+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445
We are all sorry to hear the unfortunate news mrsrangi, for all the appeal cases that I had read online, only 1 or 2 cases got rejected when there are children involved and they got dismissed not because of Subsection 4(1) bad faith but other for clauses.

I have to agree with True Love maybe reapplying after living with your husband for a few years will yield a better chance, unless you can prove there exist some procedure error in the Judge decision; otherwise it is very difficult to win in the federal court, because they will not look into any of your evidence.
Only thing I guess may go to her favor if she chose to go to federal court which is humanitarian ground because of best interest of the child directly involved with the decion or may be some other depend on the case because we all have different cases and complications and also judge may find IAD judge decion based on her previous marriage is wrongly applied.reaplying she always has that option on the table if in future she have another baby or more proof living together will help.but for federal court appeal she has to apply within 30 days after this decion I guess .
 
Last edited:
Only thing I guess may go to her favor if she chose to go to federal court which is humanitarian ground because of best interest of the child directly involved with the decion or may be some other depend on the case because we all have different cases and complications and also judge may find IAD judge decion based on her previous marriage is wrongly applied.reaplying she always has that option on the table if in future she have another baby or more proof living together will help.but for federal court appeal she has to apply within 30 days after this decion I guess .
I applied 2 times before and third time I appealed. I visited every year for 3/4 months and been visiting after 6/7 month. Judge took everything negative because of my past history
 
  • Like
Reactions: karamjeetkaur kaila
I applied 2 times before and third time I appealed. I visited every year for 3/4 months and been visiting after 6/7 month. Judge took everything negative because of my past history
It’s very frustrating I don’t know what else we can prove that we are in genuine relationship specially when you have baby too it’s crazy to think some one will have the kid only to obtain immigration status in Canada it’s only happend in real relationship.they should reunite families not tore them a part it’s very disappointing.unfortely we are powerless at this point .
 
Sorry to hear msrangi
 
Hi guys... I have an ADR conference in 3 days. I'm going in there alone without a lawyer. My wife was refused because they believed marriage is not genuine. Can you please share some advice
 
Hey guys so I had my conference today and my full hearing is scheduled for January 4th. Im so nervouse any tips
 
I applied 2 times before and third time I appealed. I visited every year for 3/4 months and been visiting after 6/7 month. Judge took everything negative because of my past history
Oh man. Sorry to hear! Such a long wait for a dismissal. Stay strong but I would try and submit for judicial review (federal) get a lawyer to help you write a good submission etc. Stay strong!
 
On the appeal letter from Immigration Appeal Board for Notice of Decision. What did it state underneath? "Appeal allowed"...... decision for PR set aside and "the officer must continue processing the application in accordance with the consent of the parties"??? Does anyone care to share theirs? Was it the same or different wording? You can private message if you like. Thanks
 
On the appeal letter from Immigration Appeal Board for Notice of Decision. What did it state underneath? "Appeal allowed"...... decision for PR set aside and "the officer must continue processing the application in accordance with the consent of the parties"??? Does anyone care to share theirs? Was it the same or different wording? You can private message if you like. Thanks
The appeal is allowed. The officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside, and an officer must continue to process the application in accordance with the reasons of the Immigration Appeal Division.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alicee
The appeal is allowed. The officer’s decision to refuse a permanent resident visa is set aside, and an officer must continue to process the application in accordance with the reasons of the Immigration Appeal Division.


Okay....anyone else has something different? Or is it all the same and generic standard letter?
 
Finally a date to look forward too!
How was the conference? Did you bring additional evidence with you?

i brought evidence but they didnt take it. when you go all they do is tell you about submitting evidence and making copies. Then taking you to get your date. its 30 mins top. waste of time if you ask me.
 
What is my best option since I had applied 2 time already the lost in full hearing, I have baby , they did not ask for DNA and dismissed the position point saying there was no DNA of the baby as evidence. Should I go to federal or reapply
 
What is my best option since I had applied 2 time already the lost in full hearing, I have baby , they did not ask for DNA and dismissed the position point saying there was no DNA of the baby as evidence. Should I go to federal or reapply

First we do not know the reason why your appeal got rejected because it is your privacy and second; none of us in here are really subject matter expertise in immigration appeal. If you are appealing at the federal court, you should seek professional help. Find yourself not just a lawyer but a very good lawyer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ana Paula
First we do not know the reason why your appeal got rejected because it is your privacy and second; none of us in here are really subject matter expertise in immigration appeal. If you are appealing at the federal court, you should seek professional help. Find yourself not just a lawyer but a very good lawyer.
Thanks