H&C Humanitarian Ground with/or Without Failed refugee claim
- Thread starter TheWaitingGamer
- Start date
Pls was ur passport expired and original seized by CBSA? If yes, What did u send as valid passport before granting the Copr? Thanks
Actually, what you fail to recognize is that H&C is, in fact, an exception to the law. That is what H&C asks immigration to consider, an exception to the legal requirements to obtain a permanent residence status.
And while we may not be required to give advice, it’s a public forum in a country that prides itself in freedom of speech. Not sure where you come from, but it allows you the same privilege.
A little more education for you:
In Canada, an “Act” under parliament is a law. If you take the time to read and comprehend information readily available on government immigration websites, you would understand what an exception to the act means. You and your friends may not care for what some of the “VIP” members have to say, but in most cases, they are just repeating facts you fail to acknowledge.
https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/application/application-forms-guides/guide-5291-humanitarian-compassionate-considerations.html
However, section A25(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) allows foreign nationals who are inadmissible or who are ineligible to apply in an immigration class, to apply for permanent residence, or for an exemption from a requirement of the Act, based on humanitarian and compassionate (H&C) considerations.
Last edited:
of course it's a country of freedom and also a country that gives a big importance for humanity and compassionate cases....
i don't care if you and your friend want to talk and comment and share but you must know that its not your job , you can say what you think and you opinion but not what others but not what others have to do, also i can't understand how some people here always want to talk to me
! when I don't want to and I can't stand them at all , you know, we must have dignity in this life.....and yes i know that H&C its an exception but it is part of the immigration system and the ircc laws., even if the acceptance rate is lower than the other categories but i repeate , h&c its a part of the immgration system and its a solution for many people and unfortunately the majority of them are desperate and need help because they don't have another choice !
You just don’t get the law or what an exception to it is. Moving on....best of luck with your application.of course it's a country of freedom and also a country that gives a big importance for humanity and compassionate cases....
i don't care if you and your friend want to talk and comment and share but you must know that its not your job , you can say what you think and you opinion but not what others but not what others have to do, also i can't understand how some people here always want to talk to me
and yes i know that H&C its an exception but it is part of the immigration system and the ircc laws., even if the acceptance rate is lower than the other categories but i repeate , h&c its a part of the immgration system and its a solution for many people and unfortunately the majority of them are desperate and need help because they don't have another choice !
Okay...it doesn't matter ! the most important is that my applicaiton will be approved .
thank you
You've worked hard for it...you will get it.
Actually it's only you and your lawyer who can judge.
It's ok for others to give their opinions. Don't upset yourself.
Sharing is caring
All you need to do is include an not explaining that your passport was seized by CBSA and that is expired and you have not renewed it due to your protected person status. It won't be an issue.
Many visitors don't get H&C actually. The primary H&C approvals are from failed asylum seekers or those who initially were on work or study permits and failed to qualify for PR. If visitors could easily get PR via H&C anyone who didn't qualify for PR via other programs would come to Canada to apply for H&C. In your case you seem like a young able bodied family who could have also tried to secure PR via economic immigration program or attempted to study or work in Canada to then qualify for PR. Canada eliminated sponsorship of siblings so it wouldn't make sense if Canada approved H&C for any adult sibling to reunite with their family especially if they had their own spouse and child which Canada considers immediate family. I also correctly pointed out that your H&C application was likely to come down to whether it was in the best interest of your child to remain in Canada due to medical care if treatment is not available in Albania. Not having access to the proper medical care/therapies/medications is the primary argument when arguing best interest of a child with medical needs. Although having a Canadian child certainly factors into H&C decisions it does not guarantee PR via H&C or else families wanting to secure PR would just have a child in Canada. Without actually knowing the grounds for why your sister ( a minor) and your father it impossible to comment. The situation in Albania when they likely applied 7-8+ years ago was also different.
Would suggest doing your research before criticizing. Albanians are amongst the highest groups of people deported from other European countries because the EU has declared Albania as a safe country. The big reasons Albanians are granted asylum is if they are part of the LGBTQ+ population. Unfortunately many countries have problems and living conditions may not be very good especially compared to Canada but if that was the only requirement to secure asylum or H&C most of the world would qualify.
There are no targets for H&C approvals. This isn't economic immigration where you can a target to approve XXXK applications within a year. The number H&C is not a target but an estimation on how many people Canada estimates will be approved for PR under H&C based on previous years data. Within each immigration department they have processing targets when it comes to how many applications should be finalized within that year but when it comes to H&C no set amount of approvals are decided in advance. That is the only target associated with H&C. Unfortunately when creating documents sometimes the terminology applies to some categories better than others.