CHC contradicts itself!?

[has33b]

Canada offers a post study work permit to its international students and subsequently residency through naturalization. Then why do students need to show home ties for a student visa? If they dont want its students to stay there, then why offer them post study work permit and subsequently residency through naturalization?
Aren't they contradicting themselves?

 

[snake]

its more like marketing policies, else other countries will get huge share of students and Canada will lose revenues. good observation though.

Regards

 

[armani]

Canada offers a post study work permit to its international students and subsequently residency through naturalization. Then why do students need to show home ties for a student visa? If they dont want its students to stay there, then why offer them post study work permit and subsequently residency through naturalization?
Aren't they contradicting themselves?

Not every student is eligible for PR... they have certain rules for the students who r interested in PR after completing their education. the visa officer evaluates the future prospects of the applicant if he could fulfill the criterion of PR after getting educaton.. and if someone cant and visa officer suspects that this person will not leave canada voluntary then any reason for rejection can be imposed

 

[GS_Stud]

Canada offers a post study work permit to its international students and subsequently residency through naturalization. Then why do students need to show home ties for a student visa? If they dont want its students to stay there, then why offer them post study work permit and subsequently residency through naturalization?
Aren't they contradicting themselves?

Very good observation!

As they say "Life is not fair, it never was".

-GS

 

[piratesparade]

Not a gud observation as its every country's own policy u should understand and oblige their policy , They r not sleeping in da holes but trying to dis-fuse da ignitions for non sincere students and unethical people .

 

[rizkhokhar]

has33b you may visit CIC website about the concept of 'Dual Intent'.
In short, it means the intentions by a foreign student during initial stage: 1- To study (Temporary Resident) 2- To become permanent resident through available streams.

The “dual intent" is not the ground for refusal of the study permit.

All that critical is to make it sure to visa officer that you wouldn't breach any immigration law which is the actual scope of any visa application.
Immigration laws could be neglected in following ways:
For example,
Your family ties may lead to let you make money rather than studying.
Your course of study may not be inline with your previous studies which may not present you a genuine student.
Your financial situation is not enough satisfactory to support your stay in Canada.
According to law; everything is ideal as follow:
You came to study (Its 1st Target) >>> You studied (1st Target achieved) >>> You apply for PR (2nd Target) >>> If 1st Target achieved you get PR 8)

 

[newtone]

Canada offers that for people who choose to make Canada their home after their studies. There could be some people who just want the work experience and go elsewhere. There could be other people who leave Canada after their studies are over and so they have to show home ties. Its easier to have the same rule for all international students across the board rather than making another sub class for people who want to stay and people who don't want to stay. Ideally international students should go back once their studies are over, its Canadian generosity for allowing them to stay and apply for PR, its really not a right

 

[haris00]

Canada offers a post study work permit to its international students and subsequently residency through naturalization. Then why do students need to show home ties for a student visa? If they dont want its students to stay there, then why offer them post study work permit and subsequently residency through naturalization?
Aren't they contradicting themselves?

yes, that's still a mystery to me as why they would do that