+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

Chronic Kidney Disease- Stage 4 fairness letter

nush78l

Star Member
Jan 3, 2014
122
7
Hello everyone,

CIC sent my family a fairness letter stating "excess demand" on Canadian Health System.

Now I understand this topic has been discussed before but I really need your help determining what points would lead to a successful response (acceptance). How many have successfully received their PR after submitting a letter for CKD Stage 4 ?

If you could share some knowledge it would be very helpful. We are submitting the letter tomorrow.
Hello mountain123,

My father is also in the same situation - CKD Stage 4, but he has not received a fairness letter yet.

How long did CIC take since the initial medical exam to send you the letter?

My father has been sent for follow up tests every 3 months since his initial medical exam in Oct 2016. Was it the same for you?

Please keep me posted on your progress.
 

Rob_TO

VIP Member
Nov 7, 2012
11,427
1,551
Toronto
Category........
FAM
Visa Office......
Seoul, Korea
App. Filed.......
13-07-2012
AOR Received.
18-08-2012
File Transfer...
21-08-2012
Med's Done....
Sent with App
Passport Req..
N/R - Exempt
VISA ISSUED...
30-10-2012
LANDED..........
16-11-2012
Hello everyone,

CIC sent my family a fairness letter stating "excess demand" on Canadian Health System.

Now I understand this topic has been discussed before but I really need your help determining what points would lead to a successful response (acceptance). How many have successfully received their PR after submitting a letter for CKD Stage 4 ?

If you could share some knowledge it would be very helpful. We are submitting the letter tomorrow.
This thread might be of relevance, which unfortunately ended in a rejection. http://www.canadavisa.com/canada-immigration-discussion-board/threads/parent-sponsorship-and-rejection-on-health-grounds-proceeding-to-appeal-process.469959/

Fairness letter response needs to address not just the immediate condition, but also the projection over next 10 years after becoming a PR in Canada since this is the duration IRCC can look in assessing excessive demand. A stable condition today, may be expected to worsen and cause excessive demand over that 10 year window.

Reports and consultations from doctors backing up your response is essential.
 
Last edited:

mountain123

Star Member
Mar 10, 2014
85
1
Thank you everyone for your response. We have a letter from doctor stating he has been maintaining his health with good diet exercise. On top of all this he does not drink or smoke. The doctor stated he would not have any issues for the next "couple of years". He did not state any specific timeline.

To answer nush781's question, it took him 6 months after CIC reviewed their application. We did not get any letter for follow up tests, I believe in your case there is some hope.

Submitting our application today, they basically stated the cost would be greater than $85K health and social combined. For social costs we are stating he would be living with us hence no special care or psychological cost incurred. For health, basically doctors letter and providing an action plan for the next 10 years.
 

carolbb23

VIP Member
Jun 24, 2016
3,564
406
toronto
Category........
FAM
Visa Office......
mississauga
App. Filed.......
15\12\2015
Doc's Request.
already did for applications
Nomination.....
n/a
AOR Received.
15/01/2016
IELTS Request
n/a
File Transfer...
10/03/2017
Med's Request
n/a
Med's Done....
02/11/2015
Interview........
thank god no interview
Passport Req..
n/a
VISA ISSUED...
28/04/2017
LANDED..........
28/04/2017
Thank you everyone for your response. We have a letter from doctor stating he has been maintaining his health with good diet exercise. On top of all this he does not drink or smoke. The doctor stated he would not have any issues for the next "couple of years". He did not state any specific timeline.

To answer nush781's question, it took him 6 months after CIC reviewed their application. We did not get any letter for follow up tests, I believe in your case there is some hope.

Submitting our application today, they basically stated the cost would be greater than $85K health and social combined. For social costs we are stating he would be living with us hence no special care or psychological cost incurred. For health, basically doctors letter and providing an action plan for the next 10 years.
Get note from specialist
 
  • Like
Reactions: mountain123

nush78l

Star Member
Jan 3, 2014
122
7
Thank you everyone for your response. We have a letter from doctor stating he has been maintaining his health with good diet exercise. On top of all this he does not drink or smoke. The doctor stated he would not have any issues for the next "couple of years". He did not state any specific timeline.

To answer nush781's question, it took him 6 months after CIC reviewed their application. We did not get any letter for follow up tests, I believe in your case there is some hope.

Submitting our application today, they basically stated the cost would be greater than $85K health and social combined. For social costs we are stating he would be living with us hence no special care or psychological cost incurred. For health, basically doctors letter and providing an action plan for the next 10 years.
Did CIC provide you with the $85K cost estimate? Any reasons given why there are social costs involved? My father was sent a medical furtherance letter to obtain an opinion from a kidney specialist (twice already). I am guessing you did not receive such a request?
 

carolbb23

VIP Member
Jun 24, 2016
3,564
406
toronto
Category........
FAM
Visa Office......
mississauga
App. Filed.......
15\12\2015
Doc's Request.
already did for applications
Nomination.....
n/a
AOR Received.
15/01/2016
IELTS Request
n/a
File Transfer...
10/03/2017
Med's Request
n/a
Med's Done....
02/11/2015
Interview........
thank god no interview
Passport Req..
n/a
VISA ISSUED...
28/04/2017
LANDED..........
28/04/2017
Did CIC provide you with the $85K cost estimate? Any reasons given why there are social costs involved? My father was sent a medical furtherance letter to obtain an opinion from a kidney specialist (twice already). I am guessing you did not receive such a request?
With ircc they do not want anyone to tie up the health care system
 

Rob_TO

VIP Member
Nov 7, 2012
11,427
1,551
Toronto
Category........
FAM
Visa Office......
Seoul, Korea
App. Filed.......
13-07-2012
AOR Received.
18-08-2012
File Transfer...
21-08-2012
Med's Done....
Sent with App
Passport Req..
N/R - Exempt
VISA ISSUED...
30-10-2012
LANDED..........
16-11-2012
Thank you everyone for your response. We have a letter from doctor stating he has been maintaining his health with good diet exercise. On top of all this he does not drink or smoke. The doctor stated he would not have any issues for the next "couple of years". He did not state any specific timeline.

To answer nush781's question, it took him 6 months after CIC reviewed their application. We did not get any letter for follow up tests, I believe in your case there is some hope.

Submitting our application today, they basically stated the cost would be greater than $85K health and social combined. For social costs we are stating he would be living with us hence no special care or psychological cost incurred. For health, basically doctors letter and providing an action plan for the next 10 years.
Here is some more info from IRCC in how they specifically screen for kidney issues: http://www.cic.gc.ca/english/department/partner/pp/pdf/IMEI_Renal_disease.pdf
 

nush78l

Star Member
Jan 3, 2014
122
7
CIC is effectively telling you that they are getting ready to refuse your application. That's what this letter means. Before they refused your application, they are giving you an opportunity to prove that your parent does not fall under excessive demand, meaning that the cost of their health care annually will be less than $6,500. So this is what you need to prove (i.e. that they will cost the health care system less than this amount per year). Saying you will cover these costs doesn't address the issue since everyone who is a PR qualifies for health care coverage.

What you want to do is submit evidence to show how much their current care will cost in Canada. You want to include letters from their current doctor confirming what treatment they are receiving at this time. You also want to look ahead 5-10 years and anticipate what their health condition will be then and the costs to the Canadian health care system. Once again, you'll want to support this with letters from health care professionals and also evidence of how much the treatments they will need will cost in Canada.

I'll be honest - I think you have your work cut out for you and this is going to be an uphill battle. Once someone is at stage 4, it's likely they will either need dialysis or a transplant. Both of these treatment options will exceed the excessive demand cap.

Good luck.
Hi Scylla,

My father also has CKD Stage 4 but unlike Mountain123's case my father has been sent for follow up tests with a nephrologist every 3 months since Oct 2016. So far his condition is stable and the specialist has provided a positive/stable outlook for the next 5 years.
My parents both have a 10 year multiple entry visitor's visa on hand. If my father is refused PR due to health grounds does that automatically mean he is no longer able to travel to Canada as a visitor? My parents would rather have the option to travel than never be able to visit Canada. So should i recall their PR application before it is refused? Appreciate any insight. Thanks!
 

omnishu

Star Member
Feb 21, 2016
60
3
Hi Scylla,

My father also has CKD Stage 4 but unlike Mountain123's case my father has been sent for follow up tests with a nephrologist every 3 months since Oct 2016. So far his condition is stable and the specialist has provided a positive/stable outlook for the next 5 years.
My parents both have a 10 year multiple entry visitor's visa on hand. If my father is refused PR due to health grounds does that automatically mean he is no longer able to travel to Canada as a visitor? My parents would rather have the option to travel than never be able to visit Canada. So should i recall their PR application before it is refused? Appreciate any insight. Thanks!
Hi, It would be helpful if you post your response on what happened ?
 

omnishu

Star Member
Feb 21, 2016
60
3
Did CIC provide you with the $85K cost estimate? Any reasons given why there are social costs involved? My father was sent a medical furtherance letter to obtain an opinion from a kidney specialist (twice already). I am guessing you did not receive such a request?
Hi, your response on what happened next, did you get through or not, would be really helpful for many.
 

omnishu

Star Member
Feb 21, 2016
60
3
Thank you everyone for your response. We have a letter from doctor stating he has been maintaining his health with good diet exercise. On top of all this he does not drink or smoke. The doctor stated he would not have any issues for the next "couple of years". He did not state any specific timeline.

To answer nush781's question, it took him 6 months after CIC reviewed their application. We did not get any letter for follow up tests, I believe in your case there is some hope.

Submitting our application today, they basically stated the cost would be greater than $85K health and social combined. For social costs we are stating he would be living with us hence no special care or psychological cost incurred. For health, basically doctors letter and providing an action plan for the next 10 years.
Hi @mountain123, I got to understand that the response that you gave was quite significanty thought at. Can you help providing the outcome of the application, we aspire to help people with same issues here in India, your response would be helpful and hopeful as well. Looking forward to your response.
 

jbhkaur

Hero Member
Aug 2, 2015
316
25
Thank you everyone for your response. We have a letter from doctor stating he has been maintaining his health with good diet exercise. On top of all this he does not drink or smoke. The doctor stated he would not have any issues for the next "couple of years". He did not state any specific timeline.

To answer nush781's question, it took him 6 months after CIC reviewed their application. We did not get any letter for follow up tests, I believe in your case there is some hope.

Submitting our application today, they basically stated the cost would be greater than $85K health and social combined. For social costs we are stating he would be living with us hence no special care or psychological cost incurred. For health, basically doctors letter and providing an action plan for the next 10 years.
Hi, what was outcome in your case. Please reply
 

scylla

VIP Member
Jun 8, 2010
95,950
22,190
Toronto
Category........
Visa Office......
Buffalo
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
App. Filed.......
28-05-2010
AOR Received.
19-08-2010
File Transfer...
28-06-2010
Passport Req..
01-10-2010
VISA ISSUED...
05-10-2010
LANDED..........
05-10-2010
Hello.
Please what was the outcome of your application? My spouse may have similar condìtion
If you are sponsoring your spouse under spousal sponsorship, they are exempt from excessive demand.
 

Ib4life

Full Member
Dec 16, 2018
41
5
I have applied for federal skilled workers programme for immigration. I am the principal applicant. My spouse has M5 in our GCM note. We are yet to hear from cic.we are not in Canada yet.I feel we might get PFL. How can I go about it.Since I am the principal applicant is my spouse free from excessive demand in Medical?