+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445
Client Portal

April 2018 AOR - join here

Just got a devastating news.......My friends PR application was refused.
AOR: March 23.
Reason for refusal: Did not satisfy officer that she met the requirement under Subsection 75(2) paragraph b.

Its really confusing as her employment letter matched with the lead statement in the NOC (4011) she applied for. And its completely unbelievable that she was denied for such reason as she was told by a CIC agent (when she called) that she already passed her Eligibility.

Please anybody with information on how she can proceed should please let me know.

Cheers!!
 
Rijo02 said:
Just got a devastating news.......My friends PR application was refused.
AOR: March 23.
Reason for refusal: Did not satisfy officer that she met the requirement under Subsection 75(2) paragraph b.

Its really confusing as her employment letter matched with the lead statement in the NOC (4011) she applied for. And its completely unbelievable that she was denied for such reason as she was told by a CIC agent (when she called) that she already passed her Eligibility.

Please anybody with information on how she can proceed should please let me know.

Cheers!!
Click to expand...

That is shocking news, especially 3.5 months after AOR. You mentioned that her letter matched with the lead statement, but what about the job duties? I've read here that it is recommended that the letter matches at least 60% of the NOC duties to which someone is applying.

Hopefully someone else here can help you.
 
Rijo02 said:
Just got a devastating news.......My friends PR application was refused.
AOR: March 23.
Reason for refusal: Did not satisfy officer that she met the requirement under Subsection 75(2) paragraph b.

Its really confusing as her employment letter matched with the lead statement in the NOC (4011) she applied for. And its completely unbelievable that she was denied for such reason as she was told by a CIC agent (when she called) that she already passed her Eligibility.

Please anybody with information on how she can proceed should please let me know.

Cheers!!
Click to expand...
Can't she reapply with a better job description letter ?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rijo02
Rijo02 said:
Just got a devastating news.......My friends PR application was refused.
AOR: March 23.
Reason for refusal: Did not satisfy officer that she met the requirement under Subsection 75(2) paragraph b.

Its really confusing as her employment letter matched with the lead statement in the NOC (4011) she applied for. And its completely unbelievable that she was denied for such reason as she was told by a CIC agent (when she called) that she already passed her Eligibility.

Please anybody with information on how she can proceed should please let me know.

Cheers!!
Click to expand...
Which category??
 
Rijo02 said:
Just got a devastating news.......My friends PR application was refused.
AOR: March 23.
Reason for refusal: Did not satisfy officer that she met the requirement under Subsection 75(2) paragraph b.

Its really confusing as her employment letter matched with the lead statement in the NOC (4011) she applied for. And its completely unbelievable that she was denied for such reason as she was told by a CIC agent (when she called) that she already passed her Eligibility.

Please anybody with information on how she can proceed should please let me know.

Cheers!!
Click to expand...
Quebec?
 
darshaknir said:
Which category??
Click to expand...
Rijo02 said:
Just got a devastating news.......My friends PR application was refused.
AOR: March 23.
Reason for refusal: Did not satisfy officer that she met the requirement under Subsection 75(2) paragraph b.

Its really confusing as her employment letter matched with the lead statement in the NOC (4011) she applied for. And its completely unbelievable that she was denied for such reason as she was told by a CIC agent (when she called) that she already passed her Eligibility.

Please anybody with information on how she can proceed should please let me know.

Cheers!!
Click to expand...
She might be college teacher but the lead statement says that university professors who are heads of departments are included in this unit group. I say reapply using a better NOC code or change some duties sentence. Good luck to her!
 
jonnie_RC said:
Thanks for the reply. So I've just had the one update. Hopefully I will get the second and the ppr soon.
Click to expand...
Doesn't have to be. I had one ghost update on the day of IP2 and next was the PPR email. So brace yourself for the ultimate update in your inbox! ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: jonnie_RC
Arod said:
That is shocking news, especially 3.5 months after AOR. You mentioned that her letter matched with the lead statement, but what about the job duties? I've read here that it is recommended that the letter matches at least 60% of the NOC duties to which someone is applying.

Hopefully someone else here can help you.
Click to expand...
Better to have 70% plus. Just the letter matching lead statement is never enough. My application got refused in 2014 and back then I didn't include job duties and responsibilities with the letter. Hence this time, I ensured my jobs duties matched almost 80%.
 
Rijo02 said:
Just got a devastating news.......My friends PR application was refused.
AOR: March 23.
Reason for refusal: Did not satisfy officer that she met the requirement under Subsection 75(2) paragraph b.

Its really confusing as her employment letter matched with the lead statement in the NOC (4011) she applied for. And its completely unbelievable that she was denied for such reason as she was told by a CIC agent (when she called) that she already passed her Eligibility.

Please anybody with information on how she can proceed should please let me know.

Cheers!!
Click to expand...
Sorry to hear about the news. I reckon the best thing to do is to get back in the pool with a comprehensive employment letter that matches jobs and duties close to 80%. It is not the end for sure as this is the reason for high refusal second only to PCC. Just because the agent told her eligibility has passed doesn't mean the second officer may had passed it too. I reckon the information had not been shared or worst, the LVO may had checked the Eligibility once again in the end. Like I said, its not the end, just ask your friend to get back in the pool and get ready with the revised employment letter and a comprehensive LoE and it will be fine. Good luck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rijo02
KingKurly said:
Sorry to hear about the news. I reckon the best thing to do is to get back in the pool with a comprehensive employment letter that matches jobs and duties close to 80%. It is not the end for sure as this is the reason for high refusal second only to PCC. Just because the agent told her eligibility has passed doesn't mean the second officer may had passed it too. I reckon the information had not been shared or worst, the LVO may had checked the Eligibility once again in the end. Like I said, its not the end, just ask your friend to get back in the pool and get ready with the revised employment letter and a comprehensive LoE and it will be fine. Good luck.
Click to expand...
Best to reapply again she can still make it this year
 
Arod said:
That is shocking news, especially 3.5 months after AOR. You mentioned that her letter matched with the lead statement, but what about the job duties? I've read here that it is recommended that the letter matches at least 60% of the NOC duties to which someone is applying.

Hopefully someone else here can help you.
Click to expand...

Her job duties corroborated with what was written on the NOC job duties. It matched up to 80%.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.