+1(514) 937-9445 or Toll-free (Canada & US) +1 (888) 947-9445

730 days PR obligation not met, appeal instruction

Efgan

Star Member
Jan 28, 2017
62
4
Think you may be referring to cataract operations but those typically can also be secured earlier than 2 years depending on the location. For other eye issues, especially emergency ones, you can get a consult in the ED if a true emergency or be sent to a larger hospital and you should also be seen by an Opthamologist in a clinic within a few days. Don’t want people to worry that an eye emergency won’t be addressed relatively quickly.
Canada agrees thet the country has queue problem on medicine. If you were me, you may be became blind, and your health card expired, there queue in doctors. If you gave doctor in home countty that she knows processes in your eyes. Dhe dealed with your eyes more than 13 years Also on that time I had more than years to expire my PR card. What you choosed? I returned my home country, next day doctors operated my eyes, after 2 month I wanted to return Canada but doctors prohibited me to fly. It is beyond of my control situation
 

Efgan

Star Member
Jan 28, 2017
62
4
Think you may be referring to cataract operations but those typically can also be secured earlier than 2 years depending on the location. For other eye issues, especially emergency ones, you can get a consult in the ED if a true emergency or be sent to a larger hospital and you should also be seen by an Opthamologist in a clinic within a few days. Don’t want people to worry that an eye emergency won’t be addressed relatively quickly.
It is not cataract. Cataract may wait several months. It is critical operation. In the past when firs time my doctor find diagnost in my eye, they started my surgery immidiately. Not waited even a day. It happened several time non only once. Even in canada health vebsite mentioned that it is very serious problem. I wrote to health section, hospital. They replied that I should go to walk in clinic or my family doctor. I havent any family doctor, my health card expired.When I was in Canada my friend want to go aftolmogist, it took himm 4 months to get oppointment. I have seen it. May I wait? If you see this things, and there risk that you may ve blind, what you choose? Consider tvst earlier your one eye was blind and still it is not recovered fully. It is very easy to write that I should stay, to try, and etc, but is is not easy to risk to be blind
 

armoured

VIP Member
Feb 1, 2015
17,598
9,124
If you see this things, and there risk that you may ve blind, what you choose? Consider tvst earlier your one eye was blind and still it is not recovered fully. It is very easy to write that I should stay, to try, and etc, but is is not easy to risk to be blind
Two things:
-I think you are misinterpreting what people say.
-Please stop arguing with people here about what you and they think are good reasons or otherwise. You have your reasons; you're getting feedback from others. Not everyone is going to agree.

In my opinion: you need to focus on how to explain, briefly, factually, and without getting emotional or offended, your case to a CBSA officer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: canuck78

Naturgrl

VIP Member
Apr 5, 2020
45,505
9,741
It is not cataract. Cataract may wait several months. It is critical operation. In the past when firs time my doctor find diagnost in my eye, they started my surgery immidiately. Not waited even a day. It happened several time non only once. Even in canada health vebsite mentioned that it is very serious problem. I wrote to health section, hospital. They replied that I should go to walk in clinic or my family doctor. I havent any family doctor, my health card expired.When I was in Canada my friend want to go aftolmogist, it took himm 4 months to get oppointment. I have seen it. May I wait? If you see this things, and there risk that you may ve blind, what you choose? Consider tvst earlier your one eye was blind and still it is not recovered fully. It is very easy to write that I should stay, to try, and etc, but is is not easy to risk to be blind
You asked the same question almost a year ago. Rather than debating forum members get on a plane and return to Canada with your family members. Have your explanation ready if CBSA asked. Then don’t leave Canada until you meet RO to renew.
 

Efgan

Star Member
Jan 28, 2017
62
4
Two things:
-I think you are misinterpreting what people say.
-Please stop arguing with people here about what you and they think are good reasons or otherwise. You have your reasons; you're getting feedback from others. Not everyone is going to agree.

In my opinion: you need to focus on how to explain, briefly, factually, and without getting emotional or offended, your case to a CBSA officer.
May ve yes dear. I am focusing as you told. I will try all my best
 

Efgan

Star Member
Jan 28, 2017
62
4
You asked the same question almost a year ago. Rather than debating forum members get on a plane and return to Canada with your family members. Have your explanation ready if CBSA asked. Then don’t leave Canada until you meet RO to renew.
My dictor still not allowet to fly me. But she told me that the process on your eye is going to stabilize. That is why I started to find ways for H&C. Hope my doctor will allow me to fly soon.
 

Naturgrl

VIP Member
Apr 5, 2020
45,505
9,741
My dictor still not allowet to fly me. But she told me that the process on your eye is going to stabilize. That is why I started to find ways for H&C. Hope my doctor will allow me to fly soon.
Try and fly before PR card expires. Why can’t your son and spouse go to Canada now?
 

Efgan

Star Member
Jan 28, 2017
62
4
Try and fly before PR card expires. Why can’t your son and spouse go to Canada now?
My wife mother has knee problem and can not walk and care herself. My wife takes care for her. Nowadays we did knee surgery. Then they will be ready to go. The situation is very complex on my case. Before it my wife father and my mother got illness. They got different time this illnesses. My mother got cancer, and my father in law was Alzheimer and got covid. We cared about them. Unfortunately both of them passed off. It affected our budget, mental health also. In this situation we could not return to Canada. I hope we will return soon to Canada.
 

Ponga

VIP Member
Oct 22, 2013
10,466
1,500
Job Offer........
Pre-Assessed..
At least a couple of those reasons would not apply to a PR. For example:

[Medical not an issue if PR was obtained from a spousal sponsorship]


financial reasons – if you’re unable or unwilling to support yourself and your family members
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: robinhood_bakun