Yes, naturally when you immigrate you cant bring your immediate family members next year but why not after 10 years if I have paid taxes and never been unemployed? Why cant I have my parents live in the same country before they die?? Why not? Taxes I pay take care of elderly parents of Canadian Born citizens, and elderly parents of Immigrants who came here 20+ years ago. How come my taxes cant even bring my own parents in the same country I live?
parent grandparent pr program 2023 - intake form
- Thread starter harry gambhir
- Start date
We need to speak up, we need to advocate for ourselves. Before our parents are alive and they can still enjoy their time with us. We dont have to worry about stamping visas, inland extensions, visa refusal, etc. It's unfair.
Generally in US or Canada, parents are not considiered as part of an adult child's immediate family. Try claiming your parents to your work extended insurnace, or taking them to your work party that welcome "family" to join. That's a cultural difference that's not what IRCC alone is considering.
Canadian born citizens don't have a choice, they are in Canada (not all of them have parents in Canada, e.g. birth tourisim). Naturalized citizens have a choice, they choose to immigrate to a Canada. It's a major choice in ones life. I think 20 years ago, not as many people applied to bring their parents here. It's the number of application and the extremly long processing time for these applications that leaded to an attempt for solutions (e.g. limited applications first come first served with cut off, then lottery...etc)
not discouraging you to speak up. advocate for yourself and best wishes.
It is not unconsititutional and is not discrimination per Canada's laws. It's totally fair to feel this is discriminatory and unconsititutional. However this isn't supported by actual laws - i.e. there's no legal argument here.
I would disagree that people who came 20 years ago had no problems bringing their parents to Canada. Lots of them had big problems - just different ones than the problems being faced now. Back then there were no application caps and processing times consequently ended up reaching 9-15 years. Parents had trouble getting TRVs while they waited (there were no super visas back then) and there are many cases where parents passed away or became too ill to pass the medical before they ever made it close to getting approved for PR. IRCC then suddently closed the program and canceled thousands of applications which had been under process for many years (in some cases a decade). It was an absolute disaster of a situation. Again, different than the mess we have now. But a mess all the same.
I agree with this. By all means petition for change.
This is where an MP is the best route. There's no legal argument here so it has to be the politics route. Best opportunities are often just before an election.
IN US you CANNOT bring your parents? Says who? US Constitution considers immigrants parents as immediate family members and gives them right to sponsor them as soon as you are PR and have employment. US will never put parents in Lottery system as it's most unfair thing you can do to a human. Processing times are 6 months to 1 year. My friend immigrated in US 5 years ago her parents are both US PR as of today. I immigrated 10 + years ago in Canada and all I have done filing visa applications and playing lottery (unsuccessfully).
The US actually allows parents to be sponsored and there's no cap on sponsorship. The issue with sponsoring your parents to the US is health care. Parents are generally older when you sponsor them and getting health care insurance is extremely expensive and unaffordable for many. So it's not an immigration limitation. US immigration law 100% allows this. It's a health insurance coverage / health care expense limitation.
I did not know that and it's most unfair system anyone can imagine. I still think it's unconstitutional to give married people right to have family in Canada and be reunited with spouses and children and depriving the same family right to a single parson who's only family are her/his parents. Everyone under the law should have the right to a family without discrimination. My personal opinion.
Two technical correction. This is not covered in the US constitution. It's covered through US immigration laws.
Also, you cannot sponsor your parents as a US PR / green card holder. You can only sponsor them once you have US citizenship. PRs / green card holders are ineligible.
65+citizen parents have free healthcare in US. my friend's parents are 65+ who recently became PR they have everything free. Their children pay taxes so they have same rights as American born citizens' elderly parents.
This isn't really accurate. If you're interested, I can point you to a US immigration forum where the topic of insuring parents is discussed extensively.
Thanks for correction. Likely my friend got citizenship as her parents are both US permanent residents now.
I think all laws in US including immigration are in accordance with US Constitution. No bill can become a law if it violates US constitution.
Because taxes are set up as a user pay system . The taxes YOU pay , are for when YOU eventually will have to use the system , not your parents. It was NEVER guaranteed when you chose to immigrate that your parents would be able to come . Part of the research one must do when they elect to move , or stay in their country
No clue why you’re bringing up another countries immigration rules . It’s irrelevant
And let’s not forget the elephant in the room, how the voters perceive the program , emphasis on program. It’s not a “ law”. Programs can be modified or terminated
Last edited:
I person
So YOU are telling me that Canadian Born Citizens and Naturalized Citizens DO NOT HAVE the same rights under the law? We are NOT equal? If we are equal why I DO NOT have right my parents to live in the SAME COUNTRY I LIVE? My parents are IMMEDIATE FAMILY Members! If you can take care of YOUR parents when they are old WHY CANT I take care of them? Because I am naturalized citizen? Is that your logic? AND Trust ME Taxes Naturalized citizens pay and jobs we take DO contribute to this country's economy greatly that you and your parents benefit from it as well! No Immigration law or FORM ever said that I will NEVER be able to bring my parents in the country I am immigrating!
I did not see ANYWHERE ON THE FORM OR CIC WEBSITE A NOTE SAYING - Hey you Kate you will NEVER be able to bring your parents in this country!
"The taxes YOU pay, are for when YOU eventually will have to use the system , not your parents" - THIS IS WRONG! TAXES I PAY TODAY ARE GOING TOWARDS ALL THE PROGRAMS CANADIAN PEOPLE BENEFIT FROM INCLUDING THE ELDERLY PARENTS OF CANADIAN BORN CITIZENS!