Applicant from PhD program after 5 Nov, 2011 connect here to get status

[immc]

Hi immc, could you give an estimated date? thx.

Submit: January 10, 2012
NER: March 20, 2012
PER: April 20, 2012
Request for fund proof: January 29, 2013

 

[websphereguy]

Submit: January 10, 2012
NER: March 20, 2012
PER: April 20, 2012
Request for fund proof: January 29, 2013

Thanks. May I ask which country are you from?

 

[Ehsan_Ehsan]

Do you mind answering some of my questions, cos it is also my concern.
Was he rejected before receiving doc request? Did he apply under the phd stream? Did he claim the adaptability points when applying? How did he know he got the points from CIO? How many points did he get according to Ottawa's evaluation? Is it possible to let us know the wording in the refusal letter?

Thanks

There was no document requested from CPP and he was rejected at that stage. However, the CIO (Sydney) gave him positive determination before that. He applied in the PhD stream under FSW class. He claimed the adaptability points and based on that, he was given the adaptability point. I think he got 65 from CPP. I don't think it is possible to paste the refusal letter here.

 

[PyramidCity]

There was no document requested from CPP and he was rejected at that stage. However, the CIO (Sydney) gave him positive determination before that. He applied in the PhD stream under FSW class. He claimed the adaptability points and based on that, he was given the adaptability point. I think he got 65 from CPP. I don't think it is possible to paste the refusal letter here.

Thanks a lot, but it seems his case was quite unique.

 

[TyrusX]

There was no document requested from CPP and he was rejected at that stage. However, the CIO (Sydney) gave him positive determination before that. He applied in the PhD stream under FSW class. He claimed the adaptability points and based on that, he was given the adaptability point. I think he got 65 from CPP. I don't think it is possible to paste the refusal letter here.

I think we have seen this kind of things before. People that got adaptability points after CIO and then got rejected on CPP. It seems to be the case, my university even sent e-mails asking people relying on those points not to apply.

 

[asbereth]

I think we have seen this kind of things before. People that got adaptability points after CIO and then got rejected on CPP. It seems to be the case, my university even sent e-mails asking people relying on those points not to apply.

I think what we've seen is quite the opposite. Besides Ehsan_Ehsan's friend, I don't think we've seen cases where Sydney granted the 5 points, but Ottawa did not. People that have gotten rejected due to lack of previous study adaptability points were never granted the 5 points from Sydney to begin with (like Dani1982). We know that, MapleDream, for example, had the 5 points even for Ottawa (though he was rejected due to work experience).

Likewise, immc had recently got document request from Ottawa, and he also had to rely on these 5 points to get above 67 points (since he initially got NER from Sydney, then appealed). By the time you received documentation request, I postulate that they are already done with your eligibility review, and can't find any fault with it, which was why they decided to continue the processing. Otherwise, rejection usually comes before any sort of documentations are even requested.

 

[TyrusX]

I think what we've seen is quite the opposite. Besides Ehsan_Ehsan's friend, I don't think we've seen cases where Sydney granted the 5 points, but Ottawa did not. People that have gotten rejected due to lack of previous study adaptability points were never granted the 5 points from Sydney to begin with (like Dani1982). We know that, MapleDream, for example, had the 5 points even for Ottawa (though he was rejected due to work experience).

Likewise, immc had recently got document request from Ottawa, and he also had to rely on these 5 points to get above 67 points (since he initially got NER from Sydney, then appealed). By the time you received documentation request, I postulate that they are already done with your eligibility review, and can't find any fault with it, which was why they decided to continue the processing. Otherwise, rejection usually comes before any sort of documentations are even requested.

You are right. But as utopie case has shown, eligibility can go on until the last moment. utopie just said a few posts ago that she got rejected after medical for being short in worked hours in her first application (CEC).

 

[asbereth]

You are right. But as utopie case has shown, eligibility can go on until the last moment. utopie just said a few posts ago that she got rejected after medical for being short in worked hours in her first application (CEC).

Ya, her case was obviously a testament that anything can happen to very last minute. But at least based on what we've seen so far of our stream, the eligibility (by Ottawa) seems to be done before any documentations are requested. Rejections due to not having enough points happened before they got any requests for further documentation. Some people got rejected after document request, but not because of not having enough points.

The question to ask Ehsan_Ehsan's friend is whether or not his friend got NER then appealed. Because if he did not, maybe it was one of those job description mismatch cases (and if he applied before April, most likely Sydney never granted him the 5 points to begin with). How did he know that his friend got the 5 adaptability points from Sydney, and when did he apply? If he just recently got the response from Ottawa, most likely he was one of the February (or January) applicants, and without appeal, these guys were never granted the 5 adaptability points for previous study.

 

[New13]

Hi,

A quick question regarding the document in foreign language. Do I need to submit (with PR application) a certified translation or normal translation will work?

Thanks.

 

[aidina]

Hi,

A quick question regarding the document in foreign language. Do I need to submit (with PR application) a certified translation or normal translation will work?

Thanks.

Certified of course.

 

[BakerMan]

Hi everybody.
I have sent my application on PhD stream on December 2011. On January 4th I was asked for Bank Statement.
From ECAS, I found a new line of " We started processing your application". My Ecas is not accessible any more.
Do you guys have any idea what it means ? Any idea would be appreciated.

 

[asbereth]

Hi everybody.
I have sent my application on PhD stream on December 2011. On January 4th I was asked for Bank Statement.
From ECAS, I found a new line of " We started processing your application". My Ecas is not accessible any more.
Do you guys have any idea what it means ? Any idea would be appreciated.

I think it's fine. Usually people have that second line on their online status right after they receive their medical requests. It probably just means that they're happy with your bank statement (can you elaborate what you sent them?), and ready for further processing. Not sure why you can't access it any more though.

 

[BakerMan]

I think it's fine. Usually people have that second line on their online status right after they receive their medical requests. It probably just means that they're happy with your bank statement (can you elaborate what you sent them?), and ready for further processing. Not sure why you can't access it any more though.

Thanks Asbereth. I sent 6 months bank activity. I had 11000 for almost 5 months. My status changed almost few days ago.
Same thing happened for my friend almost a week ago. We have not heard from them yet. Today, I wanted to see my status but I could not check it. I hope for the best.

 

[Master3]

Hi everybody.
I have sent my application on PhD stream on December 2011. On January 4th I was asked for Bank Statement.
From ECAS, I found a new line of " We started processing your application". My Ecas is not accessible any more.
Do you guys have any idea what it means ? Any idea would be appreciated.

I don't have access to me Ecas too !!!!!?

 

[BakerMan]

I don't have access to me Ecas too !!!!!?

Hi Master3, Have you submitted the requested documents ? Did you have the new line on your
Ecas ?