Can I deport my wife from Canada If I surrender my PR

[azazaz]

Not necessarily a false statement! I heard here in this forum that approximately 40% of PR applications from a certain country (e.g. India) are fraudulent!

agreed to an extent..many people are fraud from south asia thats why they are closing doors on them....if you do googe researching india tops in terms of ielts fraud from indian punjab..here are links..

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/fake-ielts-certificate-scam-exposed-10-held/577999


http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2009-10-25/ludhiana/28082535_1_impersonation-case-scam-kingpin

http://www.punjabnewsline.com/content/indian-student-jailed-australia-visa-scam/39448

http://apossieinaussie.wordpress.com/2009/07/15/punjabi-marriage-proposal-i-love-your-english/

http://blog.abhinav.com/2010/06/man-arrested-for-clearing-ielts-exam-for-others/

http://www.canadavisa.com/canada-immigration-discussion-board/ielts-fraud-report-from-indiabewaredont-put-the-real-peopin-trouble-t52319.0.html

and many more do google research

 

[SenoritaBella]

Even so, it's no guarantee that the wife will be deported. As a permanent resident, she has a right to appeal, etc. If she is well established in Canada(job, social ties, home, etc) and can demostrate that going back to India will cause undue hardship, she will be allowed to stay. In addition, if she was not part of/aware of the "fraud", that will work in her favor.

As for the OP, there are consequences for making such declarations such as being banned from Canada. What if he does that and the wife is still allowed to stay in Canada? What will he have "gained" from it? Is it worth destroying one's life for?

This is a marital squabble and they should resolve it between themselves or through divorce court instead of using CIC to settle scores and wasting our tax dollars in the process.

 

[noon]

don't live in fools paradise...you don't know the seriousness of case..don't u think kuljeet knows these things..?

Many divorces cases in India are inflated ones. Relatives interference add oil to burning fire. From what I understood Kuljeet want his wife to come to India and but his wife want him to come to Canda. Both of them have the same motive: to live together. They both should reach a compromise. Even if she is deported from Canada for the sake of living as Kuldeepsingh's wife in India, does any esteemed member in this forum think that she could love him the same as before? If she approaches an Indian court for divorce for mental harassment or cruelty she will be awarded divorce with lot of compensation(Indian courts judgement are always favored towards females/wifes in case of divorce). Her aunt is in Canada and she can arrange a nice Candian guy for her and she will be again in Canada. So Kuljeet Singh think before you leap!!!!
I am only your well wisher.

 

[azazaz]

Even so, it's no guarantee that the wife will be deported. As a permanent resident, she has a right to appeal, etc. If she is well established in Canada(job, social ties, home, etc) and can demostrate that going back to India will cause undue hardship, she will be allowed to stay. In addition, if she was not part of/aware of the "fraud", that will work in her favor.

As for the OP, there are consequences for making such declarations such as being banned from Canada. What if he does that and the wife is still allowed to stay in Canada? What will he have "gained" from it? Is it worth destroying one's life for?

This is a marital squabble and they should resolve it between themselves or through divorce court instead of using CIC to settle scores a
nd wasting our tax dollars in the process.

i disagree..if op calims pr was acquired fraudlantly his pr will be cancelled and automatically wife's also..he just need to say in his claim that he is surrendering his pr as he had realised his mistake and feel sorry for that and should request that wife's pr should also be cancelled bcz she got bcz of him...

i dont think cic will accept wife will have hardships in india, wat kind of hardship ? she is not a refugee...

its up to kuljeet singh wat to do now? if he has got balls he can take this step else not...

 

[MASunny]

Dear Kuljeetsingh, IF YOU ARE UNHAPPY............there are few words to you: Once upon a time, there was a non-conforming sparrow that decided not to fly south for the winter. However, soon the weather turned so cold that he reluctantly started to fly south. In a short time, ice began to form on his wings and he fell to earth in a farmyard, almost frozen. A cow passed by and crapped on the little sparrow. The sparrow thought it was the end, but the manure warmed him and defrosted his wings. Warm and happy, able to breathe, he started to sing. Just then a large cat came by, and hearing the chirping, investigated the sounds. The cat cleared away the manure, found the chirping bird, and promptly ate him!

The moral of this story here in your case is that:

1. Everyone who shits on you is not necessarily your enemy (your wife)

2. Everyone who gets you out of the shit is not necessarily your friend. (Ppl like Karwa Sach; they always fight here with everyone!)

3. And, if you're warm and happy in a pile of shit, keep your mouth shut! (This is not a forum for such private discussion, consult a solicitor)

Hi, I got permanent residence of Canada on the basis of Federal skilled Worker Visa. I was principle applicant for this case. As a PR I entered to Canada in May, 2011 and started to live in Toronto. My wife as a PR entered in Canada in June, 2011 and started to live in Vancouver with her aunt. I came back from Canada to my home country (India) in Dec 2011. Since then I am living in my home country alone. And my wife is living in Vancouver since June, 2011. Means we are living separate for almost 2 years. Now I want that my wife should come and live in India with me. But she wants to live in Canada. Now the case is, neither she gives me divorce nor she comes to India to live with me. Now I want either divorce or I want that Canada government should deport her to India as I was the principle applicant in our Federal skilled Worker Visa so that she can live with me. Can anybody help me to get divorce or to get her deported to India. And for this I am ready to surrender my PR of Canada. I wanna follow legal ways for divorce. But the law of India will not help me because she is in Canada now. Can government of Canada help me in this regard. I will be highly grateful if anybody can tell me some way...Thanx..Kuljeet

 

[azazaz]

Dear Kuljeetsingh, IF YOU ARE UNHAPPY............there are few words to you: Once upon a time, there was a non-conforming sparrow that decided not to fly south for the winter. However, soon the weather turned so cold that he reluctantly started to fly south. In a short time, ice began to form on his wings and he fell to earth in a farmyard, almost frozen. A cow passed by and crapped on the little sparrow. The sparrow thought it was the end, but the manure warmed him and defrosted his wings. Warm and happy, able to breathe, he started to sing. Just then a large cat came by, and hearing the chirping, investigated the sounds. The cat cleared away the manure, found the chirping bird, and promptly ate him!

The moral of this story here in your case is that:

1. Everyone who *censored word*s on you is not necessarily your enemy (your wife)

2. Everyone who gets you out of the *censored word* is not necessarily your friend. (Ppl like Karwa Sach; they always fight here with everyone!)

3. And, if you're warm and happy in a pile of *censored word*, keep your mouth shut! (This is not a forum for such private discussion, consult a solicitor)

+1..liked it ;D

 

[azazaz]

yeah msaeed..now i will not surrender my PR..thanx dear...

r u sure..so u changed in a day of posting here.. ;D ;D ;D

hatts off to canadavisa forum and david cohen...he is stopping breaks ups and uniting families.... 8)

 

[canlove]

@ cocosyr, I did a bit of research on your last posts and found that what you write is total crap, here some of it is reproduced, dont forget to read what is my conclusion about you at the end.
“I know what you're saying. Most of you guys are from third world countries. So delivering pizzas in Canada is better than being a professor in your home country. Junior scientists? LOL. Should say junior losers! Nobody in Canada changes the world's history or leads anything. This is a country for losers...”

My conclusion : You are white r a c i s t trash. I am going to stay in Canada and so are other asians. You go to hell.

Lol..!
I like it.

+1

 

[kiterunner]

If you were the main applicant and she applied as your wife (i.e. you sponsored her application), you can contact Canada Immigration Services (or the Canadian Embassy in India) and report the fact that during your stay in Canada she has refused to live with you. If she immigrated as your spouse on your "skilled labour" she was required to live with you for the first two years. If she took up residency in Vancouver at her aunt's home rather than with you in Toronto (she lived six months at her Aunt's home while you were living in Toronto; apparently her intention was not to come to Canada to be with her spouse.) during her first 2 years then she is in violation of her visa and the Canadian government can revoke her residency and deport her. I take it since you have asked her to rejoin you in India, and I am guessing to come to Toronto when you were living there, reuniting with your spouse had been your intention when you sponsored your spouse to come to Canada.

 

[Aquib]

If you were the main applicant and she applied as your wife (i.e. you sponsored her application), you can contact Canada Immigration Services (or the Canadian Embassy in India) and report the fact that during your stay in Canada she has refused to live with you. If she immigrated as your spouse on your "skilled labour" she was required to live with you for the first two years. If she took up residency in Vancouver at her aunt's home rather than with you in Toronto (she lived six months at her Aunt's home while you were living in Toronto; apparently her intention was not to come to Canada to be with her spouse.) during her first 2 years then she is in violation of her visa and the Canadian government can revoke her residency and deport her. I take it since you have asked her to rejoin you in India, and I am guessing to come to Toronto when you were living there, reuniting with your spouse had been your intention when you sponsored your spouse to come to Canada.

+1.
Agreed with what u say

 

[on-hold]

If you were the main applicant and she applied as your wife (i.e. you sponsored her application), you can contact Canada Immigration Services (or the Canadian Embassy in India) and report the fact that during your stay in Canada she has refused to live with you. If she immigrated as your spouse on your "skilled labour" she was required to live with you for the first two years. If she took up residency in Vancouver at her aunt's home rather than with you in Toronto (she lived six months at her Aunt's home while you were living in Toronto; apparently her intention was not to come to Canada to be with her spouse.) during her first 2 years then she is in violation of her visa and the Canadian government can revoke her residency and deport her. I take it since you have asked her to rejoin you in India, and I am guessing to come to Toronto when you were living there, reuniting with your spouse had been your intention when you sponsored your spouse to come to Canada.

I don't know, but I'm not certain that this is true -- I think that the two year deal applies for people who immigrate as spouses. Maybe I misread the original story, but I thought that the OP and his wife both came as FSW, in which case she can leave him without any sort of relationship fraud.

 

[myluckyprincess]

this is one of the most intriguing subjects on this website. just wanna share these:

first, deport is not something that someone does. it is the government of the country that does deporting.

try to resolve your issues which made you decide to divorce your wife. address why your wife wants to live in canada. there might be things that are not said to each other. it's better to talk the way mature people do.

 

[myluckyprincess]

i just remember your case when i read Leon's post in other topic Re: Is it misrepresentation?? Please advise me:

I agree that in this case, the misrepresentiation is not of a serious kind but in any case, as long as you don't tell, who will ever know?

I have heard of people losing their PR and getting deported for a misrepresentation as small as having lied about their activity during a period of 2 months of their past where they said they attended school but were really not doing anything. Having been unemployed for those 2 months would certainly not have affected them getting PR but goes to show how nitpicky immigration could get if they wanted to. However, this was also a very exceptional case as it was a lady who worked for immigration and was a victim of marriage fraud. She was on this forum at the time and that was some years ago. She asked her coworkers what she could do to get her husband deported. They said find anything he may have lied about. She knew about the 2 months and voila, no more PR for him.

 

[farney bhoy]

What a strange topic! I don't pretend to understand the cultural side of this as i am not Indian but i have to say that if you love your wife you should get on the next plane to Vancouver my friend. Also the fact that you asked the forum about the possibility of getting your wife deported makes me think that you need to have a good look at yourself.

You would actively try and have your wife removed from Canada for your own selfish reasons? Is it any wonder she doesn't want to come back to you!

 

[Thommo]

What a strange topic! I don't pretend to understand the cultural side of this as i am not Indian but i have to say that if you love your wife you should get on the next plane to Vancouver my friend. Also the fact that you asked the forum about the possibility of getting your wife deported makes me think that you need to have a good look at yourself.

You would actively try and have your wife removed from Canada for your own selfish reasons? Is it any wonder she doesn't want to come back to you!

Very well said!