate Muslim state was very good on paper, but the problem with having as exclusive Islamic state is that the Muslims (or any other religion for that matter) tend to take the State and fellow Muslims for granted. I speak from experience as I have observed in Saudi Arabia too. Yes, it is an Islamic state, but when you see the majority of Saudis practicing their religion you cannot help but feel that there is something amiss, that they are taking their religion 'casually'.
Yes, Indian Muslims (atleast the practicing majority) are better off because we are constantly reminded that 'Islam' to us is a blessing, and we are proud to be born as Musims and NOT as non-muslims as we see them practice their religion on a daily basis. Without trying to be demeaning towards them, as a Muslim I cannot help but compare my religion to theirs and feel that 'Yes, my religion is more logical, makes more sense, guides me better'. At the same time, it gives us more opportunities to practice the teachings of Islam, such as tolerance and patience towards them. And they in turn return that, contrary to what is portrayed by the media.
Politicians are a corrupt lot in every country. But when such blatant corruption comes from a Muslim 'politician', its hard to digest. Theres always this question "How better would we have been if this state was run in a true Shariah way?' Running a theocratic state is therefore a huge responsibility.
I do not mean to ruffle any feathers, and I apologise if I have done so unwittingly.
: