Has anyone got PR approved after disclosing stable Chronic Kidney Disease

[Peanuts-100]

Hi all,
Want your advice,i know CKD has been covered but not in this combination.
Our family planning to migrate to Canada hopefully but we are worried about my sis-in-law, she was diagnosed with Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown origin when she was 29years (now she is 36) and since the beginning has been in stage 3. Her creatinine levels are for the past years have been stable around 1.7-1.9 and uric acid levels are a high normal
Shes currently on one BP med and cery low dose of Steroids, other than that she is completely normal with no protein i. The urine or other complications and has not stopped working even during and after diagnosis. Both her and my brother are in the medical field and they are planning to migrate with her as the main applicant.
My question is is there any chance that she may actually pass her medical for PR??
B’coz her doctors here says she can go for a long time without dialysis or KT
Or some people are suggesting not to disclose as all her blood panels are normal and so is her BP, but she was saying that if she does that, after landing she may have problems when she has to go to a doctor or clinic there....i think she means after landing with PR it could be revoked?!
But she is apprehensive to do that way and at the same time worried if she does disclose she may get rejected

Please help us
Thank you

 

[canuck78]

Yes misrepresenting her health condition is a very bad idea and could have consequences after the fact. Her blood levels will show her medical problems so there is no point in hiding it. If this is your SIL I don’t understand what this has to do with your family’s immigration situation but kidney disease is one of the big concerns and she will almost 100% need dialysis and a transplant at a certain point. You should also be aware that unless they are nurses their is a surplus of pharmacists and dentists and doctors rarely get relicensed.

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/small-business/sb-growth/glut-of-dentists-causes-aches-in-canadas-big-cities/article36322773/ (Has gotten worse in the 3 years since the article)
https://www.reddit.com/r/pharmacy/comments/83g70s/canadian_pharmacists_how_saturated_is_the_market/ (If they are pharmacists)

 

[Peanuts-100]

Thank you for the advice,
We are 3 families applying at the same time
My 2 brothers and their family and my family.
Will show her this thread, as she doesn’t feel comfortable not disclosing it either, even though the normal blood tests will not show any abnormalities and her BP is well under control.
We are only apprehensive as we don’t want to leave her and her family behind.

Yes misrepresenting her health condition is a very bad idea and could have consequences after the fact. Her blood levels will show her medical problems so there is no point in hiding it. If this is your SIL I don’t understand what this has to do with your family’s immigration situation but kidney disease is one of the big concerns and she will almost 100% need dialysis and a transplant at a certain point. You should also be aware that unless they are nurses their is a surplus of pharmacists and dentists and doctors rarely get relicensed.

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/small-business/sb-growth/glut-of-dentists-causes-aches-in-canadas-big-cities/article36322773/ (Has gotten worse in the 3 years since the article)
https://www.reddit.com/r/pharmacy/comments/83g70s/canadian_pharmacists_how_saturated_is_the_market/ (If they are pharmacists)

Hi all,
Want your advice,i know CKD has been covered but not in this combination.
Our family planning to migrate to Canada hopefully but we are worried about my sis-in-law, she was diagnosed with Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown origin when she was 29years (now she is 36) and since the beginning has been in stage 3. Her creatinine levels are for the past years have been stable around 1.7-1.9 and uric acid levels are a high normal
Shes currently on one BP med and cery low dose of Steroids, other than that she is completely normal with no protein i. The urine or other complications and has not stopped working even during and after diagnosis. Both her and my brother are in the medical field and they are planning to migrate with her as the main applicant.
My question is is there any chance that she may actually pass her medical for PR??
B’coz her doctors here says she can go for a long time without dialysis or KT
Or some people are suggesting not to disclose as all her blood panels are normal and so is her BP, but she was saying that if she does that, after landing she may have problems when she has to go to a doctor or clinic there....i think she means after landing with PR it could be revoked?!
But she is apprehensive to do that way and at the same time worried if she does disclose she may get rejected

Please help us
Thank you

 

[canuck78]

Thank you for the advice,
We are 3 families applying at the same time
My 2 brothers and their family and my family.
Will show her this thread, as she doesn’t feel comfortable not disclosing it either, even though the normal blood tests will not show any abnormalities and her BP is well under control.
We are only apprehensive as we don’t want to leave her and her family behind.

They will measure her creatine levels and hers are high so yes it will show up. Kidney disease is one of the things Canada looks for because it is dialysis is extremely expensive and there tends to be a very high level of diabetes and kidney disease in South Asian communities. As I pointed out if they are in the medical field, except nursing, physiotherapy and a few others, there is a surplus of current professionals and salaries are going down or people are unemployed or working in other industries. If they are doctors they should consider UK, Australia, US, etc.

Would also point out that your parents are not guaranteed immigration to Canada so if all their children leave that could be a problem.

 

[vensak]

Good news for you is, that only the family where she belongs as a main applicant or dependant (spouse or a dependant child) will be affected. However with this diagnoses, chances to immigrate for her are almost 0.
And not disclosing it (since it is easily detectable in her blood samples) equals misinterpretation (the level they will find will point out how severe the situation is and if she could have survived properly without knowing about it).

 

[canuck78]

Good news for you is, that only the family where she belongs as a main applicant or dependant (spouse or a dependant child) will be affected. However with this diagnoses, chances to immigrate for her are almost 0.
And not disclosing it (since it is easily detectable in her blood samples) equals misinterpretation (the level they will find will point out how severe the situation is and if she could have survived properly without knowing about it).

Her chances are not zero and it would be misrepresentation whether it was easily detectable or not. People are obligated to disclose their medication conditions and medications they use during their physical.

 

[vensak]

Her chances are not zero and it would be misrepresentation whether it was easily detectable or not. People are obligated to disclose their medication conditions and medications they use during their physical.

Her chances are close to 0. Medical is a huge gray ground and depends on case to case bases.
What I was talking about is the next step. One thing is to discover something serious during those medical exams (that is before you have full blown symptoms or if they are pretending to be something much milder and other is to have all the symptoms and undergo treatment yet not tell it and let them find out.
First instance will be just normal PFL, medical inadmissibility and the second one will be misinterpretation on the top of it.

 

[canuck78]

Her chances are close to 0. Medical is a huge gray ground and depends on case to case bases.
What I was talking about is the next step. One thing is to discover something serious during those medical exams (that is before you have full blown symptoms or if they are pretending to be something much milder and other is to have all the symptoms and undergo treatment yet not tell it and let them find out.
First instance will be just normal PFL, medical inadmissibility and the second one will be misinterpretation on the top of it.

Agree it is misrepresentation and have mentioned this many time to this poster. I have also pointed out there is no point in misrepresenting because the blood panel is looking for kidney failure and will be picked up anyways. I would say the chances are 50/50. I have seen many others that shouldn’t have been approved that actually get approved.