Hi jackson2209, can you clarify what you meant by not on the skilled worker's list? I'm assuming that you're referring to the 38 occupations for eligibility? These occupations are just for eligibility, but then again, if you have completed more than two years of your PhD, you are eligible, and all of your work experience from the last 10 years can be counted (provided they fall under skill level 0, A or B). So check back all of the experience you've had from the last ten years, and see if they can be considered skill level A, 0 or B. And the most important thing, make sure you have at least 1,950 of continuous work experience for any period within the last 10 years. We have one applicant rejected because of precisely this reason.
s.guo82, yeah, if you are going to prepare for resubmission, then you might as well make sure you can claim more than 3,900 hours. But did you claim hours for your non-taxable parts of the income as well? If you did, then more likely they would give you positive review, and you wouldn't have to worry about re-submission. At least for the purpose of CIO, we have confirmed that the CIO did indeed accept non-taxable Canadian incomes as 'salaries' for our work experience. Not sure if this would be true for VO though.
Also, if I'm not mistaken, AF___ only claimed 650 hours for taxable work experience through RA/TA, and did not even put the number of hours for his non-taxable parts (he included everything else in his letters though, except for the number of hours per week). And he already got his PER. Admittedly, he claimed eligibility points from his wife's credentials, so that's probably why his case was a bit more straight forward than yours.